Webinar

Don’t follow donations with silence: Create an email welcome journey

If you want to stop leaving money on the table, you need an email welcome journey... right now! (An email welcome journey is a series of messages sent to a supporter immediately after they take an action with you.) This is your golden opportunity to draw people into your story, validate their decision to become donors and turn them into loyal ambassadors for your cause. Stop greeting your donors with silence; keep them coming back forever!

‍During this session, we'll introduce you to the power of automated email welcome journeys and help you consider how they can accelerate your organization's fundraising strategy. We'll share the best practices on when you should trigger emails and what content you should include engaging with your donors in a meaningful way. You'll leave with ideas, inspiration, and an outline for your first welcome journey.

Transcript:

Kate Kramer: Hey, everybody. Welcome to our Thursday webinar.

I’m going to give it a few minutes and let all of our attendees get in the room before we get started. But in the meantime, please drop in the chat where you’re joining us from. I know I’m on the East Coast, so for me it’s one o’clock. But if you’re over on the West Coast or in the Central time zone, grab your lunch, join us, let us know.

Oh, yep, Seattle, Kansas, Arizona. Somebody said Virginia. Oh, Loudoun County. That’s very close to me. Wilmington, wow, we’ve got lots of people. That’s great. India? Oh, I love it.

Seems like people are still rolling in, but I do want to be courteous of time. So I’m going to at least go over a few housekeeping tips. This webinar is being recorded. Later today you’ll get this recording in an email. You’ll also get the slides. If you have questions throughout for Patty, please drop them in the little Q&A box in Zoom, and that way we’ll keep them and we’ll answer them all at the end.

Oh, we already have a question. Oh, nope.

If we have not met yet, I’m Kate Kramer. I’m the partner marketing manager at Bloomerang. If you don’t know what Bloomerang does, we are an online platform for all of your organization’s fundraising needs, donor management, volunteer management, email marketing. We would love to hear from you. We can drop a link in the chat to connect with us if you would like. And also at the end, you’ll have a chance to let us know if you would like to hear more from us.

But now, without further ado, I’m so pleased to introduce today’s presenter, Patty Breech with The Purpose Collective. Welcome, Patty.

Patty Breech: Thank you so much for having me. It’s great to be here. Let me see if I can share my screen. Alright.

So today, we are talking about the topic of email welcome journeys. And I’m really glad all of you guys are here. Thank you for giving up an hour in your busy schedules to join us. I hope this is going to be a really great and productive conversation for all of you. My goal is that you will have the start to your very own welcome journey by the end of this presentation.

So really quickly, by way of introduction, if you just want to throw your answers in the chat, I’d love to know what organization do you work for? What CRM, also known as a database, which CRM are you using? And what email program are you using? So if you’re a Bloomerang user or whatever it might be, go ahead and throw that in the chat.

Awesome. I see we’ve got Salesforce, Mailchimp, Neon, Bloomerang, Network for Good. Great. This is a wonderful, wonderful mix.

So by way of introduction, my name’s Patty. I’m the founder and CEO of The Purpose Collective. So we’re digital marketing consultants who work with nonprofits on their social media, their email, their websites. I used to work in a nonprofit myself, most recently, one that was based in Nepal. And so that organization was located thousands of miles away from their main donor supporters. So that meant that everything we put out on social media and email on the website, that was our only real touch point with the donors. They were never going to visit us in person. I mean, I learned a lot about how to do that successfully. And so now I run this consulting firm to help other nonprofits see a similar level of success.

Thank you guys so much for sending all this in the chat. This is great info. Okay. So I’m curious to know, have you ever set up an automated email welcome journey before? So in the chat, you can say A for yes, B for no, or C for what is a welcome journey.

Nice, mixed here. I’m glad to see a lot of people are being honest in saying C, what’s a welcome journey. Also, a fair amount of people who have done this before. Lots of A’s. And these are wonderful. This is great.

So let’s get started. For those of you who answered C, oh, by the way, Scott, it’s been on the agenda for a while. I feel that one. That’s what happened to me when I was at a nonprofit. We knew we should get a welcome journey in place, and then six months would go by. We still hadn’t done it. Another six months would go by. We hadn’t done it. So for today, I’m hoping I can help you jump start that process.

Okay. So what’s an email welcome journey? For those of you who are unfamiliar with the concept, quick introduction, it’s a series of emails sent directly after someone takes an action with you. Usually triggered automatically. So that might be when someone makes a donation to your organization, when they sign up for your email list, when they sign up to volunteer, when they register for an event, all of these actions can trigger a welcome series.

An email welcome journey has many names. Some people call it a nurture series. It’s also been called a drip campaign. There’s lots of different words for it. Usually, we’re all talking about the same thing. And the goal of a welcome journey is to provide a personalized, warm welcome to your supporters. To give them a little bit more information about your work so they’re further engaged. We want to validate their decision to support you, make them feel appreciated, draw them into your story. This is what an email welcome journey is designed to do.

