Webinar

Raise those paddles: Your event's special appeal

A special appeal is the fundraising opportunity at your event with the largest potential return. We will look at how to structure a successful appeal in line with your event program, and explore a few key strategies that will increase your event fundraising quickly.

Learning objectives:

  • Why a special appeal (paddle raise) is relationship-driven giving and the highest fundraising potential of the event, and how to ask for unrestricted funding.
  • Plan the program so the special appeal lands at the peak of the program arc, ahead of the auction and other transactional activities.
  • Structure an appeal with a one-person impact story, a direct and clear ask, and an active way to collect gifts, such as paddles.
  • Use donor data to set precommitted starting gift levels, start high and work down, and use matching challenges to build momentum.

View this session's slides on this page.

Transcript:

Kate Kramer: Welcome, everybody. I know that we have quite a few people in the waiting room, so I'm going to give it a few minutes before we get started.

I'm Kate Kramer. I'm the partner marketing manager here at Bloomerang, and I'm so excited that you guys are joining us for day two of fundraiser focus week.

I'm joining from Virginia today, where it is very rainy. Feel free to drop in the chat where you're joining us from, or maybe you have fun evening plans. I know Kristin is joining from the West Coast. Correct?

Kristin Steele: I am. Portland, Oregon. We're sunny today, actually. So, yeah. Yes. Lots of Toronto raining.

Kate Kramer: Yes. It looks like rain maybe everywhere. Oh, there was someone in Virginia. Not raining, but cloudy. Yes.

Kristin Steele: We have now.

[crosstalk]

Kristin Steele: We got Silverton, Oregon. Hello. Good to see you.

Kate Kramer: Oh, that's awesome. So, a few little housekeeping notes before we get started. We are recording this. We're going to send out the recording as well as the slides later today.

Since this is fundraiser focus week, we don't take any live questions. We'll take all of those Thursday during the panel, but please still put them in the Q&A box so that we can bring them to Thursday's webinar.

Before we end today, I'm also going to pick one attendee to give a fifty dollar gift card to Uber, so please stick around till the end in case your name gets drawn.

Hopefully, you guys are familiar with Bloomerang, but if you're not, we are an online platform for your donor management, volunteer, online fundraising, and event management needs. If you want to learn more, you can let us know at the end, and when you do, let us know if you want to hear more from Kristin.

And that leads me to turning this over for the content you've asked Kristin for. Welcome, Kristin. We are so excited to have you.

Let me stop my share.

Kristin Steele: Awesome. Thank you.

Y'all, it's great to be with you. We are going to NASCAR through, like, twenty-six minutes of your event special appeal, so I'm going to share my screen so we can get rolling.

Please know that going through your appeal, we could spend eight-hour days together on this. So today is intended to be super high level, to pique your interest, to remind you of some key points, and to get you thinking about what questions you have for Thursday's panel.

This is not intended to be every piece of everything. It's just a big-picture overview so you can start to think about the special appeal at your event and what that can look like. So let's talk about events really briefly at the top, and the power that gathering can have for your organization.

There's a reason why gathering is at the base of every religion and every social justice movement. When you bring people together, there is a different potential for your organization than when you are talking one on one with people. What we want to do is use the power of gathering to raise money for your mission and for your organization, and that's where the special appeal at your event comes in.

I'm using the words special appeal. It's also called a paddle raise. It's called a bunch of stuff. So let's talk about what that is. There are a lot of regional differences here. Just quickly, from the top, seeing everybody log in to the chat and say where they were from and what the weather was like, I'm talking to folks all across the country, in Canada and beyond, maybe.

This looks different regionally. How people approach this, what it's called, the function it serves at an event, what they do with it, can be very, very different. So please know I'm coming from a very specific West Coast benefit auction perspective. Take this and modify it to where you are, but the guiding principles should still hold.

I'm talking about a special appeal or a paddle raise today in the frame of a major donor event. There are several different kinds of events you can throw, from acquisition events all the way to legacy events. Major donor events sit about two-thirds of the way through your donor cultivation continuum. These are where you have donors in the room who know your organization and have given to it, and you're able to leverage those relationships to raise a lot of money at your event.

So, like I said, it's called a bazillion things: special appeal, paddle raise, fund-a-need. They all mean the same thing. It is a direct ask for cash for your mission in the room.

