Webinar

Best practices on engaging and keeping your monthly donors

In this webinar, Erica Waasdorp will show you how to cultivate and recognize monthly donors — and how best to steward them.

Learning objectives:

  • Build a same-week outreach sequence for failed payments: an email the same day, and a letter and a call within 48 hours.
  • Track which donors called to cancel and which simply stopped paying, so each group gets the right follow-up.
  • Use a link to an update page, a courtesy call script and a credit card updater to win back lapsed monthly donors.
  • Plan an upgrade ask that thanks donors first and offers a few amounts they can choose from.

Transcript:

Steven Shattuck: Okay, Erica, is it okay if I go ahead and get this party started?

Erica Waasdorp: Yep.

Steven Shattuck: Awesome. Good afternoon, everyone, or good morning if you're on the East Coast or the West Coast, I should say. Thanks for being here for today's Bloomerang webinar, "Best Practices on Engaging and Keeping Your Monthly Donors." I'm Steven from Bloomerang, and I'll be moderating today's discussion as always. Thanks for being here.

Just a couple of housekeeping items. We're recording this session, and we'll send the recording and the slides later on. If you get interrupted, if you're at home, like me, and a kid runs in and you miss a nugget from Erica, don't worry. We'll get all that to you this afternoon. I'll email it to you.

Most importantly, please chat in any questions or comments you have throughout the hour. We're going to try to save some time at the end for Q&A, so don't be shy. We'd love to answer questions live, as many as we can before 3 o'clock Eastern. You can also ask on Twitter, and I'll keep an eye on the feed. Don't sit on those hands.

If this is your first Bloomerang webinar, an extra special welcome to you. We usually do these webinars on Thursdays, but we've been doing more of them, given everything going on in the world with fundraising and nonprofits. I think you know what I'm talking about. We have some great sessions coming up, even this week.

We're best known for our donor management software. If you're thinking about switching, or you're just curious, visit our website and you can watch a video demo and see everything in action. But don't do that right now, because we have Erica Waasdorp here. Erica, how are you doing? You doing okay?

Erica Waasdorp: I'm good.

Steven Shattuck: This is awesome.

Erica Waasdorp: Hello, everybody.

Steven Shattuck: I'm so excited. Erica is the monthly giving queen. Anytime I see a question about monthly giving, I'm like, talk to Erica. She's the only go-to in my mind for monthly giving. She literally wrote the book on it, and lots of other books too. She's joining us from beautiful Cape Cod, my homeland, another reason why I love Erica. We planned this webinar a few months ago, and things have changed a lot since then. Erica and I were talking last week and asked ourselves, should we still do this? We both decided yes. It's still timely, and it may be even more relevant, given all the sustaining support that monthly donors can give you. So that's why she's here.

So, Erica, I'm going to stop my screen share and let you pull up the slides. I'm going to stop my video too, because nobody needs to see me anymore. Let you find that share button.

Erica Waasdorp: Sure, share, okay.

Steven Shattuck: There you go.

Erica Waasdorp: Here we go.

Steven Shattuck: I think it's working.

Erica Waasdorp: It's working. Okay, great. I'm going to say hi, and then take down my video as well, so you won't have any distractions from the slides. I'll be back later.

Okay, so we're going to talk about best practices for engaging and keeping your monthly donors. Steven has already introduced me, so I won't talk about that too much. I did throw in a couple of slides about bringing in new monthly donors, and the reality is, especially now, that monthly donors are really important. If people don't have a lot of money, they can still give by making a small monthly gift. But it's really important that you ask. It's all about making some small changes to what you're doing right now that can generate big results. What if you had so many monthly donors?

I'd love to know in the chat how many monthly donors you have now. I didn't prepare any polls, so just type your number in the chat. People don't necessarily realize the tremendous value of monthly donors. If you had 100 monthly donors and the average monthly gift is about $24, that's $288 a year, or $28,000. If you had 200 monthly donors, that's almost $60,000. If you had 500, that's $144,000. Whenever you talk about monthly donor results, always annualize them. People are blown away, because getting people to give monthly has always been a challenge. I'm going to show you a couple of examples we did just last week, asking for a monthly gift as part of a COVID-19 coronavirus message.