Okay. So research shows that the best time to contact someone is in that window of time immediately after they take an action with you. So like I said, the donation, a sign up, people are really responsive to hearing from you in that time immediately following. And I wanted to examine this for a second. So why immediately, like, why are we saying that people should be contacted right away after they take an action with you?

Let’s use a real world example to explore this a little bit. So, I’d like you guys to picture a cute little restaurant. And you’re going to go here for dinner tonight. When you go to a new restaurant, what efforts did you usually take to come to this restaurant? You can throw some answers in the chat if you like. I know for me, I often heard about it from a friend. Someone said, oh, you have to try this place. It’s great. These are some great answers I’m seeing. Like, we maybe research restaurants on Google before we go to them, research them on Yelp, find the ones with a lot of reviews. Yeah. Maybe we looked at the menu. Maybe we were really craving a particular type of food and this restaurant serves it. Maybe we follow a foodie blog and someone was raving about this place. Maybe we were just out looking for a restaurant, and we walked past ten other places, but this one really caught our attention. This one looked like the best. TikTok is another great place to find restaurants.

So, yeah, usually, we put some effort into finding a restaurant. It’s usually not totally random. Maybe it’s all of these things that we’ve talked about.

So I want you to picture the first scenario. You walk into this restaurant and the staff greets you with a smile. They offer to take your coat. They ask if you’ve been in here before. Do you want to sit outside? Do you want to sit inside? They’re just generally very warm and welcoming. How do you feel in scenario number one? You can throw your answers in the chat for this one.

You feel good, comfortable, happy, engaged, welcomed, special. Yes. All of these things. These are great answers. Like, I made the right choice. Yeah. So that’s an important one. We feel validated if this is the response we get. Right? We’re like, I’m glad I did this. This was a good decision.

Now I want you to imagine a different scenario. You walk into this restaurant, and the staff kind of ignores you. It’s really hard to get their attention. They’re busy somewhere else and you’re left standing at the front of the restaurant for a few minutes. How would this make you feel?

Alright. Yeah. You might leave if this happened. You’d probably walk out. You’d feel like you were unimportant, feel anxious, neglected. Yeah. These are great answers. You’d probably second guess your decision to go here. Right? Like, I might be thinking, are they still open? Should I have made a reservation? Is there a private party happening here? Like should I not be here? Should I go somewhere else? So this is not a great feeling when this happens.

And this is something I want to point out about human nature. We all want to be welcome. We all want to be validated and appreciated for the decisions that we made. Whether we’re talking about a restaurant or even just, you know, an online activity that we took part in. So as nonprofits, when we follow donations with silence or with nothing more than that automated receipt that someone gets for an online gift, we are like the restaurant in scenario number two. So we are missing out on an opportunity to make someone feel validated about the choice that they made, to make them feel warmly welcomed and engaged. And instead, we run the risk of making them feel not welcome. Making them feel like maybe they shouldn’t have done that.

So that’s where welcome emails come in. This is our attempt to be more like that restaurant in scenario number one.

A few things I want to mention. Users who receive a welcome journey show thirty three percent more engagement with the brand that sent them the email. So this is a great way to get folks to feel more connected with you, more engaged with you. And I also just want to mention, the average nonprofit sees a donor retention rate of about forty to forty five percent. I’m not sure what it is for your organization specifically. But this means that more than half of the people who give to your organization are not going to give again. Right? So it’s hard to get people to come and keep coming back. And email welcome journeys can really help with this. You can help with that donor retention rate and help make sure that all the effort that you put into getting those donors is going to help keep them around for a long time.

Okay. Another quick poll here, do you know what your average email open and click rates are for your organization? If you do know, you can throw it in the chat if you want or you can just say, hey. Totally fine if you’re not sure.

Nice. We even had forty five percent. That’s great. Okay. Wonderful.

So the average email marketing campaign for the nonprofit industry sees an open rate of about twenty one percent. Those of you who are getting forty, fifty percent, well done. You don’t need [inaudible]. Right? And click rate is around two to three percent. So given this industry average, a welcome email is going to see an open rate of about fifty percent across the industry. That makes it twice as effective as a standard newsletter. For those of you getting eighty two percent open rates, well done, I don’t know if we can improve on eighty two percent, but what I have seen for all the clients that I have set these email journeys up for, I’ve seen at least double if not triple open rates for these messages. So you can see we set up a donation thank you series for a small nonprofit. Their average open rate was about fifteen percent for their regular email newsletters, and these emails saw a fifty one percent open rate. So you can see across the board, no matter what the organization’s open rate was, the welcome journeys they set up had much higher open rates, same with the click rates, click rates were really high for these. So this just goes to show that people want to receive these messages from you. They want to read them. They want to engage with them. And so we want to be contacting them when they want to hear from us.

Okay. Now I’ve hopefully convinced you of the value of a welcome journey, and I would like to get started helping you create a welcome journey for your organization right here and right now, mapping out what that would look like, what we’re going to do.

