Ask the experts: board engagement
You've spent the week exploring strategy with Julie, Lauren, and Kent. Now it's time to bring it home.
Join nonprofit thought leader Rachel Muir as she leads an energetic roundtable on board engagement, full of candid conversation, new perspectives, and ideas you can act on right away.
Learning Objectives:
- Wrap up the big ideas from the week
- Ask the questions you're still sitting with
- Get concrete moves for engaging your board
Transcript:
Jess Cronk: Yay. Hello, everyone. Welcome. Welcome. Welcome. I’ll give everyone a minute to log in and get settled. While you’re doing that, I’ll go ahead and introduce myself. If this is your first time joining us this week, I’m Jess. I am the VP of customer marketing, events, and partnerships here at Bloomerang, joining you from, today, sunny, yesterday was cloudy, sunny Tampa, Florida.
Today is our final day of Fundraiser Focus Week, where we get to dig into the questions that you’ve been submitting all week long and ask our experts about all things board engagement. A few housekeeping notes before we get started. Yes, today’s session is being recorded, and yes, you will receive the recording later today when we wrap up. If you have more questions for our panel, please go ahead and throw them in the Q and A. We will do our best to get to them throughout the conversation.
At the end of today’s presentation, I’ll be giving away a $250 Uber Eats gift card for you to share with your teams, or if you want to covet it for yourself, I guess you can do that too. But you must be in attendance to win.
If you’re not familiar with Bloomerang, we are a giving platform built for purpose, created to help nonprofits build stronger relationships and grow their impact. Our tools, like donor and volunteer management, online fundraising, peer to peer campaigns, and donation forms, are all designed to help organizations just like you thrive. We believe that when you have the time and insights that you need, you can focus on what truly matters: making a difference in your communities. If this resonates with you, let’s connect. We’d love to help you achieve your goals.
I’d also like to invite you to our annual conference, GiveCon. This is the nonprofit conference that is moving fundraising and missions forward. We have over 100 CFRE accredited sessions, an engaged community, and immersive experiences all lined up to help connect you in a place where you can learn, recharge, and turn your ideas into action. Prices go up November 1, so if you’re interested, go ahead and use that QR code and register today.
Alright. Without further ado, I will hand it over to the effervescent Rachel Muir.
Rachel Muir: You’re so kind, Jess. I am so excited to get to be with everybody today. This is such a rock star panel of experts, and I just wanna say we’re gonna be chatting you up in the chat. Of course, I wanna know what everyone’s gonna be for Halloween. So type your Halloween costume plans into the chat. If getting your board to fundraise or be a healthy thriving board feels like giving your cat a bath, you are in the right place, because we’re gonna be fixing that today. And I’m joined by three brilliant, beautiful friends to help you do just that.
I’m gonna introduce them one by one, and I’m gonna share some of my favorite snippets from their session and give them a question. And we’re gonna start in the order of appearance with the fantastic Julie Shannan, who I have adored since I met her, oh my gosh, almost thirty-five years ago. That’s how long I’ve been fangirling Julie.
Julie Shannan: Oh my god. Same.
Rachel Muir: She’s amazing. I mean, amazing. So Julie is the founder and CEO of Big Mission Consulting, and Julie is in this beautiful intersection of helping nonprofits with their fundraising and their mission and their marketing, which is a completely fantastic and totally unique space. She’s such a creative legend. I mean, Julie has more ideas in her little pinky than I have all day. She’s just a total genius, and she kicked us off on Monday with Just Don’t Ask Me to Fundraise board edition.
She spent her whole career in nonprofits. She was at the American Cancer Society and then had a very esteemed career at Girlstart. And then she went on to be the executive director of VentureLab, and she is now a consultant. And I just popped a link in there where you can find out more about her. Yes. She is truly a wonder woman and incredible.
So, Julie, you started this off on Monday with no board meetings, making it easy for board members to invite their prospects in. You actually shared an incredible mission moment, which I remember warmly, with one of our dear board members who said that the reason why she supported Girlstart was because she had cancer, and she believed that the cure for cancer was in a girl’s mind. You just did such a great job. You’ve got a poster download in the link, by the way, your skill inventory little download that you have.
Okay. You got this question. My board members regularly say, “I don’t know anyone.” Even when we’ve mapped out relationships both as a group and one on one, how do I motivate them to take the next steps even when it’s right there in front of them?