This organization had two buttons in its email. One asked, will you give monthly to support us during this critical time? The second was the one-time option: yes, I'll make an emergency gift. The results were fantastic. Making a tiny change to an email you're already sending can make a difference in bringing in monthly donors. You have the tools, and you've done the backend work. You have your monthly giving page for people to come and make a gift.

So put it right out there: this is what you want people to do. You want them to give monthly. Anytime you send an email, try an extra button: "Make a one-time donation," "Become a monthly donor." This organization tripled its number of monthly gifts by adding this button to every email it sends. It doesn't cost anything, and it's a very simple change. The same organization just did an emergency appeal and brought in a number of nice new monthly gifts. You have nothing to lose by trying this.

Every time you reach out to your donors, especially now, when you're giving them updates or asking how they're doing, put a line in your PS or at the bottom of your email signature inviting them to join with a monthly gift. Those are three little things that can help you grow your monthly giving.

If you have monthly donors now, it's also a good time to get back to the monthly donors who have lapsed and dropped out. Or maybe you can ask your existing monthly donors for an extra gift, especially now. The cultivation, retention, extra gifts and upgrades all go hand in hand. If nothing else, now is a good time to pick up the phone and say thank you. If you've never said thank you to your monthly donors, now is a good time to tell them how much you appreciate their ongoing support. Engage everybody who can help with that. A thank-a-thon, thanking a monthly donor during the year, is always a good idea.

What I typically recommend is that you don't send a monthly thank-you letter in the mail. Instead, in January, send out a tax letter. As part of the follow-up to today's webinar, you'll get a tax letter template you can customize for your organization. Those are a couple of things to cultivate.

And you want to make monthly donors feel special. If there's something exciting or positive you can share, share it with them. I always recommend a special segment in your email program and in your donor base. Then you can say, I'm doing something special for all my donors, but for the monthly donors, this is one I want to add. Fred is walking, right? The other donors get this too, but it's a great way to make monthly donors feel special.

There are lots of other ideas for cultivating, but I only have an hour, so I focused on some of these. Think about what's special, surprising or positive that you can share with your existing monthly donors right now, something that will make them feel good and confirm they made the right decision to help you. That's really what it's all about.

People sometimes worry: does it take a lot of time to keep these monthly donors? The reality is yes. You're going to have to track your monthly donors, and you have to follow up if their card stops or their payment doesn't come in, because it's all about retention. A study done about a year and a half ago said 47 percent of organizations did not follow up. If you're on this webinar, you're not going to be one of those 47 percent. You absolutely have to follow up. Now is a good time to say, there may be monthly donors who dropped out for whatever reason, maybe you don't even know why, and it might be a good time to reach out and say, can you come back? We really need you. Keeping your monthly donors is a process. You'll get a process flow from me that you can customize for your organization.

There are a couple of parts to that process. You want to look at what I call hard cancels. Hard cancels are donors who call, email or write and say, "I don't want to do this anymore." There's a way you can possibly save them. Soft cancels are probably the bulk of the lapsed monthly donors you have. Soft cancels are donors whose payment doesn't come in, but they didn't tell you they wanted to stop. They really want to continue. Make sure you have a tracker in your database or system that shows which donors actually called and said no, as opposed to the others.

Then we're going to look at having a call script to bring them back, with emails, maybe more than one email, and letters, maybe more than one letter. Once you start doing this, you'll be amazed at the value of taking a little time to reactivate your monthly donors.

You're going to get a process flow, a simple PowerPoint tool you can fill in with what you're doing now. It sounds silly, but I've done this with big and midsize organizations. When you write down the process, you can see exactly where the holes are, who does what, and what isn't happening where you thought it was.