For the average welcome journey, whatever the trigger is, whatever action someone took with you, the structure that I usually recommend is to send about three to five messages. Starting immediately after the action and continuing for about four weeks later. I wouldn’t go much longer than that. And this is a really big one here. This welcome journey should always provide something of value to your supporters. So this is not an opportunity for you to talk about yourself. We want to give the reader something that they want, something they’ll enjoy, something that will entertain them, something that will help them even. At the very least, we just want to thank them profusely, shower them with gratitude so that they feel good about their decision. So we want to be really careful to make sure that we’re not using this opportunity to make this about ourselves and what we do here at this organization and how great we are. This is about the donor, the supporter.

Okay. So the journey that we’re going to map out today is going to be a five part donor journey, meaning someone makes a donation to your organization, and this five part email series is triggered. There are lots of other types of welcome journeys that you could create. Some popular ones include a welcome email for when people join your email list or for when they sign up to volunteer with you. Or when they register to attend an event with you. But I would say it’s good to prioritize the donor journey first. This is a really engaged and really important audience. And your time is limited. And if you can’t create a hundred journeys all at once, let’s just start with this one. The donor welcome journey. And I would recommend sending this to anyone who makes a donation, either a new or a returning donor. Send them this five part series. We want everyone to only get it once, but we do want everyone to receive it.

Okay. So how we will structure this. We want to send a plain text gratitude message as close to immediately as possible. So zero to twenty four hours later. I say twenty four hours later because I know that some of you might have programs that require an overnight sync in order to get your donor information to your email program. That’s totally fine if it comes a day later instead of an hour later. But if you can get it close to immediate, that would be preferred.

The second email we want to send is the story of impact. So we want to tell a story about how our supporters’ donation is making a really big difference in the world. And this will come one to three days later, and the timing is after the date of the gift. So gift happens, zero to twenty four hours, then your email number one, one to three days after the gift. They get this email.

The third email we want to send, yes, these are all emails that we are sending. So third email is a request to take an action with your organization. We’re going to send this one a week later. So this might be something like, come volunteer with us, sign our petition, whatever it might be.

We’re going to tell another story in email number four. This is going to come two weeks later.

And then the fifth and final email that we’ll send in our donor series is a request to become a monthly donor. So this will come three to four weeks after their donation came in. It’s really important that we’re able to segment our donor journey, we don’t want to ask anyone to become a monthly donor if they already are one. So we want to make sure all of our monthly donors are labeled as such so we can exclude them from this step of the journey.

Okay. A few more details here. The trigger for this is a new one time donation is made. If you want, you can include new monthly recurring donors in this as well. Again, we just want to make sure they’re excluded from that fifth email. And the goals of this journey, first and foremost, we want to express gratitude. So we want people to feel that we are super grateful for them. We want to thank them profusely. We want to validate their decision to give, and we want to draw them more fully into the story of the organization. So we want them to feel like the work that we’re doing is super important, and they have a role in it, and they’re a needed part of it. And, lastly, we want to convert them to a monthly donor if they are not already one.

So I see there’s a question about what do you recommend as the final email if someone is already a monthly donor? I’d say send them four emails, not five. You don’t need to replace the fifth email with something different. Just skip it for them.

Okay. So the first email, if you want, you can pull out a piece of paper, pull up a Word document, take notes as we go. Think about how you would structure this for your organization. So the first email is going to be a plain text gratitude message from the founder or the executive director. I say that because we want this email to come from someone who’s recognizable. So think about who that might be for your organization. And like I said before, the timing is as close to immediately as possible, but it’s okay if it’s up to one day later.

Here’s an example of what this looks like at an organization. So this is from the founder and CEO. Super simple email. You know that there’s no photos in here. There’s no fancy HTML elements. And it’s personalized. It says, hi, Patty. Every week I get notifications of any donations that come in, and I stop and quietly breathe a sigh of relief. We got this. We can do this, I think to myself. So this is saying, you know, the work that I do is really hard, and it means a lot to me when I see a donation come in. There’s a lot of ups and downs. So thank you. When you give, it directly transforms the lives of our children here. It enables this work we do, and it transforms this community from the ground up. Thank you so, so much for your generosity.

If you find this compelling, go ahead and put a plus one in the chat. So if you gave a donation to this organization, and you got this email in response, let me know if you feel like this was... I’m seeing a lot of plus ones. Awesome. Yeah, this feels really genuine, really heartfelt, and it’s really simple. It’s just saying thank you. It means a lot.

Here’s another example from another organization. This one, again, super short, super simple. It’s from their executive director. The personality of this organization is a little bit more goofy. They work with young adults, and their personality is just fun, and they like to play games, they like to sing songs. And so this message is designed to capture the personality of their executive director. So the title is “Patty, You Rock.” And then it says, you’re great. You crushed it. Pat yourself on the back today. So these messages should sound true to you and who you are and who your organization is. It should sound like a person wrote it. You want to avoid any dry, professional language here. And it’s okay if it’s nice and short, like this one.