Julie Shannan: This is a great question, and I hear it a lot. And thank you, Rachel. It’s the mutual admiration club. Rachel was my boss, y’all, for ten years. Can you imagine how big your ego could be? She is like this all the time, by the way. This is not just Rachel on Zoom. Thank you, Rachel.
I think one of the things that I see is everyone wants this to be an easy button. Give me the people. Let’s hire a fundraiser that can bring the people to you. Well, I have news for you. I never promise introductions. I don’t even have to remember who I know, because it doesn’t matter. It’s who connects with your mission and why. So it’s really not about who you know, it’s about who you need to know, is what I really truly believe. This takes work. It’s like building a house, brick by brick.
And I think with board members, if they don’t know the right people, you don’t have the right board members, is what I would say. If that’s a tough situation, of course, you’re not gonna fire your whole board, but start bringing in some people that do get really motivated about going out in the community and meeting people.
One way that we did this that really helped us a lot was we started creating some roundtables that allowed community members to give us their expertise in really interesting ways, like government affairs. We didn’t do advocacy at Girlstart, right? But we knew those people were connected to major players in the community. Well, guess what? From that government affairs roundtable, that community roundtable, which was an hour and a half with lunch provided, we had a connection to the lobbyists for Google. We had a connection to all of these different lobbyists that were like, “I can help you. I’ve got a daughter. I like what you’re doing. Let me help you. We have an initiative, and this will make our client look better.”
I can’t tell you how much those community roundtables helped us. But find ways to make it about the person that you’re recruiting, not about you. Because people really, really don’t wanna go learn about you. They wanna connect with their peers the most.
Rachel Muir: I love it. That’s great information. I’m going to introduce Lauren and give Lauren one of her questions. Lauren is amazing. I first met Lauren and got to see her do her magic at GiveCon, where she was kind of cohosting, and it was incredible. I’m gonna put more about Lauren in the chat. She’s a visionary leader. She’s in Charlotte, North Carolina, chief executive officer at Architect Philanthropic Collective. Lauren, tell me, you were with the nonprofits that you used to work with, YMCA. Am I remembering that right? Yay. Okay.
Lauren Tudor: Yeah. YW, YW. But YWCA. Yes, we were briefly running the Girls Inc. after-school program, so some connections there.
Rachel Muir: Yes. Special heart. Special connection to Girlstart. I love it.
I loved your session, “Your board did nothing. Your onboarding did.” And I loved how you shared your own personal experience being on a board. No names were shared. A little bit later, I’ll pop in the replays, or anyone else, if you want to, you can pop it in. I mean, Bloomerang, pop in the replay so people can see it if they didn’t.
And for the questions, we do have your questions, and we’re gonna get to as many as we can, and you’re welcome to answer questions anytime. So I love that Lauren shared her very personal board experience. I was just like, preach, preach, preach, when I was watching you, because I have had that experience where I’m just like a wallflower. There’s no interaction whatsoever. And I love what you shared. You were honest. It’s not them. It’s us as nonprofits. We’re not doing enough to onboard them. And my goodness, you think about any company, for anyone who has worked for a for-profit company, they work so hard to onboard you. And we as nonprofits have to do it with our board.
I love what you shared. You said it’s a territory, not a committee; a number, three to five warm contacts; a counterpart, give them a board buddy or a staff person or both; and an end date. Make giving to you one of their top priorities while serving on the board. And you shared a really great download that I’ll invite you to pop into the chat.
So I’m gonna ask you one of your questions. Everybody has a lot of questions. Our board members are working managers. They’re not at the C-suite, and they don’t seem to have the network to tap into or the authority within their own company to make any kind of fundraising decisions. What can I do to motivate them to open up their personal contacts, make an effort to engage with their companies, or find other ways to support us? Many are unwilling to do this or brainstorm, or they avoid it when our ED directly asks them one on one. This is so much avoidance here. What are your thoughts, beautiful Lauren?
Lauren Tudor: It’s true, and it’s natural. I kinda wanna push on that just a teeny bit, because Julie just kinda grazed it. The premise is that when we tell a board member to go tap their network, what we’re kinda unintentionally asking is, “Go tell us you know rich people.” And that sucks. That does not feel good at all, because it becomes this really awkward status question, and nobody wants to answer that. There’s no tactful way to answer that. Especially for those working managers who feel like they have no network or they feel like they have no authority.