At your event, this is the highest fundraising potential of the night. Don't get confused by the shiny of auctions and wine walls. All of those things are great, but they're transactional. Your special appeal is relationship-driven giving, and you have the highest potential for fundraising at your event through your special appeal.

You should make sure that when you do your special appeal, you are asking for unrestricted funding. That doesn't mean "please donate unrestricted funding tonight." It means don't lock yourself into funding a specific project at your organization. Grants lock you into specifics all the time. This should be an unrestricted pocket of money that you can use as you deem appropriate.

It's how you're going to keep the lights on. It's how you're going to add staff. It's how you make the shifts and changes to your work that you don't have to get into the weeds on. So don't get up and raise money for a swimming pool because construction costs may change. You may have to raise more money for the swimming pool. Let's say you decide the swimming pool isn't a good idea, but you have to keep your staff paid. You will have to go back to all of those donors and ask them to change the intention of their donation. So don't do that.

This is unrestricted funding. That's the frame we're going to use.

Your paddle raise is actually a donor cultivation strategy, and this is where tools like Bloomerang come into play. When you have a CRM and you have really great donor data, you can track that year over year. The paddle raise, and who you're going to talk to about participating and precommitting, comes right out of your donor data.

Your paddle raise at your event allows the people in the room to be part of something bigger than themselves. This is how they take collective action at your gathering, and it is their opportunity to be recognized in front of their peers. We're going to talk about why those are such powerful motivators for behavior.

Susan Howlett at the University of Washington did a study on why people give. It's a weird thing. I take money out of my pocket, without much thought, and give it to an organization I believe is going to go do good work. On face value, that could seem like a very odd exchange. Yet there are personal motivators for why I would do that.

She did a study where she talked to donors. Why do you give? What is in that for you? The top three reasons that came back were that donors want to be a part of something, that they want to be known, and that they want to make a difference.

Those are really powerful motivators for people, and all three can be satisfied by your special appeal if you do it right.

When you do the special appeal at your event is often the first question people ask. They say, "Yeah, I do a special appeal. We do it all the time, and we don't raise money." I would argue that when you do your special appeal can make all the difference in how much money you raise. There is a science to sequencing the appeal at your event. You can often increase your fundraising at your event one-fold, two-fold, by simply moving the order of your stage program so your special appeal hits at the peak of your program arc.

When I talk about a program arc, this is what it looks like for us. There are actually three arcs happening at the same time: a people arc, a program arc, and a fundraising arc. Some of those you can control, and some you can't.

The people arc, you can't control. It's human economics. It's happening all the time. It's happening for me right now. I probably got your really, really great attention for the next five minutes, and then lunch and doorbells and kids and dogs and work and emails, and all of those are going to start to factor in, and it's going to start to dwindle. So I'm going to try to get you the maximum information you need in this first section, and then reinforce it in the back section, so that if you tune out, you've gotten what I need, and we're all on the same page at the peak of my program.

I call it the journey to soft pants. When I go to an event, I am looking for the shortest, easiest route home, to get out of my fancy clothes and back into soft pants. You have a chunk of time with me, and that's it. So you want to make sure that you are sequencing your program and your fundraising along that same arc, so they're not fighting against each other. The special appeal, which is the peak of your fundraising, should happen at the top of that arc.

You're having a fundraising event. Make it important. Put your fundraising out there first and clear, and do it at the beginning of your program. Then put all of the candy later, for people to stay for. When we talk about sequencing, you want your special appeal to sit right at the peak of your arc.

There are three elements to every successful paddle raise, and I want to walk through them. You need all three for your paddle raise to be as successful as it can be. You need a really good impact story that showcases your work. You need to actually ask people for money. That seems obvious, but often an ask gets mumbled into a thank-you, and maybe you don't quite ask for money. We're fundraisers. We should be comfortable asking people for money and giving them the opportunity to be part of something.

If we think of Susan Howlett's reasons for giving, people want to be a part of something. They've come to your event knowing it's a fundraiser. Show them that you take fundraising seriously, and ask them to participate. Then, after you ask them, you have to give them a way to give you the money. That seems super obvious as well, but it's not. If I ask you for money but don't give you a mechanism for fulfilling that, I don't get the money. You may be well-intentioned, but I have to give you the opportunity to give it to me.

We're going to talk through each of these three pieces. Let's start with the story: your impact story. This is not your organizational story, and it is not the story of all of your programs. It is literally the story that sets up your special appeal, and it shows one person being impacted by your work. It is the hero's journey.