Here is another email I want to highlight. So this is from an animal sanctuary. And the interesting thing about this is that the executive director, when he set up his email welcome journeys, he decided he wanted to thank people retroactively. So he went, like, six months back and sent this email to people who had donated in the previous six months. And what I love about this is what he says in the second paragraph here. So he starts off by saying, I saw you made a donation. I wanted to say thank you. You’re making a world of difference. And then he said, I’m sorry that you haven’t heard from me sooner. To be honest, I feel like I haven’t stopped moving. I’ve been so busy. Things are so crazy. So I like that he succinctly owned that this thank you is coming a little bit late. So he’s being a bit vulnerable with his audience, being pretty real with them and saying, I know you should have heard from me by now. And you didn’t and I’m sorry. But I’m still really grateful for you. I think you’re amazing. So just another example of how we want these messages to feel genuine.

One last example here, I made a gift to this organization on Giving Tuesday. I had given to them before. And I got this really short and sweet message saying, just wanted to thank you for your continued support. So there was acknowledgement that I was a returning donor for them. To this day, I don’t actually know if this email was automated. It looks like this person sat down and wrote to me personally on that day. So if they did automate it, they fooled me. I felt like I got personally thanked. That’s another nice thing about the plain text email, it feels really personal.

Okay. So to review, for this first email, I recommend writing it from the first person. And keep it you focused. So we’re thanking you, the donor, for your support, you’re wonderful. We appreciate you. We want to make sure that it feels personal, vulnerable, meaningful, authentic, and gratitude is the goal. So we’re not asking them for anything in this email. We’re just saying thank you. And if it’s possible, we want this to be a true plain text email. So no fancy HTML elements, strip out as much formatting as you can. I’ve found Mailchimp in my experience is the best at sending a true plain text email, some of the other platforms come close, close enough. So the more basic this can be the better.

Okay. Now for you, I want you guys to think who should your plain text gratitude message come from? Is it your founder? Is it your executive director? Do you have another spokesperson for the organization? If you feel like sharing your answers to these questions in the chat you can. That could be helpful for us to see how other organizations are thinking about this. You don’t have to, though, this is mainly for you to think about. And then I want you to think about, what is your organization’s tone? Are you in that, like, fun, upbeat, goofy kind of language? Are you more warm and nurturing? Are you more straightforward and down to earth? What feels right to you? Think about what tone feels the most authentic for you.

I like that someone who’s already said fun and weird feels good for them. I love getting fun and weird emails, so keep it up.

Okay. The second email in our donor welcome series, I recommend telling a story of impact. And the timing of this is going to be one to three days after the donation. So I want to emphasize here that as human beings, our brains are really not wired for statistics. So when we hear things like three hundred and fifty thousand people a year are diagnosed with this disease, and we’ve seen progress treating it with this medication that shows a twenty to thirty percent improvement, all of those numbers go in one ear and out the other. And that can be hard for us to really feel the impact of statistics. What is much more impactful for us is one person’s story. So if you can find one individual to tell a first person narrative about how their life was changed or how they volunteered with you and witnessed change. Or how you worked on something to create change. Those first person narratives are really going to stick with us. We’re going to want to read every word. We want to know what happens next.

So here’s an example from an organization. The one that works with young adults who’ve had serious illnesses. This is from a participant in the program who is talking about how difficult it was when she got a cancer diagnosis. She felt like her identity had split in two. She felt lonely and isolated, and then she found this organization and participated in a program. One of the important programs made possible by generous donors like you, and she was able to change her life. She was able to get a new perspective. So we’re hearing about her story from the first person, but it’s still using donor centric language. So she’s still addressing you as the donor to say thank you for being a part of this. Thank you for your support. You’ve made the world a better place. You’ve changed lives. This is the type of email that really helps people feel like their donation mattered. That’s the goal.

Here’s another organization, an animal sanctuary again. So they are telling the story of one of their donkeys saying, we had a donkey who showed up who was dying of starvation and malnourishment. We didn’t know if he was going to make it. We rushed him to the hospital. This type of story, by the way, people are going to read it start to finish. They want to know what happens next. This donkey made a miraculous recovery. Thanks to donors like you. Your support of our organization allows us to make these wonderful stories come true. So this is another example of how to tell that really great story of impact.

One more from an organization that helps children at the border who’ve been separated from their parents. Here’s this wonderfully heartwarming story from a mother who’s saying thank you so much for what you did for my family. Your support of this organization allowed me to be reunited with my child. It was this terrible experience. Thanks to you, it has a happy ending. And so we want to make sure, by the way, that we’re always portraying our community members in an empowering light. And that’s what these emails are designed to do.

Okay. So in summary, the second story of impact email, use a first person narrative if you can. They’re really powerful. And most importantly, tell a really, really good story. So something that’s heartwarming or sweet or emotional. What story would you tell if you were at a dinner party and you were trying to impress everyone there with how important your work is? Tell that story. And remember, we still want to stay you focused. This is not about us, this is about our donors, and how important they are to the work that we’re doing. The donor is the hero.