So my advice to them would be, okay, instead of thinking super grandiose, let’s just scale it down a little bit, and let’s talk about what a real Thursday actually looks like for you. If you don’t have this massive Rolodex, perhaps we can look through who the service providers are in your network, or who the vendors might be in your network. And to build upon what Julie stated about these little roundtables: invite them into your world.
Let’s stop asking about their network and really start figuring out who’s already in their orbit that we could bring closer to our mission, closer to our vision, and offer conversations with them and see what their charitable giving strategies are. Maybe they’re the vendors you’re already paying. Perhaps there’s some company match that we could discover through conversation. Or maybe the CFO has a granddaughter who’s really attached to this. We never know until we start having those conversations with folks in our ecosystem who are already there, kinda naturally. And that’s a more equitable practice, I think, to start looping folks in, instead of going after the easy button of “who do you know, and how can we get them to write us a check.”
Rachel Muir: I love that. That’s awesome. And that reminds me, Julie, you shared something really great in your session. It was one of your blog posts or on your newsletter about leveraging your LinkedIn network. I don’t know if you wanna put that in the chat, but that’s a great one.
I’m gonna introduce our friend Kent, who I met eons ago at a fundraising conference. And here’s something amazing about Kent. Okay, he’s a genius. He’s written all these books. He’s fantastic. I’m gonna put his little bio in here. But here’s something epic about Kent that you can’t tell right now, but that’s really unique. Kent is really, really tall. If Kent stood up right now, we’d see his kneecaps. He’s just an epic, epic fundraising genius. The pearls of wisdom were falling out of the sky like confetti at a wedding. He’s got several books. He’s a fundraising legend and has taught and made so many great fundraisers better at their fundraising.
Some of the truth bombs that you shared that I wanna share: boards don’t own what they did not create. True that, a hundred percent. You also said people don’t own what they don’t create. To improve board performance, we have to evaluate board performance, which I will throw up our poll on in just a second here. You have this awesome Navy SEAL quote: under pressure, you don’t rise to the occasion, you sink to the bottom of your training. That’s why we train so hard. Did I get that right? Oh my gosh. And then also inviting people to ask what legacy as a board or as an individual member do you want to have?
So I’m gonna ask you a question, and then I’ll pop up that poll so that we can know how often people are evaluating their boards. I think this is an interesting one. It kinda speaks to what we’re talking about so far. What methods have you used to create a more open atmosphere so board members can share their feelings and fears more honestly with our executive director and with the entire board? I love this question. It’s a very heartfelt question. Board members aren’t vulnerable enough to talk about their challenges or the actions that they’ve taken. So how do we help them?
Kent Stroman: Yeah. That really is a great question. In a way, part of this goes back to the other question you shared earlier. A lot of times when we see what looks like resistance, it’s uncertainty about trust. As a board member, here’s what I don’t wanna do. I don’t wanna give you the name of somebody, because I don’t know, you’re gonna call them up and say, “Oh, Kent said that you had all this money and didn’t know what to do with it, and that you want to give it to us.”
So do we have clarity? For example, do we have a board-established confidentiality policy that talks about how we do what we do? Do we revisit occasionally the donor bill of rights? When we underscore those things, then ultimately what we’re doing is making it both clear and safe to share information and to know that I’m not gonna be taken advantage of. People oftentimes don’t say that. They just don’t give you the name. Right?
But more directly on the topic of creating an open atmosphere, one of the things we recommend is that on every board agenda, usually as the last item, we have an executive session. And go into executive session all the time, which makes it not scary. Because right now, nobody goes into executive session, and when we do, somebody’s getting fired. Right? But if the purpose of executive session is where the board talks about how we are doing, how did we do tonight or this afternoon, and you can have executive session with the CEO or without the CEO as appropriate, think about it: what opportunity do board members have to meet together in the context of a board meeting without the executive?
Somebody said, “Well, if we did that, no one would know what to do.” Well, nobody knows what to do on stuff they’ve never done before. Right? So when you make it regular, put it on the agenda every time. And then our job, if we’re not members of the board, is to equip the members of the board to do their job. We can’t do it for them, but we have to give them the equipping so that they can do what needs to be done, and do it in a way that’s clear and constructive and meaningful.
Rachel Muir: I love that. I’m gonna go ahead and launch this poll for folks to take. Hopefully, you guys are... Do you guys see it up?