We find that video is one of the most successful mediums for this. We've all been conditioned so that when the lights go out and the screen turns on, we pay attention. Video is a really compelling way to center your storyteller, whose story it is, and let them tell it to your audience.

Paul Slovic out of the University of Oregon did a study about what happens if I tell people the story of one and I tell the story of many. Will I get more donations with the story of many? He told the story of one kid who was hungry and needed help, and asked people to give. Donations went up. Then he thought, well, that worked. So he tried telling the story of all the thousands of kids who go hungry every day. Did that ask get more donations? Donations went down significantly.

So he thought, maybe people don't understand the case. So he tried telling them the story of one, and then telling them that he's one of thousands. He found that while it raised more than telling just the story of thousands, it still brought in fifty percent fewer donations than telling just one story. When he asked people why their donations decreased, they said, "I was overwhelmed. I'm not Melinda Gates. I don't have millions of dollars to solve child hunger. But when you told the story of one, I could identify with them, and I really felt like my twenty dollars could make an impact in their life."

Your audience is smart enough to extrapolate that you do more than help one person. But by focusing in and telling your impact story through one storyteller, and talking about how their life is different as a result of coming into contact with your organization, you allow your donors to see themselves impacting a life.

So we encourage you, when you're telling your story at your event, to tell one person's story of impact. People always ask, "But what's the shape of the story? How do I tell it? What does it look like?" It's super simple. You ask your storyteller to tell us what their life was like before they came into contact with you, before they knew you. Then, what happened when they came into contact with you, what they experienced, and what that did for them. And now, how they see their life after spending time with your organization.

It's that same shape. It's that arc. It's who they were before, what the connection with you changed and did for them, and now what's possible for them as a result. Simple story format. Make your storyteller the center of the story.

So we've told this great story, and now we need to ask folks to give. This is my best Bob Barker pose. Come on down. You need to make an ask. You need to say you've teed folks up. They're invested. They're leaning forward. They're listening to the story. They're ready to get on board. They love your work. You need to say, "This story is one of many, and we would love for you to make this possible for others."

Clear. Simple. Don't have somebody get up and say, "Thank you for being here tonight." That closes the door. Open it up by saying, "Please give generously tonight." Support Lisa, and ask people to lean in, dig deep, and donate. It's short and sweet.

This is Dixie, and I want to talk about what the optimum sequence of your story and your ask can look like, to hit the peak of your arc. Dixie told her story in a video of what her life was like before she came into contact with Community Action, what changed in her life, and what's possible for the future of her family as a result. As an audience, we all sat and watched Dixie tell her story on video.

Clap. Right? Everybody started clapping after the video was over. Then somebody got up to the mic, or the MC got up to the mic, and said, "Y'all, I'd like you to put your hands together for Dixie, who's here with us tonight." So then we all kind of look at each other and go, "Wow. That's amazing." You've brought Dixie off the screen and into the room, and we start clapping even harder, because we want her to know we're with her.

So Dixie takes the stage. This is the beautiful moment of Dixie coming up to the mic before she has spoken and realizing that all that clapping in the room is for her, for the journey she's been on and the support they want her to feel. She had an earnest reaction to getting all of that applause, and then the room went even more wild.

Then she said, "Community Action changed my family's life. Please give generously tonight, all that you can." That was it. She stepped away from the microphone, and we used the benefit auctioneer, and we started the collection, which is how people give us the money.

So let's talk about the collection. You leave money on the table if you don't collect it. There are two ways to collect, active and passive. The more active you make your collection, the more money you're going to make. Sure and simple.

Active looks like this: big paddles in the air, with a benefit auctioneer going through levels of giving and recognizing people in the room. It's active. And not only that, it satisfies the other piece of why people give that Susan Howlett was talking about. People get seen. Ego is not a bad thing. People get seen getting in the room, and they feel like they're part of something when a paddle raise goes up. It builds energy and momentum in the room.

The least active, most passive form of collection for your appeal is leaving stacks of envelopes under the bread basket for people to fill out. So what you want to do is activate it as much as possible. If you have to use envelopes and you can't use paddles, at least activate your envelopes by having them passed out to people. There's a study that shows that when people receive something, they have a higher percentage of returning it to you. So have volunteers go around and pass the envelopes out, so people actively see them and take part. We know paddles aren't available to everybody, but activate where you can.

