Can a simple prompt encourage more monthly giving?

Hypothesis

This experiment tested whether inviting one-time supporters to give monthly encouraged more recurring gifts without making them less likely to complete their donation.

Timing

September 21–October 1, 2026

Audience

Nonprofits using eligible Standard Donation Forms with one-time and monthly giving enabled and Recurring Upgrade turned off. Reported results cover standard checkout, excluding Express Donate, where supporters don’t see the prompt.

Group split

Half of eligible visits included the prompt, and half didn’t. The prompt invited supporters to give monthly at half their selected one-time amount—for example, $10 a month instead of a $20 one-time gift. Every other form element stayed the same.

What this means for you

Give supporters an opportunity to make their generosity ongoing. Consider turning on Recurring Upgrade, especially if you receive many gifts under $50. Watch how many supporters finish their donation and how many keep giving monthly to see how the prompt works for your nonprofit.

Key results

The prompt helped more supporters choose recurring giving. Recurring gifts made up 6.29% of completed donations with the prompt, compared with 5.15% without it—a 22.0% increase. Revenue per visit from initial donations showed no clear change. The group with the prompt completed 2.3% fewer donations through standard checkout, a small drop that needs monitoring. After 30 days, monthly supporters in both groups made second payments at similar rates.

Segment insights

The prompt made the clearest difference for gifts under $50. For gifts of $50 or more, the test didn’t show a clear change in how often supporters chose recurring giving.

Conclusion

A simple invitation encouraged more recurring giving, especially among smaller gifts. The results support turning on Recurring Upgrade while watching how many supporters complete their donation and keep giving over time.

22.0% increase in recurring gifts

See what’s possible

Build a better giving experience.

Explore how Bloomerang brings giving, donor relationships, and insights together to help you raise more with confidence.