Kent Stroman: Yep.
Rachel Muir: Okay. Cool. So this was one of the questions. If a board isn’t doing any kind of assessment on their performance as a group or their performance as individuals, I mean, we get evaluated for our performance as employees. There isn’t really a lot of accountability. We’ve got a lot of people participating in this, and this is interesting. Oh, wow. 84% have never done a board assessment. That is 87. This is getting... 91%. 93. What? My goodness. Kent, when you see that, what’s your reaction? What are your thoughts?
Kent Stroman: Well, I wanna cry, because it’s normal. And what we don’t wanna do is what’s normal. We wanna do what’s best practice and what’s effective. In fact, if you need somebody to blame, you can blame me at the next board meeting. And that is to say that the board has no authority to evaluate the performance of the CEO until after the board has evaluated the performance of the board. When we do that, it puts a condition: of course, we should evaluate the performance of the CEO, but first. Right? So we need to make that normal.
Rachel Muir: I love that. Okay. I’m gonna do another poll for my beautiful Lauren, because you talked about onboarding. You really talked about how it’s not the board members. It’s us. We’re not training these people enough. I think back to a job I had once where I spent a whole half day in hour-long sessions with different leadership teams just as onboarding, and it was so fun. It was so fun. So you guys are taking this poll now. I’m gonna ask Lauren one of her questions.
Okay. This is an interesting one. This might get us into a whole fascinating place. Do you suggest an amount for give or get, as opposed to a personally meaningful gift? We have board members who are students, undergraduate and graduate.
Lauren Tudor: Yeah. Do I suggest an amount? It depends. I think “personally meaningful” sounds super kind, and I know why we lean on that kind of language, but it does a lot of nothing for people sometimes. So getting really clear on what that means is important. If we’re dealing with audiences who may be at the beginning of their careers, then I think it’s important to at least share some confines or even some parameters around what that might look like for them.
In that particular instance, I do believe in picking a number quietly that would ladder up to the overall goal, because we want folks to understand this is a coaching opportunity for this young person, in this either junior board or even regular board, to understand how fundraising is the lifeblood of these organizations and that their contributions matter, and ultimately ladder up to closing that operational gap. So for your students, they have to understand that point. They have to understand the budget. They have to understand how all of it works together. And we get to really be a guiding hand in that particular arena. So I’d say at least a flat minimum, so that they can figure out creative, different ways that they might even get to that goal.
Rachel Muir: And I love that you talked about transparency around that, because I feel like that’s one thing that nonprofits don’t do. They may have a budget amount for the board giving, but it’s not in the budget that the board members see. And it’s like, well, this is not visible at all. What’s your reaction here, Lauren? 21% of the people here, and this is over 150 people participating, just get a binder. And then 53%, there’s one meeting. What are your thoughts about this? Does this echo what you’re seeing?
Lauren Tudor: Oh, that’s super... I think that too is super normal. I’m curious about how folks are experiencing half-day training. I’d love to see some insights out of that. Half-day trainings plus thirty-, sixty-, ninety-day check-ins is really wise. Maybe a bit too much checking in. I don’t know. It depends on the type of organization and that board. I’m a proponent of a ninety-day check-in, maybe twice a year. But yeah, that’s right in alignment with what we’re seeing now.
Rachel Muir: Yeah. This is an interesting question, and this is one that Beth asked, specifically of Kent, in the Q and A. How should board training be addressed? Ongoing or one big training session? And I’ve got a poll up inviting people to let us know how much training you’re giving your board members. What recommendations do you have for training your board members, and how frequently should it be?
Lauren Tudor: I personally am a big proponent of a couple of times a year, because the year fluctuates, things happen, the government changes, economic disasters happen, natural disasters happen. The board should be prepared for almost every kind of scenario so that they can spring into action when or if those things occur. So we’re not sitting there kinda dumbfounded like, “Oh my god, we weren’t anticipating this grant to stop today.” We can train this governance body to live up to its highest and number one priority, which is fiduciary oversight. So let’s get them prepared for the pivot.
Rachel Muir: Kent and Julie, I’m gonna invite you to share any advice that you have around frequency, content, just how fundraising training should be done and how it can help a nonprofit with their board.