Here's an example. The credit card declines, or the payment doesn't come in. Pick one day a month, and sit down with the finance person, your accountant or your bookkeeper, and look at the people whose payment didn't come in. I recommend you send an email that same day. Send a letter within the first 48 hours, and try to call within the first 48 hours. Do all of those at the same time. Don't wait, because things fall through the cracks. Right now, people are getting their mail and emails, and they're home, so it's a good time to call. If they don't respond within, say, 10 days, make a second call, and then maybe a second email. Map out your current process, and then we can talk through where you can make tweaks.

I mentioned hard cancels already. If a donor calls and says, "I don't want to do this anymore," they care about your organization. They don't really want to stop. It's almost like they're calling to have you convince them otherwise. Find out why they're canceling. In some cases it's financial. Maybe they can lower their monthly gift. Maybe they were giving $24 a month and can go to $5 a month. That's still $60 a year, so it's still worth it. They might say, "I never thought about that. Yes, I can do $5 a month." Or they might say they can't give monthly, but they could give quarterly or yearly.

Have that conversation and find out what they want. They want to support you, just not this way right now. You can also ask whether they want to keep receiving updates from you. If they say, "I'm so upset, I don't want to receive anything anymore," you've probably lost them. But in most cases they'll say, "Oh yeah, I'd love to keep receiving updates." Maybe you can offer a pause: can I call you in six months? Maybe their situation has changed. We're all human, and we have things going on in our lives. Give them some options.

It's good to have what we call a save option. Find out why they want to stop, and then thank them. Everything you do on the phone when they call is about gratitude. We know you're making a difference as a monthly donor, and we're grateful, even if they keep saying no. Really listen to what they want, and then follow their direction. This is an example script you can use to try to save them.

If the donor's payment just stops, that's a soft cancel. They didn't contact you to stop. They want to keep giving. They may not know the card changed or was compromised, or they got a new card and forgot about you. I'm a monthly donor to I don't even know how many organizations, and I wouldn't necessarily think to let them know when my card changes. The donor wants to continue giving. They just forgot.

Pick one day a month to look at your soft cancels. In some systems, you can see ahead of time that a donor's card is about to expire, so you can act before it happens. In most cases, you won't get the information until it happens, so look at your system and take action right away. Some organizations charge daily. If someone signs up on the 24th, they're charged on the 24th every month. Other systems charge on the 15th, the 20th or the first, depending on how you set it up. No matter the system, pick one day and ask, how am I doing? Then take action to get these monthly donors back.

Then ask, how many monthly donors am I losing or about to lose? Say that's 10. At $24 a month, that's $288 a year each, so this month your number of monthly donors at risk is 10, worth almost $3,000. That's worth a little time and effort. If you look at it that way, you can talk to your boss and say, I need to spend a little time bringing these donors back.

People tell me, "I don't want to be a nag." You're not a nag. The donor wants to support you. They didn't want to stop. You're providing a service. You can be courteous: "It looks like your payment didn't come in this month. Maybe your card has changed. Can you please give me your updated information?" That's totally fine. They want to support you. Think about it that way. It's a courtesy and a service. You love your donors, and they love you back for doing this.

Don't wait. Combine everything. Send an email, send a letter, call people, and if you have their permission to send a text, send a text too. Then, if your payment processor offers it, set up what we call a credit card updater. For some systems, it's a great game-changer. Then repeat.

Right now, there's no general consensus in the nonprofit world on when to stop. Some organizations remind donors three months in a row. Others remind them four or five months in a row. Don't give up too soon. We're all human. Maybe you left a message, and I was meaning to call you back, but I got busy with the kids. Keep at it until you get that updated information.

Send an email, ideally with a link to a special update page. We're all busy. I might get that email at 5 o'clock and sit down at 10 o'clock to update my information. A link to a form where I can type in my updated information is ideal, because I can do it any time. If I have to wait until I can call you during the workday, I won't get to you. Make it easy for the donor to update. I recommend you copy your monthly giving page and set it aside for updates, so anybody who uses that URL is updating their information, not signing up as a new monthly donor. Definitely consider a link in your email straight to that update page. Then also send a letter. You'll get a monthly donor retention playbook from me with letters, scripts and emails you can customize.