This is where we could spend days and days. So I'm just going to highlight these pieces very loosely, so you know that the magic of a special appeal happens in strategy. It's not "I close my eyes, walk into the room, and hope I know what happens. I hope we raise money." It's strategy. You have to know what's going to happen. You have to know you have top gifts, so you know where to start. If you don't have a ten-thousand-dollar donor in the room that you know of, don't start at ten thousand dollars.

Precommit strategy: this is where your data out of your CRM, like Bloomerang, shows up. You can start to have those conversations in advance, and know that you have your top levels precommitted, to create momentum in the room, so that people feel like they're part of something successful. You want starting levels that you know. Again, if you don't have a ten-thousand-dollar donor, don't start at ten thousand dollars. Start where you know you have people, and work your way down. Do not work your way up. Start high and go low. This is where your data really comes into play. If you have groups of people you want to move up, your data will help you tell that too.

Challenges are a really big part of success in appeals. Matching gift challenges and corporate matches are ways you can leverage different levels to say something like, "The standard is here today to match the first fifty gifts at a thousand dollars. Double your money right now. Who's in? Paddles up in the air."

I want to show a quick video that talks about how you can build a movement in your room with your special appeal. I think it's the best way to show it.

TED speaker (video clip): So, ladies and gentlemen, at TED, we talk a lot about leadership and how to make a movement. So let's watch a movement happen start to finish in under three minutes and dissect some lessons from it. First, of course, a leader needs the guts to stand out and be ridiculed. But what he's doing is so easy to follow. So here's this first follower, with a crucial role. He's going to show everyone else how to follow. Now notice that the leader embraces him as an equal. So now it's not about the leader anymore. It's about them, plural. Now there he is, calling to his friends. If you notice, the first follower is actually an underestimated form of leadership in itself. It takes guts to stand out like that. The first follower is what transforms a lone nut into a leader.

And here comes a second follower. Now it's not a lone nut. It's not two nuts. Three is a crowd, and the crowd is news. So a movement must be public. It's important to show not just the leader, but the followers, because you find that new followers emulate the followers, not the leader. Now here come two more people, and immediately after, three more people. Now we've got momentum. This is the tipping point. Now we've got a movement.

Notice that as more people join in, it's less risky. Those who were sitting on the fence before now have no reason not to. They won't stand out, they won't be ridiculed, and they'll be part of the in-crowd if they hurry. So over the next minute, you'll see all of those who prefer to stick with the crowd, because eventually they would be ridiculed for not joining in. That's how you make a movement.

So let's recap some lessons. First, if you are the type, like the shirtless dancing guy, standing alone, remember the importance of nurturing your first few followers as equals. It's clearly about the movement, not you. But we might have missed the real lesson here. The biggest lesson, if you noticed, did you catch it? Leadership is overglorified. Yes, it was the shirtless guy who was first, and he'll get all the credit. But it was really the first follower who transformed the lone nut into a leader. So, as we're told that we should all be leaders, that would be really ineffective. If you really care about starting a movement, have the courage to follow, and show others how to follow. And when you find a lone nut doing something great, have the guts to be the first one to stand up and join in. And what a perfect place to do that, at TED. Thanks.

Kristin Steele: So I think what that — sorry, let me again. There we go. I think what that captures really well is that when you do those precommits at the top, you start to build momentum, and you actually hit a tipping point in your special appeal where people can lean in and get on the train. It feels better to give and be part of what's happening than to cross your arms and sit out. So, creating a movement. Your leader is such a top giving level. It's really easy to follow. You want to make sure you have precommits to follow them, because three is a crowd.

Public movement, that's why an active paddle raise really helps create momentum in the room. If we're all quietly filling out envelopes, I don't know who's doing what. So I may diminish how much I give, because I'm not being motivated to give more. You can create a tipping point in the room. When more people join in, it's less risky. Being part of that in-crowd becomes really crucial in the room.

So what I thought would be great, because I know we all come to this with a bunch of different understandings of what a paddle raise looks like, is to show you an educational video that shows an active paddle raise in about four minutes. Let's take a look.

Auctioneer (video clip): Are you fired up to raise some money for North by Northeast tonight? Folks, we've come to a very special part of our program, and what I'd like to do is ask everyone to get really quiet at this moment. So if we can get everyone real quiet right here, right now.

Event host (video clip): We've got the opportunity now to share the story of a fantastic partnership with one of our North by Northeast family members. Please turn your attention to the screens to learn more.