Kent Stroman: Well, one thing I would say is sometimes I think our terminology gets in the way. I don’t ever do board training, because boards don’t perceive that they need to be trained. They are the pros, and we need to be learning from them, even if it’s topics they know nothing about. So we just do equipping. And anybody can be equipped. Dogs and cats get trained. Horses get trained. Board members don’t get trained. You say that’s a small thing, but one of the things that we recommend, and I think somebody put this in the chat box, is that every board agenda also has a board moment. And that is where we’re exploring best practice.
Just for a minute, I’m gonna use an example that’s close to me. The framework of my board book, the intentional board, is the 17 laws of the intentional board. Whether it’s that book or something else, bring a focus that says part of what we do on this board is we’re constantly elevating our effectiveness as a governing body. And so the board is gonna learn together. By the way, this isn’t a staff function. Staff were disqualified.
When the board chair, or better yet the chair of the governance committee, says, “This year, our focus is gonna be on the intentional board, and at our next board meeting I’m gonna bring a focus. I selected law number three, and I’m gonna give a three-minute synopsis” (I can’t say the word) “a three-minute summary of law number three, and then we’re gonna spend two minutes talking about what the relevance is to our organization.” And the reward for the person who does that is they get to choose the person who’s gonna do it next month. So it’s not one voice all the time, but there is one common thread. And who gets the most out of that? The person that prepares for it. Right?
Over the course of a year, if we meet monthly, we’re gonna have a dozen of our members taking part in this board equipping. And when they are hearing from each other, they will listen differently than if I show up in a room. So that’s thing one.
Thing two, I would just say, if the board doesn’t already have it, create a culture of, at least annually, a full day of board retreat. A time away together, and it’s purposeful. It’s significant enough that people will go out of their way to do it. And when we do it well, the job of everybody there is to make sure that everybody who wasn’t there regrets it: “I wish I’d have been there.” Right? But usually what we do is, “Yeah, I wasted a whole day reading reports that could have been an email.” So anyhow, those are just the few.
Rachel Muir: I love that. You know, that makes me think of, when people ask, and this is a question from Beth, should I do training ongoing or one big training session? Think about that retreat that everyone loved and everyone talks about, and they’re sad they missed it. Think about the things that we do in a retreat, the funny things that we do and the experiential things we do and the hands-on things we do. And I always tell people, try to make fifteen minutes, ten minutes out of one board meeting to do a miniature version of that, because that’s a good way to sneak a lot of great fundraising training into a regular ongoing board meeting.
Julie, I’ve got a question for you, and this really speaks to the undercurrent, the general malaise, of how do I get unengaged board members to be engaged? Of course, we’re gonna train them. Of course, we’re gonna onboard them. These are all really big pieces. But I wanna learn more about the earned revenue committee that you started when you were executive director of a nonprofit. I think that’s a really great example of you taking board members and people out in the community and creating excitement around volunteering that really influenced the bottom line of a nonprofit. Tell us more about what you did there.
Julie Shannan: This committee changed my life, changed the organization’s life like nothing else I’ve ever seen. And I have never been a huge fan of earned revenue. Of course, I love it, but it’s hard to figure out, because I really like the mission, and I wanna give it away for free as much as possible, and I want to raise money for that.
VentureLab is entrepreneurship education for kids. We had curriculum and training and programs. During COVID, we really needed to have a different push into more of who’s gonna pay for this besides the schools and a few donors. We had a lot of startup people around us. So we asked for their chief revenue officers, their chief technology officers, people that were head of revenue marketing, to help us with a three-month, one-hour-a-month, very low-lift engagement, and it was our earned revenue committee.
And by the way, a lot of people do believe nonprofits should be sustainable on their own, because they want nonprofits to stop asking for so much. I don’t necessarily agree with that, but it is a true belief, and we tapped into that. We’re like, you’re telling us this? Hey, why don’t you help us? Because it is important to be able to have an arm that’s sustainable and helps you.
This helped us. This was hard, y’all. I had to learn a lot. They wanted to look at all of my metrics. They wanted to look at everything. Every click, every engagement, everything we had that we were giving away, we looked at it all. And it felt like I was putting my diary out online for them, and it took a lot of work. But we raised our earned revenue from $25,000 to $200,000 in one year. And that is significant. Think about it: these guys have had major exits. We’re in Austin, so we have a big angel bench in the venture community, people they were investing in. So that was super helpful.