Okay. So now to think... Oh, sorry. This is really important. I want to mention. While we’re telling these stories, we want to make sure that we’re using conversational language. We want to write the way we talk. So this is not a grant application. We don’t need to throw in lots of big fancy words. It doesn’t need to be professional sounding. In fact, it should be at about a sixth grade reading level. So that’s super basic language that we’re going to be using. Bloomerang has this wonderful donor communication tool. It’s totally free. The link is right here. You can paste any amount of text into this tool, and it will tell you what your reading level is. So I have put text into this tool from some organizations’ communications. It’s come back at, like, a fourteenth grade reading level, which is basically off the chart, language is way too complicated. So if that’s you guys, use this tool to help you kind of simplify it, see if you can tweak some wording around and get it down to a lower reading level. Another thing this tool will tell you is how many times you use the word you versus the word we. So again, as I’ve been saying, we want to use all this you focused language. This tool will help tell you how well you’re doing towards that goal.

Taylor, I love what you say about you banned the word initiative from your style guide. If I could ban the word infrastructure from nonprofit communications, I would do it.

Alright. So thinking about your organization, what amazing story can you tell about your organization’s work? So take a moment to jot down some thoughts for yourself. If you want to share them in the chat to help your fellow nonprofit professionals feel free. But really, take a note, what comes to mind when you think about a story of impact?

Okay. Email number three. This is where we’re going to make an engagement request. And so by this, I mean, we’re going to ask our supporters to take another action with us. It might be completing a survey, signing a petition, maybe it’s just sharing a photo on social media to help us raise awareness, maybe you want to invite them to an event, maybe we want them to volunteer with us. Whatever it is, it’s basically saying, we like you and we want to keep hanging out with you. Do you want to do one of these things with us? And most importantly, we are not asking for a donation. So the timing of this is one week after they just gave to us. So this is a little too soon to ask them to give again. We’re going to avoid that.

Alright. Let’s take a look at this in action. So here’s an example from the organization that basically says I have more information for you at the bottom of this email. But if you have time to reply and say hi, please do. I’d love to hear from you. Please give me a little grace time in responding, but I will read every email. So this is a really simple engagement request. It’s just saying, will you write back? Will you tell us who you are, will you tell us why this work holds a special place in your heart, you could add other questions based on what your organization is, you know, for the organization that I used to work for that was in Nepal, a question that could be asked is have you ever been to that part of the world? You’ve been to Nepal, so we’d love to hear about your experience. Things like that.

Back to the animal sanctuary. So the route they took was to ask people to post on social media for them. So they provided an image, they provided a caption, and they said, we feel like this is a really important issue, the donkeys that we work with, they’re under threat globally. And if you could share this graphic, you would really be helping us spread the word about how important this work is. So that’s an option.

Another organization said, what’s your story? You know? Here at our organization, we believe everyone’s story is important, and that includes you. So we want to know you. Who are you? What would you like to tell us about yourself? Why is this work important to you? So they included a link to a really quick survey. I think there’s something about five or six questions on it. Super simple. Another way to draw people further in.

Okay. So in review for this email number three, we want to be warm and inviting, and our goal here is to become better friends with our supporters. We want to get to know them. We want to hang out with them. And basically, we should think of this as an invitation into our inner circle. We’re saying, yes, you donated. Let’s keep a good thing going. What else would you like to do with us?

So I’m curious to know, what action can you invite your donors to take for your organization? Do you have volunteer opportunities? Do you have, like, an annual event that you want to invite people to come to? Do you ever do petitions? Would you ever want people to write to their elected representative on your behalf? What else? What can we think of? Being a mentor to our students, that’s a really good one. Asking people to share on social media, upcoming events, yep. These are great. Yes. Totally okay to ask them to complete a one to two question survey. Oh, inviting people for a tour. I like that one. Oh, museums that need volunteers, this is great. So there is a question about whether this is a good opportunity to ask people to join your email list. You should already have permission to be emailing them if you’re sending them this journey. So we never want to email people who have not actively opted in to receiving communications from us. So that should ideally happen at the time of the donation. There would be a box that they could check that would say, yes, I want to hear from you. Please go ahead and add me to your list. Oh, this is another good one. You could ask people to donate a bike that they’re not riding. This is great. Love all this.

Okay. That was email number three. Going to email number four. This is going to be another storytelling email. I really cannot overemphasize the importance of storytelling. We love stories. Stories are powerful. Stories draw people in. This is going to come about two weeks after the donation.

Here’s an example from the organization that works with young adults. It’s another first person narrative talking about what it was like to be diagnosed with a cancerous brain tumor. There’s a clear before and after here. You know? I felt like I didn’t have a voice. I felt like my music career was over, and then I found this program. Now my life has been transformed. Thank you so much for making transformations like mine possible.

Another example here, I love this email because it starts off by saying, I want to tell you a story. This is a really good hook for people. I want to tell you a story about a five year old boy from Guatemala. We can’t help but keep reading. We want to know what happened, and it’s a really impactful story about how this boy was basically suffering from a skull fracture, and he made a miraculous turnaround, and he’s doing great now in kindergarten. Very heartwarming story, shows the urgency and the importance of this work.