Patient speaker (video clip): My mother and my father are civil rights workers. They very much instilled in us the importance of standing up for each other. When I first got diagnosed with high blood pressure, I was in here every three weeks. That's the day they saved my life. I knew I was going to be okay because you trusted this place. They really helped save people's lives, and I think there's a lot more lives we can save and reach.

Event host (video clip): Community, it is my honor to introduce a North by Northeast patient, friend, family member, and a member of our patient wellness council, Abigail Lawrence.

Patient speaker (video clip): Thank you, Jamal. Thank you very much, and thank you all for being part of my family. Being cared for by North by Northeast feels so good. And because of North by Northeast, I feel like Black health matters in this community. I want our important work together to continue and thrive. You make all of that possible. You make all of that possible with your generosity, and I ask that you give all that you can. And thank you for saving my life.

Auctioneer (video clip): This is the moment where we all get to come together and give generously. So here we go. We're going to start off at the five-thousand-dollar level. We have levels of giving for everyone in the room tonight. So the first level is at five thousand dollars. Who out there would like to make a gift at the five-thousand-dollar level? Bidder number 198 at five thousand dollars. Bidder number 105, that's the Frank Foundation. Bidder number 102, Dr. Johnson. Thank you very much. I want to hear a roaring round of applause for all of our donors at the five-thousand-dollar level.

The Collins Foundation wants to ignite some generosity. They will match the first four new gifts at two thousand five hundred dollars. Your gift will be doubled. We'd love to have your support. Bidder number 207, bidder number 191, bidder number 161, bidder number 332. For anyone who gives five hundred dollars tonight, you'll be entered to win a beautiful pair of diamond earrings.

Our final level of giving tonight is at the twenty-dollar level. And in honor of Pastor Mary, Dr. Joel Ginsburg, and Dr. Louise Clark will match every big, everyone. Smile real big, everyone. You're going to get your picture taken. Bidder number 104 is giving five times. And just for the record, that's Dr. Louise Clark. She's going to match her own gift, and I like it.

Folks, tonight in our appeal, I'm really excited to announce that we raised sixty-four thousand dollars. Yay. Y'all, a big roaring round of applause to each and every one of you. That was incredible.

Kristin Steele: But that's kind of how all the pieces can come together for your special appeal. Sometimes seeing it in action helps show what that is. When you use bidder numbers, you assign guests a number, and that number becomes like a tab they use throughout the evening. They can bid on auction items, the special appeal, and so on. When you have a precommit, you let your auctioneer know the bidder number. Say bidder number 330 is Jean Crawford, so that she can be called out by name. That starts the momentum going in your appeal, and you can go from there. So that's a very quick, high-level look at the appeal at your event.

Kate, talk to me about the gift card.

Kate Kramer: Goodness. Couldn't find my button. Sorry about that. All right. So right before I draw the winner, I want to put up a quick poll. Please let Kristin know if you would like to hear more from Swaim Strategies, or if you want to hear more about Bloomerang, or if you already use Bloomerang but want to know more about our auction software or our events software. You can let us know on the poll as well.

Also, thank you so much. That was such an amazing presentation.

Kristin Steele: You bet.

Kate Kramer: Today's winner is Scott Christie. Scott, you will see an email from me later this afternoon. If you don't, make sure you check your spam.

I hope to see everyone tomorrow for our last session of the week. And if you have time, please come Thursday. That's when we're going to answer all of your great questions and hear from all of our panelists again.

Thank you so much. We hope you have a wonderful day, and I hope to see you soon.

Kristin Steele: Happy fundraising, y'all. Bye.

Key takeaways:

  • Build your event paddle raise structure around the peak of your program. Moving the appeal to the top of the program arc can noticeably increase what you raise. Put the fundraising first and clear, then the rest of the program.
  • Start high with precommitted gifts, then work down. If you don't have a top donor in the room, don't open at that level. Your donor data shows where to start and which groups you can move up.
  • Tell one person's impact story before you ask. One storyteller who was helped by your work is more compelling than a story about thousands. Then make a direct ask and say the story is one of many.
  • Keep the collection active so the room builds momentum. Paddles in the air and bidder numbers make giving visible, and once a few people join in, others are more willing to join too.
Helping you help others

Every act of generosity starts here.

Empower your team to connect deeply and fundraise confidently.