Here's an example letter. You can call the organization too, and that's in the playbook. Have the letter go out at about the same time as the email. Make sure there's a reply form with the donor's information on it, and a reply envelope. You could even consider asking the donor to upgrade their gift. You'd be amazed how often donors are willing to do that.

Finally, you could consider a postcard. You've sent a letter, a couple of emails and tried some calls. A postcard can say, "Hey, is this really goodbye? We hope you're still with us." It's that final push, where people say, "Oh yeah, I was meaning to do this, I keep forgetting." Let me go online and do it. Pull out all the stops.

As mentioned, make that courtesy call. Thank the monthly donor in your message or live. The playbook has a couple of scripts, one for a live call and one for leaving a message. If you're talking with the monthly donor, have a solution ready. Maybe they changed cards, or maybe you can ask for their bank account information if you offer that option. I'll show you a couple of examples. If you're having that conversation, it's a courtesy call. Always include a thank you, and then ask for the updated information. The script will be in the playbook, and you can leave a message.

Depending on your donor base system or payment processor, find out whether they have a credit card updater, account updater or credit card recycler. It's all the same terminology for a system that works in the backend. It's PCI compliant, and it's been a game-changer, especially for organizations with bigger programs. Ask your donor base or payment processor, "Do you offer this? Do you have it in place?"

Here's how it works. The card doesn't go through, so the payment doesn't go through. The system looks in a huge database you'll never see, finds the updated information and processes the gift. Or it says the information isn't updated yet, so you still have to act. Right now, organizations are getting updated information for about 30 percent of their monthly donors this way. So 70 percent still need a call, an email and a letter. But that's 30 percent fewer people you have to contact, and their payment keeps going.

Text messages have a 90 percent open rate right now. Make a text very personal and short, with a link to the update and your phone number. Make sure you have permission. If you used something like MobileCause or another text program to sign up your monthly donors, you have their permission to text them. This is a great opportunity.

After this, look at your process. Maybe you're already doing it perfectly. If not, how will you change your process flow? What will you add, and what will happen? It's about how many more monthly donors you can keep, and how much money you keep at the end of the day. Every month, you could be losing monthly donors because credit cards expire. About 5 percent of credit cards expire every month, so you could lose 5 percent of your monthly donors if you do nothing. That's why this is such a crucial piece.

Even if they stopped giving a couple of months ago, now is a good time to reach back out and say, "You used to give to us. Would you consider coming back?" You never want to give up on them. Put your lapsed monthly donors in the special email you're sending out now, with the link to the monthly giving page, and see if you can bring them back. If you have a separate segment, track how they respond. See how many monthly donors you bring back. Even a few is more than zero. You've done the hard work. It's a matter of bringing them back into the fold.

If you're sending direct mail appeals to generate monthly donors, add your lapsed monthly donors as a special segment and track it. The bigger organizations with direct mail do this. They're always looking for new monthly donors, but they also go back to their lapsed monthly donors, because things change. These are your soft cancels, the donors whose payment didn't come in. They want to continue giving.

I was talking to a woman in Canada a while back, and I interviewed her for a blog post. She started calling her lapsed monthly donors. Out of the 48 she talked to, 24 reactivated. Some had stopped giving monthly five years ago. That's 50 percent, which is a very powerful number. It doesn't take very long. She schedules one call a day and stays half an hour late once a week, so about one day a month. It doesn't take much time, and it's worth a lot of money if you can bring them back. You also get to have a conversation and find out what they like about your organization, what they don't like, and whether they weren't treated right. One call a day can do a lot. It doesn't have to take much time or money to keep them.

The big trend now is to get monthly donors to give by electronic funds transfer, ACH, direct debit or automatic bank withdrawal. Donors change banks about every 12 to 14 years, if at all. So once you get them to give from their bank account, retention is even higher.

Look at this statistic. Some organizations still send mail reminders, called check statements. On average, retention for that group is 62 percent, because they get 12 check statements a year, and they don't send a check each time. If donors give by credit card, retention averages 87 percent. If you can get them to give by electronic funds transfer, ACH, you're looking at 94 percent retention.