I also wanna mention the trainings. I lead a mission raising workshop, and I do that virtually, because a lot of times board members are even afraid to talk about your organization in the wrong way. They’re afraid to talk about it, so they don’t talk about it, or they’re afraid to get that mission statement wrong, which is so hard, and so they don’t mention it. So we practice talking about your mission statement in your own words, talking about a mission moment, talking about an impact moment. We practice it in the workshop, because I think that’s part of the fear of even talking about the org: how do I do that?
Rachel Muir: I love it. So I’m gonna ask a couple of questions, and Lauren, feel free to answer, and anyone else who wants to answer. This is interesting, and I feel bad for the person that asked this question, because I’ve been there, and they’re clearly going through some pain. In general, there were a few questions about people who... How do I remove a board member that is not participatory or helpful when there have not been term limits established? And a kind of corollary question: what do I do if I’ve got some micromanaging board member who’s gone completely rogue and they’re not complying with the bylaws? Problem children, Lauren.
Lauren Tudor: Oh, problem children. They’re the best. Just kidding. Actually, they kind of are. They are gifts, even though we have to mindset-shift how we see some of that stuff. Most of the time, this is actually a bylaws problem. And these things can be fixed inside of a board meeting, to Kent’s earlier point about executive session and some of those other things. Those things can be fixed too by putting term limits in place and assigning everybody a class, or, you know, populating that against what some of those things are. You could enforce some of those immediately.
I’m gonna leave the problem child alone, because we wanna make it fair and palatable and equitable across the board. But maybe for some people who’ve been in place for a really long time where there haven’t been term limits, you could set the new standard that their terms end at the end of the year, and we start fresh in the new year. That’s a great way to tighten up the systems and overhaul what hasn’t been working historically. Then you apply that to the whole board at once, so that nobody gets singled out, nobody gets the big long speech, and people end up finishing with a date, and they get to finish with dignity. It is important that we still recognize dignity is a virtue.
While you’re putting some of those things in place, you could lean into, okay, how are we gonna have some checks and balances so that this does not happen again in the future? Maybe you start with implementing more of a survey approach. Six months later, after those term limits have been rewritten into the bylaws, we ask folks where they are in their journey. Just straight up ask them, “What would make this more useful for you, your service? How can we support you along in your board journey? We see the end of your term is the following year,” or whatever. Because somebody who’s getting nothing out of this experience will very often tell you in so many ways. And generally, we should do a much better job of allowing them that out. Just allowing them that out, so they get to leave with their dignity intact. You get some very clear parameters to work within, and business can go on as usual. So that’s how I would approach it.
Rachel Muir: I love it. Kent, I’m curious if you have anything to add, but I have another question for you. And that is, how do you hold board members accountable for the commitments that they made?
Kent Stroman: Yeah. Well, great question. I think to be effective, we have to define “you.” How do you hold board members accountable? If “you” is staff, you don’t. Because the board and the board members are not accountable to the staff. So this has to be a function of the board. And ideally, it’s the governance committee. The governance committee functions year round. A lot of organizations have a nominating committee. Get rid of that. Nominating is occasional. Governance is perpetual.
Whatever the issues are, if you think about a year, we start the year with an individual commitment, where each person says, “Here’s what you can expect from me this year.” That’s a matter of record monitored by the governance committee. Then as we approach the end of the year, we’re asking that question, how are we doing? And we do this old-fashioned thing called a report card. We’re either doing really well or we’re doing terrible or someplace in the middle.
I tell you, I chaired a board one time that had an attendance requirement, a minimum attendance. And the top corporate leader in the community was not meeting that requirement. I might be tall, but I was a little guy in the community who had to go sit down with this big guy and have a conversation. I said, “We’ve got this requirement in the bylaws, and notice that this year, your actual fell below the expected. How do you see that changing going forward?” That’s the hard thing: there is a standard, there’s something to measure against, and the measurement didn’t equate. And here’s what he told me. He said, “Kent, my schedule doesn’t belong to me. When my employer calls, I’m gonna respond there before I’m gonna check on my volunteer commitments. So it’s probably gonna get worse going forward.”
And then I love what he said next, because it’s a very merciful thing that he said. He said, “You know, I could probably help the organization more off the board than I can on the board.” I started breathing again at that moment.