This is another organization that chose to use, they work with students, so they chose to highlight one of their students who basically said, I’ve always wanted to go to college, and thanks to your support, I have the opportunity to do that. And this is another really wonderful heartwarming story. As a donor, you can’t help but read something like this and think it really matters that they gave to this organization. And again, this first person narrative is going to be a lot more powerful than statistics. You know, if this organization were to say, we have a ninety two percent graduation rate and eighty seven percent of our graduates go on to higher education, that doesn’t really pull us in as much as hearing the story of one person. And his dreams and his hopes and his story.

Okay. Elements of email number four, still a first person narrative. Still aiming to start up emotions. A lot of this is going to be similar to email number two. It’s still you focused. And I want you guys to think again what’s another sweet, heartwarming, amazing story that you can tell about your organization. Is it going to be from a community member that you serve? Is it going to be an experience from a volunteer? Is it your origin story? Do you want to have your founder talk about why the organization was started in the first place?

I see there’s a question about who is going to write these first person stories, the organization or the impacted person. Either way, if you as the organization write this story, you want to get approval from whoever’s name you’re putting on it. Usually, that’s the method that we do, we would write the email ourselves and then run it past the person and say, can you please edit this to make it sound more like you? Can you make sure we got everything right here? That’s just a way to be respectful of people’s time, but we want to make sure that we are being accurate. And there is no call to action in these emails. We’re still just thanking people and making them feel good about their decision.

Okay. Email number five. Now there is a call to action in this email. So we’re going to make a request that our donor becomes a monthly donor. Again, assuming they’re not already monthly giving. So we want to do this carefully. So this is going to come about three to four weeks after their donation. And we want to make sure that we’re acknowledging that we know they already gave. We know they already gave recently. And it’s because they gave recently that we feel like they’d be a good fit for our monthly giving program. So we don’t want to make it seem like we’re not paying attention in asking them to give money even though they just did. We want to very specifically call that out.

So let me show you an example. There’s an action. The animal sanctuary again. The start of this email says, you recently made a generous decision to help rescue donkeys recover from past abuse and live the rest of their lives in a happy home. We’re still thinking about how compassionate you are. So this email starts off by saying, you recently gave. We love that you recently gave. It’s so generous that you recently gave to us. And then it goes on to say, would you like to make a bigger impact by donating monthly? You can join this monthly giving program. It’s called the Guardians, and it’s great because it ensures that all of our animals have all the medicine and the food and the care that they need. So you can be the hero for our donkeys. What do you think? Does it sound like a good fit for you? So notice that this language is really, really emphasizing their previous behavior. It’s not just out of the blue, give monthly.

Here is another example from another organization. This is another plain text email. No photos, no HTML buttons in this one. And it says, last month, you made a generous donation to support our family in Nepal. We’re still thinking about you and how big your heart is. Then it goes on to say, you know, I’ve got to be honest with you, this work is hard. There’s highs and lows to it every day. One thing that really helps to make sure we can continue this super important, life changing work is monthly donors. Would you like to become one? We think you might be a good fit for it. So super personal. What your donors want most is to be seen. They want to feel like you remember them, you know them. We don’t want to make it sound like they just got thrown on to a list, one size fits all. We’re just asking for money. We don’t care about who you are. We’re being very conscientious here.

Okay. So in summary, for email number five, we’re going to start with gratitude again. Thank you for your recent gift. We’re going to show the donor that we know exactly who they are. We remember their last gift. And we’re going to make a case for their support. So we’re not just saying, oh, do you want to give monthly? That’d be cool if you could sign up to give us more money, that’d be great. We’re making a case for it. We’re saying here are the lives that would be impacted if you could give monthly. Here is the difference that you can make in the world. So that’s what I want to challenge you guys to think about right now. How will you ask your donors to change the world with you? What is the case that you can make for their monthly support? If you can write down some ideas for this, again, if you want to share your thoughts in the chat, I think it’s always helpful to see what other people are thinking. But what is the case for why donors should sign up monthly to change the world with you?

Okay. I want to make sure we have enough time for questions. So really quickly in summary, here is the five email structure that I recommend for a donor journey. And you will all get these slides afterwards. So don’t worry if you’re trying to furiously write all this down.

A few tips I want to mention. If this feels like a lot to you, just start with three emails or one. Just start with a few. Get it going with a plain text gratitude email, and a story of impact, and an invitation to volunteer. And then, you know, maybe come back and do email four and five later when you have more time. You can always add on to this journey later.

Another tip I want to mention is I really advise that you segment your list. So if someone is receiving the donor welcome journey, we want to make sure they are not getting anything else from you. They’re not on your regular email newsletter list. They’re just getting the journey. These journeys are triggered on their own schedule, they go out whenever a donation comes in. And so we want to make sure that they’re not, like, getting a donor journey email and then two hours later they’re getting your email newsletter that went out to the entire list. That can sort of feel like email overload to some people. So if you can, segment them out.

And my last tip here, if you want to see these in action, the organizations that I used as examples in this presentation, here’s a link to each of them. You can sign up for their email list, see the series that you get as a result there. You can donate to them if you like, see the series that comes as a result of that. And, yeah, let’s go to the question section.