Based on the most recent Blackbaud Sustainer Benchmarking, on average 5 percent of monthly donors give by electronic funds transfer, but it's growing, because it's much easier to set up now. If you can offer it, add it to the mix. Reach out to your existing monthly donors and ask, would you consider switching? It saves us money, it's cheaper and it's safer. You might even send a special appeal in-house and see what happens. You want their bank account information.

You can use the phone. If you're talking with them, ask them to update their information, and you can also ask them to set up automatic payments from their bank account. Have that negotiation. If you can offer EFT on your online form, it's even easier for the donor when you ask them to update their information. It's all about savings for your organization. More money goes to help the animals, the children and the clients you serve. And it's easier for your donor too.

Next, it is absolutely possible to upgrade your monthly donors. People ask me this all the time: "I'm worried. I don't want new monthly donors who only give $5 a month. I really want more money." It may be better to bring them in at $5 or $10 a month, because you can upgrade them later. You can also ask for an extra gift, and you can ask them to leave you in their will. Ideally, you do all of it. Monthly donors support you because they want to help. The ease of giving monthly is secondary. They want to help you, and monthly giving is just a good way to do it. They're interested in extra gifts, upgrades and leaving you in their will, but you have to ask.

On average, 6 percent of monthly donors make at least one additional gift. I'm waiting for the latest statistics from last year, but 6 percent make at least one extra gift. Some organizations get two, three or four extra gifts from their monthly donors. In some cases, they're the best-responding group every time they send an appeal. Twelve percent of monthly donors are interested in upgrading, and some do both. You have nothing to lose by asking. Don't be too greedy, though. You don't want to ask when they've just come on board. I recommend waiting at least half a year. You don't have to wait a whole year, but six to 12 months is a good time to ask for an upgrade. You can still consider additional asks during the year, but do it right.

Always thank them for giving monthly, and then say, I have a special opportunity. Donors want to help, so give them the opportunity. Look at your schedule of appeals. Every organization is different. Some send two appeals a year. Others send two appeals and two e-newsletters. Others send 10 appeals a year. Look at which appeals are most successful with your donors, because those will be the most successful with your monthly donors too. If you have to make choices, which are the most responsive appeals? Which special appeals would a monthly donor appreciate, like a calendar, a membership or a support card? A match appeal will appeal to your monthly donors. A giving day or Giving Tuesday will too, and they're likely to make an extra gift. Look at your plan, your number of appeals and emails, and ask, what can I do, and what makes the most sense? It's okay to ask your monthly donors what they'd like to hear about. They'll tell you. Pick the right appeals, and get more money in the door.

Upgrades work well, but you have to do them right. Recognize your donors. I'm a partner in Hope for St. Jude, and I've been for a number of years. They send me an upgrade appeal. I'm giving $5 a month now, and they're looking to upgrade my monthly pledge to $6, $7, $8, and others. Always give a couple of options. The message is, I'm thankful to you. It drips with gratefulness. That's the key.

On your reply form, put the new amount, because that's the new amount the donor commits to. In your letter or email, you might say, "Would you consider an upgrade of $2, $3 or $5 more?" Then on the form, have the donor indicate the new amount, so you have a record of the commitment.

When you ask for new monthly donors, ask low to get a high response. When you ask for an upgrade, don't be too greedy, but test a couple of options. My experience is that one-third of the current monthly gift is a good starting point. If someone is giving $4 a month, you could start with an upgrade of $8 a month. You can test smaller steps too: what if I do just $2 more, or $4 more? Some organizations are very sophisticated with their forms and can be flexible about ask amounts. Others find it harder. You need one online donation form on the back end that offers the amount donors are most likely to upgrade to. You can test a few forms, but keep it simple.

Start with one-third, then two-thirds, then the same amount they're giving now, to see whether you can double their monthly gift. If you're in doubt, start with $2 a month. This is especially true if you have monthly donors who give $10 or $12 now. Religious and animal organizations often have smaller monthly amounts, so look at what you get now and test upgrades there. Donors will tell you if they can do more.