But here’s the thing. If the board chair doesn’t have that conversation, especially with the most visible, I’m gonna use the term “violator,” then what that tells everybody is that it just doesn’t matter. Ultimately, we have to decide if stuff matters or not. The way I approach it is, if it’s in the bylaws, that says we think it matters. Just for fun, in a board setting, I’ll ask people, just for a moment, turn and look at the person on your left. Now turn and look at the person on your right. Which of them would you rather share a jail cell with? Well, you can guess how that goes. Right? That’s an exaggeration. But the point is that stuff matters. If we don’t abide by the laws that we make, nobody, even us, can expect that we’re abiding by laws that we don’t make. The laws of the state, the municipality, whatever. We have to create this realization that important stuff is important. And if we called it important once and put it in the bylaws, and it’s not important anymore, let’s take it out.
Not that we’re applying something to an individual that we don’t like that’s selective. Lauren, I think you did a good job of using a reference to justice. If there’s an attendance requirement or whatever the other thing is, it either matters or it doesn’t. If it doesn’t matter, take it away. If it does matter, treat it like it matters. And here’s the thing: you only have to remove somebody from the board once in a generation if it’s done properly, because nobody wants to do that. And then we also have ways to create off-ramps that don’t require a fatal collision.
In fact, earlier this week, another consultant shared with me, be cautious about policies that exist only for conflict avoidance. Do we have conflict avoidance policies? Right? Because we want everything to be easy and charming, but it’s not always that way. If we have a clear policy, it’s consistently applied, it has purpose behind it, then rest in that, rather than be anxious about how to make sure nobody ever feels any conflict.
Rachel Muir: I love that. Lauren and Julie, is there anything that you’d like to add to that?
Lauren Tudor: No. I sent up a bunch of hearts for that. So true. Let’s not have a lopsided set of bylaws that are so conflict-avoidant. I love how you said that. That was really great. Let’s have a balance of, okay, this is what happens when we win; this is what happens when we need to have hard conversations; this is what happens in case of emergency. Have it be comprehensive. That’s great.
Rachel Muir: And I love what the person said to you, Kent, about “I’m gonna be able to do more not on the board.” I like to think of it in terms of graceful exits. And going back to something genius that Lauren shared, I think it was dignity. To the person who’s clearly having a hard time, who’s got someone who’s gone a bit rogue and needs to be let go: sometimes we need to prune our garden of board members, and sometimes people need greener pastures. No matter what, though, I want them to go out in the community and only say wonderful things about you. And you can make that happen by showing them gratitude.
Maybe they’re not fundraising. Maybe they hate fundraising, and maybe they claim they’re allergic to fundraising. Even we know that’s not a real allergy. Maybe you’ve done the onboarding. Maybe you’ve done the evaluation. Maybe it’s just a fluke. We all know that it may not be a fluke. But if it is, you can say, “You know, we own this. We didn’t set the right expectations. We gave you the wrong idea. That’s on us. Relax. As of now, you don’t have to worry about this anymore. You don’t have to serve anymore. We’d love to keep you involved. We’d love to just ask you questions from time to time and contact you as an adviser. Would that be okay with you?” Yes. You know? And thanking them, like writing them a thank-you note, so that no one has to feel shame or resentment or like a failure.
Julie Shannan: Well, and to add to that, it’s part of the interviewing process. We’ve lost the interviewing process for being on a board. It’s like, “Oh, you’re a warm body. You know us. Okay, get on our board.” So I also think these smaller committees, these roundtables, these opportunities, advisory committees, are an opportunity to get to know people and how they are understanding what it means to be part of your organization, before we ask them to marry us and manage us, because they’re gonna be your managers. And sometimes if they don’t know what they’re doing, it’s really not great to be on the other side of it.
Rachel Muir: A hundred percent. So I’ve got a question for Kent. How is a governance committee different from an executive committee? And another question related to that was, how do you have an executive session with the CEO?
Kent Stroman: Let’s see. Which order do you wanna... Do you wanna attack those, Rachel?
Rachel Muir: You pick.
Kent Stroman: Yeah. So executive session, by definition, is when only the voting members of the board are in the meeting. Now, hopefully, your chief executive officer, executive director, whatever you call them, hopefully that person is not a voting member of the board, because if they are, you can’t meet without them. But in executive session, the board can selectively include anybody who, by definition, is not included, the CEO being an example. Right?