Kate Kramer: Oh, sorry, my unmute button wouldn’t work. Thanks so much, Patty. Hey, before we pop into the question section now, I would really like to put up a poll. If you guys would like to learn more from Patty, you can indicate this. Or if you’d like to learn more from Bloomerang, a lot of what Patty talked about, we have the ability to help you with. In fact, we also have an ebook that I’m going to drop into the chat about segmentation. Where’s the chat? There we go. That you guys can access as well.

Okay. Let’s see here. We have a lot of questions, a whole lot. Somebody said can this be set up in Bloomerang? Yes, let us know you want to hear from us. We can help you with that.

Would this email journey be the same for a person who donates to an event such as a walk or would you treat them differently?

Patty Breech: That’s a good question. I would say in a perfect world, I’d treat them differently. So if they’re donating to a walk, they might not be as familiar with your organization. They’re probably more familiar with the athlete, the person doing the walking.

Kate Kramer: Mhmm.

Patty Breech: And so I would want to send them emails, but I’d want to acknowledge that and say, like, hey, you might not know who we are. We just want to take a minute to tell you. That’s in a perfect world. If you don’t have time to create a journey specifically for your walk event, then go ahead and send them the regular donor journey. That’s what I would say.

Kate Kramer: Would you send these to new donors who gave in memory gifts or would you remove those?

Patty Breech: I would send it to new donors who gave a memorial gift, yes.

Kate Kramer: I don’t understand segmenting them out. Can you explain that?

Patty Breech: Yeah. So, basically, this is just the idea that you’re probably sending regular email communication to your general list, like a monthly newsletter, or a solicitation for a fundraiser. If somebody just gave to your organization, I think they should only receive the donor welcome series for the next four weeks, and they should not get any other communication. So if there’s a way for you to make sure that they are labeled as someone who’s on a journey so that you can exclude them from whatever those regular newsletters are or solicitation emails are, I think that’s the best way to go because it shows that you’re paying attention to who they are and what they’ve done with your organization, and you’re not just randomly throwing them into the mix with everybody else.

Kate Kramer: Awesome. Next, do people get annoyed with all of the emails?

Patty Breech: That is a good question. I mean, we saw the statistics on these emails at the beginning of the presentation. In my experience, no. They’re not getting annoyed. They love these emails. They’re opening them. They’re clicking on them. They’re engaging with them. They’re consuming them. There will be some people who don’t want to hear from you this much, and they’ll unsubscribe, and that’s okay. I think unsubscribes are good. It helps to keep your list clean. You only want to be emailing people who want to hear from you, and the people who don’t want to hear from you, they’ll let you know.

Kate Kramer: If someone makes a donation, for example online, would you send a receipt automatically and then the first welcome message be separate?

Patty Breech: Yes. Yeah. I think the receipt should be separate from this email. The receipt is a great thing. You always want that to go out, super helpful for tax purposes, your EIN number in there. This is meant to be on top of that, meant to feel personal.

Kate Kramer: Can the emails come from more than one person?

Patty Breech: Absolutely. Yeah. You could change the sender name on each email every time.

Kate Kramer: Should donors in an email welcome journey be suppressed from other email communications during that time?

Patty Breech: Yes. That’s what we just talked about with the segmentation.

Kate Kramer: Do you recommend that these are sent from the organization’s email or a staff members'?

Patty Breech: So this is going to depend on your specific audience. I have found that when an email shows up from a person’s name, it’s more likely to be opened than if it shows up from an organization’s name. You can always put both if you’re more comfortable with that. So you could say this is from Patty Breech at The Purpose Collective, but I would play around with it, with your audience and see which type of sender name gets a better open rate.

Kate Kramer: Alright. As a member based organization, should our welcome series be different for new members versus donors? We currently do separate them into different email workflows with different messaging.

Patty Breech: Yes. I believe you should have a journey, a specific journey, for every possible action someone could take with you. So if you can have a journey for a brand new one time donor versus a returning one time donor versus a new monthly donor, that would be great. And so if I’m not sure exactly how your membership works, but if someone becomes a member, we want to speak specifically to that action and say we’re so glad you just became a member. Of course, we don’t all have time to create three, four, five, six, seven journeys. So I would say, you know, sometimes it’s okay if you just have one that you use for both membership and donations based on your time and your ability level. Maybe you start with one for both of those and you set a goal of six months from now, we’re going to create a membership specific one.

Kate Kramer: Awesome. How long of a narrative should you ask for from clients?

Patty Breech: If this would be, like, for the storytelling email, I think that depends on the story. I do think that when it’s a first person narrative, people are more willing to read a longer email. It just depends on, like, are you able to really draw them in? Do they want to know what happens next? But we do need to be careful about droning on a little bit too long because I think then we run the risk of now we’re in the territory of talking about ourselves a lot. I want to make sure that we’re still keeping it focused on how is this relevant to you as our supporter and is this valuable to you, our supporter.

Kate Kramer: Alright. So, we have so many questions. What if the level of engagement grows at email four, then we start them on a new five email series?