How do you get more money and engage your monthly donors even more? You can ask for an additional gift, and you can ask donors to consider leaving you in their will. Here's an email with multiple buttons: increase your existing gift, which goes to an upgrade page, or make an additional one-time gift. Test it on one or two appeals. You can do a lot in your emails, so use multiple buttons. What do you have to lose?

Additional appeals work too. You're thanking me for being a partner in Hope for St. Jude, and then you want an extra gift this month. Some big organizations do this. If you have a couple of dollars, join some of the bigger organizations with substantial monthly donor programs, like St. Jude, ASPCA and Habitat for Humanity, just to name a few, along with religious and animal organizations like HSUS. They have bigger monthly donor programs. Join them and see what they're doing. They test a lot. If they're testing it and doing it, we know it works, so let's borrow that idea.

Additional emails work too. I mentioned you can ask for Giving Tuesday or a match. One organization calls its monthly donors "wildlife guardians." They recognize them as wildlife guardians and then ask for an additional gift. They tell the donor they know the donor is already giving monthly.

Don't be afraid to put something in your newsletter, your e-newsletter or a buck slip in your tax letter. Add a little note at the bottom of your e-newsletter, just planting the seed about leaving the organization in a will.

One thing I started doing with organizations recently is to ask them to look at donors who left the organization in their will. What was their starting gift? How long ago was that? How many gifts did they make since then? What was the last gift, and when was it? You'll be amazed that most people who leave you in their will come from these smaller donors.

One of my organizations has about 30,000 monthly donors, and 75 percent of its legacy revenue came from monthly donors. Look at what you have in your database and let that drive you. You don't have to wait until they're big donors. Start planting seeds with a checkbox on every appeal: "Please send me information about leaving you in my will." This is an ad in one organization's magazine.

With everything we do, asking for extra gifts, asking for upgrades, asking for new monthly donors, retaining monthly donors, cultivating monthly donors, the combination of mail, phone, email and text is the most powerful. Reach the donor where they are.

Never forget to say thank you. I always recommend you say thank you in hard copy when someone joins, when they convert to EFT and when they upgrade. You decide what that looks like. The more personal, the better. It's okay to call and say, thanks so much for your upgrade, thanks so much for sending your updated information, thanks so much for converting to ACH. It makes a difference for the animals, the children and the clients you serve.

We're all in this together, and the donor wants to be part of it. They want to help. You don't earn loyalty in a day. You earn it day by day, by doing a few of these things and keeping your monthly donors going for a very long time.

That's it for me. If you have questions after today, I'll probably do one follow-up later this week. I promise we'll only do one follow-up. You can always reach out by phone or email, and you can download resources from my website. You'll get some handouts after this as well. Steve, any questions?

Steven Shattuck: Yeah, that was awesome. Erica, we got a lot of questions. I want to say thanks, this is awesome. I knew it would be chock-full of good stuff. Thanks for making a quick pivot for us, because when we scheduled this, we didn't anticipate a global pandemic that would disrupt fundraising. I really appreciate you still doing this. We got a lot of questions, so if you haven't asked one yet, now is the time. Angela was wondering whether you have a formula for the right ask amount, in dollars per month. Is there a rule of thumb?

Erica Waasdorp: It's also that one-third. Say somebody is giving you $35 in an appeal. Start with one-third of that. Low is always better. If you can get away with $5 or $10 a month, that's great, but one-third is typical. I've been doing this for more than 25 years, and it still seems to be the golden formula. Start with about $10 a month, then $15, then $20, and go up from there. One-third is a good formula.

Steven Shattuck: That's a massive increase in lifetime value, right? One-third times 12. And retention rates for monthly donors are around 90 percent, so that's not nothing. I love it. Linda is asking about workplace giving, folks giving monthly through their workplace. Should you do anything different there?

Erica Waasdorp: The system is a little different in how you track it and where it's recorded, but you can absolutely recognize workplace givers as part of your monthly donor program. If you have a welcome letter or a special email, you can include them. It's typically tracked somewhere else, so keep that in mind. Always recognize your donors as special. That never hurts.

Steven Shattuck: Catherine works for an advocacy organization, so should they...

Erica Waasdorp: Petitions are great.

Steven Shattuck: Any differences in approach there?

Erica Waasdorp: If you do petitions, they're great. Or surveys as part of your advocacy activities. If someone signs a petition, then as part of the thank-you for signing, you can say, "It would be really helpful if you would consider giving monthly. Click here." That gives you a free option to ask donors to give monthly. Some organizations have great success offering that on the back end of their advocacy efforts.

Steven Shattuck: Cool. I love the petitions idea, because you're already making a touchpoint. Existing touchpoints are kind of the secret sauce here.

Erica Waasdorp: Yes.

Steven Shattuck: Just slipping it in. Okay, that makes sense. A few questions came in that are pretty related, though they won't sound like it when I read them, so I'm going to combine them. Jessica is wondering whether reaching out to monthly donors semi-frequently reminds them the contribution is being made. I hear this one a lot. And Amber, I'm sorry, Amber is wondering the same thing. Then Jessica asked: I need to reach out to a monthly donor, but I'm not sure if now is a good time, with what's happening in the economy. It's like reminding them there's a utility bill in place. What do you think?

Erica Waasdorp: Some systems send a receipt every month. If you have monthly donors on PayPal, PayPal automatically sends a receipt every month, and you can't suppress it. So donors are reminded, and there's nothing you can do. Other systems let you suppress that and do something special. You can say thank you so much for your continued monthly support, here's an update on what's happening, or here's a great story about how your gifts are making a difference. If you confirm they're giving monthly, but it's more than a receipt, thanking them and reporting back on how the gifts are making a difference, you're totally fine. Now is a good time to say, I just wanted to thank you for your ongoing monthly support. You really make a difference. If you have any questions, I'm here. You can even say, I know you're already giving monthly, but we're really struggling right now with this pandemic. Could you consider an extra gift?

Steven Shattuck: I love it.

Erica Waasdorp: If you do it right, including the thank-you, you can put a laser-printed message on an urgent appeal, or a handwritten note, saying, "Thank you for your ongoing monthly support, but I really need you right now. Would you consider an extra gift?" The donor can say no, and that's okay. They're not necessarily going to cancel their monthly gift because of it.

Steven Shattuck: If all you send is 12 transactional receipts, they're going to feel like a utility bill, something disposable. Utility bills aren't disposable, but that one could hit the chopping block. It's funny you mention the second question, because we did a webinar on Friday, off topic, and this came up. Our guest said every business he's ever transacted with reaches out to him, but none of the nonprofits he supports do. I counted, and my family gives 11 monthly contributions, which is a little high for most households. I'm kind of a philanthropy geek.

Erica Waasdorp: I'm doing more than that [inaudible 00:56:23].

Steven Shattuck: But I haven't heard from any of them. A couple of them are human services, and I'm wondering what's going on over there.

Erica Waasdorp: I got a great video from one of my monthly donor folks in the Illinois area. They made a little video saying, "Because of you, we're able to do some of these things." It's a thank-you video.

Steven Shattuck: That seems like one of the first groups I'd reach out to. Here's one from Chris: is there value in converting monthly donors to multi-year pledge donors? Have you seen that conversion happen?

Erica Waasdorp: Pledges have an end date. If you ask, would you consider a three-year pledge, there's an end date. Monthly donors really don't have an end date, and you don't want one. I'd only do it if you reach out to your monthly donors about a capital campaign or a building project and ask whether they can make a special extra gift and pay it off over a couple of years. Then it becomes a second gift, a multi-year pledge. Otherwise, I wouldn't offer a pledge, because it has an end date.

Steven Shattuck: So in addition to, not instead of?

Erica Waasdorp: Right.

Steven Shattuck: And monthly donors would be a good prospect for that?