Patty Breech: Totally understand that question. I’m not sure I do what you... Okay. What, if someone donates, we start on a journey, they up their level of engagement. What would be the next step in that scenario? I mean, ideally, they are more engaged with you now and the next step is they’re going to come to your event. They’re going to volunteer with you. They’re going to take a tour. They’re going to feel more connected to you. You could keep creating more journeys for these things. You know, you could have a volunteer journey. You’d have a post tour journey. Just try to keep that engagement going.

Kate Kramer: Can you please explain the click rate?

Patty Breech: The definition of the click rate is how many people click a link in your email. It’s traditionally very low. So it’s a lot more likely that you’re going to get someone to open an email than it is for you to get them to click on a link within an email. And, actually, this brings me up to a question I saw in the chat about including videos in emails. There is no way to get a video to autoplay from within an email. So in order to get someone to watch a video, you’d need for them to click on it and watch it in another platform. And because click rates are so low, I mean, a high click rate would be five, ten percent. So keep in mind if you include a video, you’re looking at less than ten percent of people actually watching it. So I think it’s better to include what you want them to see in the email itself.

Kate Kramer: Should you ask for a specific amount toward monthly giving, like a percentage of their previous donation?

Patty Breech: You could. My rule of thumb for monthly donations is to ask for a really small amount. Like, say, even just five dollars a month can make a difference. People will tend to give more than five dollars a month, but five dollars a month sounds so easy and so doable that they’ll sign up for it. If you want to try to get into, like, asking for a percentage of their previous gift, that’s going to be pretty sophisticated. And one of the things about these journeys is I want them to be set it and forget it. I want you to set it up once. It’s automated from here on out, and you don’t have to go and manually tweak anything or think about it other than once a year, once every six months. And so if you’re trying to get, like, a percentage of their gift in there, that’s going to be hard to calculate automatically. And so I might just skip it for that reason.

Kate Kramer: Okay. When should they begin to receive the regular e-newsletter?

Patty Breech: After they finish the journey. So whether your journey is three emails long or five emails long, after they get that last one, go ahead and put them on the regular list.

Kate Kramer: We have a lot of older donors who do not have email addresses. Do you suggest making a print or mailable version of this system?

Patty Breech: Yes, I do. I don’t think it needs to be five things that you mail, but I think one heartfelt message of gratitude, whether it’s handwritten or it’s a postcard with a heartwarming photo on the front. I think that can be really impactful for the donors who you don’t have email addresses for.

Kate Kramer: For segmenting, how do you recommend making sure everyone gets the email without over emailing, like current people in our email list that have not yet gotten the welcome?

Patty Breech: Wait, sorry. I’m not sure I understand that question.

Kate Kramer: How do you make sure that everyone gets the email without over emailing, segmenting?

Patty Breech: I hope I’m understanding this question correctly. You want to make sure that... So this goes back to the, like, over emailing. If you can label someone as, like, this is very easy to do in Mailchimp. You set up an automated journey, you can tag them at the beginning of the journey and then say, this person is actively receiving a journey, and that tag stays with them until the end of the journey where you would remove it. Then every time you create a newsletter, you’d say exclude everyone who has the tag “actively receiving a journey.” And, also, we want to tag them, mark them in some way to say this person has completed the journey so that we’re not sending it to them a second time. That would be another way to avoid over emailing them.

Kate Kramer: Once the welcome journey is over, how frequently should you stay in contact if they do not become a monthly donor?

Patty Breech: I would recommend once a month, whatever your regular cadence is for your email communications.

Kate Kramer: Awesome. And we’re running out of time, so I’m trying to scroll through the questions.

Patty Breech: Yeah. I do want to quickly mention, my organization offers free office hours. If there’s a question you have that we didn’t get a chance to address today, I’d be happy to go over it with you then. I know a lot of people were asking how do you set this up in various platforms. That’s a whole other webinar to talk about how that works. And so I’d be happy to talk to you about it one on one.

Kate Kramer: Wonderful. Well, Patty, thank you so much. Her contact information is up, so please jot that down. I think it will also be included in the email we’ll send out with the recording. But we appreciate your time today, and thank you everyone for being here.

Patty Breech: Thank you so much.

Kate Kramer: Bye bye.

Key takeaways:

  • A donor email welcome journey keeps you from following gifts with silence. Patty compares an automated receipt alone to being ignored at a restaurant door. She says welcome journeys see open rates around 50%, versus about 21% for a standard nonprofit newsletter, and that the average nonprofit retains only about 40 to 45% of its donors.
  • Use a five-email structure over about four weeks. Start with a plain-text thank-you within 24 hours, then a story of impact, an engagement request, a second story, and finally a monthly giving ask. Existing monthly donors skip the fifth email, and you can start with just three emails if five feels like too much.
  • Keep every email donor-focused, personal, and conversational. The emails should come from a recognizable person, use first-person stories instead of statistics, and be written at about a sixth-grade reading level. Patty recommends using “you” at least twice as often as “we.”
  • Segment donors so they only get the journey, then add them to your regular list. Tag donors as actively receiving a journey, exclude them from newsletters and appeals until it finishes, and keep the receipt separate from the welcome email.
Helping you help others

Every act of generosity starts here.

Empower your team to connect deeply and fundraise confidently.