Erica Waasdorp: Typically, monthly donors aren't your big check writers. But if you have a special project at the end of a capital campaign, and you're going to your general donors to reach a goal, then by all means, offer it to monthly donors too. If I were a monthly donor and you didn't offer me that opportunity, I'd be upset. I'd want my name on that building, on the plaque, in that library.

Steven Shattuck: That makes sense. Here's one from Maria. She just started a new job, and she's wondering how long is too long to reach out to folks who soft cancelled, who lapsed because their credit card expired. She's going through the database and seeing these, but it's been a while.

Erica Waasdorp: It's never too long. Remember the woman I showed you? She started reaching out, and some people hadn't given in five years. You have nothing to lose by reaching out and seeing whether you can bring them back. A couple of years ago, I started 25 new monthly gifts and gave them a card that was expiring the next month, just to see how they'd respond. It was pretty sad, actually. And one organization reached out. The woman said, "I'm new in this, and I was looking through the monthly donors and saw your name, and I wanted to see if you'd come back." She reached me by phone, probably 14 months after I stopped. I said, "Oh yeah, of course." I'd forgotten my payment didn't come through. You have nothing to lose by reaching out to those soft cancels.

Steven Shattuck: And they probably didn't even notice if it was $7 or $12. I check my online banking, but if that stopped, I don't know that I'd notice.

Erica Waasdorp: Once a year I look at my taxes, and I think, oh yeah, I forgot about that.

Steven Shattuck: So what I'm hearing is that fortune favors the bold. I love it.

Erica Waasdorp: Yeah.

Steven Shattuck: Erica, this was awesome.

Erica Waasdorp: Great.

Steven Shattuck: Thanks for doing this. You're the best, as always. How can folks get a hold of you? I've got your contact info, but what should folks do?

Erica Waasdorp: Send me an email, or call me. Like I said, I'm going to do one follow-up, so you'll get some handouts. You'll get the slides, the recording and the process flow. Sign up for my email. I typically send one email a week, or I was going to say a month, with lots of tidbits and case studies.

Steven Shattuck: Cool. Sign up, it's good. She doesn't overdo it. It's one of the good ones. I don't think you'll want to unsubscribe anytime soon. I'll get you the slides and recording. She sent me a flow worksheet she showed on her slides, and I'll get that to you today, I promise. This was awesome, Erica. Thanks for being here.

Erica Waasdorp: Great. Let me know what you're doing too. I'm always looking for great case studies, especially now. See how many monthly donors you can bring in.

Steven Shattuck: We'd love to know, and we're going to keep the conversation going. We have a webinar two days from now with Rachel. She's been collecting emails and social media posts about how folks are reaching out to donors, constituents and potential donors about the coronavirus, and she's going to share some of that. It's a short-notice one, and she was willing to do it for us. If you can't make it, we'll record it, and it'll be on our blog, as always. If you're free on Thursday at 2 p.m. Eastern, join us. It's going to be a good one. We'll call it a day there. Thanks for being here. I know things are hectic, and I appreciate you hanging out for an hour. Please stay safe. We'll see you again in a couple of days. Take care.

Erica Waasdorp: Thank you, bye.

‍

Key takeaways:

  • Treat monthly donor retention as a process you run every month. Erica says to pick one day a month to review donors whose payments failed. She cites a study that found 47 percent of organizations did not follow up at all.
  • Separate hard cancels from soft cancels. Hard cancels are donors who ask you to stop, and a conversation about a smaller gift can sometimes keep them. Soft cancels are donors whose payment simply stops, and Erica says they usually want to keep giving.
  • Move donors to bank transfers where you can. Erica cites average retention of 62 percent for check reminders, 87 percent for credit cards and 94 percent for ACH, and says a credit card updater can recover some expired cards.
  • Wait six to 12 months before asking for an upgrade, and thank donors first. Erica suggests thanking them for giving monthly, then offering a modest increase. She says about 12 percent of monthly donors are interested in upgrading.
Helping you help others

Every act of generosity starts here.

Empower your team to connect deeply and fundraise confidently.