But again, if we never meet, and we only do this when there are bad personnel problems, then everybody’s always nervous anytime you say the word “executive” followed by “session.” People panic. Right? That’s why I wanna normalize it. I was in higher ed for twenty-five years, and most of those years, I was never a member of the board, but I was almost always in the boardroom. When the board went into executive session, that was like my get-out-of-jail-free card. Right? I got to leave. I wasn’t welcome. And it wasn’t personal. It was positional. So we wanna build clarity around that. I’m trying to remember, Rachel, what the first part of the question was.
Rachel Muir: How is the governance committee different than an executive committee?
Kent Stroman: Yeah. So the executive committee... And by the way, I can give you opinions. The real answer is in your bylaws. If you don’t have an executive committee defined in your bylaws, you don’t have one, unless the bylaws allow for additional committees as determined by the board. Right? But I want a governance committee that’s a standing committee that has a specific focus, and it’s on attracting, engaging, evaluating, and when necessary, releasing members of the board. Okay? It’s how the board does the work of the board.
The executive committee typically is made up of the officers: the board chair, the vice chair, the secretary, the treasurer, and oftentimes also the CEO of the organization. And if the executive committee is structured like the original intent, it exists to act on behalf of the board outside of regular board meetings, so kind of an emergency situation. One of the recommendations that we make in the intentional board is, if you have a regular meeting scheduled for the executive committee, you should disband it. Because when that happens, it ends up disenfranchising everybody who’s not on the executive committee. Right? Here’s what executive committees end up doing: they have nothing to do, so they do the stuff everybody else is supposed to be doing, and everybody gets frustrated in that process.
So again, for every committee, you’ve got the bylaw definition of the composition of it. But make sure you have a written committee guide that says, here’s the purview of the committee, here’s how we meet, here’s how we report, here’s the stuff that we do, here’s the consequence of our functioning well, and here’s the consequence when we don’t function well. Once people know that and once they take ownership of it, okay, this isn’t a staff concern. It has staff implications, but the staff can’t create it. They can’t dissolve it. They can’t make it function well. Make the board work the work of the board.
Rachel Muir: I’m gonna invite Lauren and Julie for this one. How do you feel about or handle a founder on the board? Our founder still sees fundraising like it was when they founded the organization forty years ago, and we’re not the same in 2026. Oh, founder syndrome.
Julie Shannan: I mean, immediately start an advisory board and have them move over to it. I do think founders have unique situations where they come in and out a lot of times. They have a lot of attention on you, and then they leave, and they’re doing something else. And then they come back. It can be very disruptive. Not all founders are like that. But if they’re staying on the board, I would ask them, “Hey, will you head up our advisory board? Will you help us get that started? We’d like you to be the first to do it.”
Rachel Muir: Julie has firsthand experience. Lauren, what would you say? Lauren and Kent too.
Lauren Tudor: That’s so true. Yeah. We’ve been there. It’s a sticky and delicate and political one at times, but I absolutely agree with that method. It can be really difficult for them to let go and allow for new breath and new life to come in. So we have to create conditions for success for them to feel like they’re being offloaded in ways that are respectful, not just putting them out to pasture. There is a delicate balance to that. And yes, if the organization has changed and they’ve been in that position for forty years, my goodness, then it’s also time to have a really honest conversation about what the realities are for the next forty years. That’s something, ideally, any reasonable founder can stomach and can handle.
Julie Shannan: And to add to that, a lot of times the rest of the board will not do anything different than what that founder is going to do. So you’ve really got a stagnant groupthink there, where people just don’t feel comfortable saying anything different than the founder.
Rachel Muir: Which is all the more reason to put them on an advisory board.
Kent Stroman: Yeah. Probably the only thing I would just kinda caution about a little bit, and we’re probably using it as vernacular here, is that there’s only one structure in the organization that has the word “board” on it. Otherwise, you end up with confusion. And so having advisory...
Julie Shannan: The council. Right.
Kent Stroman: And then the other thing is, people don’t own what they don’t create. So I wanna work with the founder to say, let’s build a bridge that helps you and the organization move from this place to the next place. What might that be like? If we ask them to help build the bridge, it’s different than saying, “You build the bridge, and then we’re obligated to your definition.” Right? So we wanna engage their mind and heart, their experience, all that, in the process. And then, back to transparency and openness: here’s where we were, here’s where we are now, here’s where we wanna go. How do we get from here to there?
Again, depending on the board membership of that person, this is probably something in the executive session that the board members need the freedom to talk openly about. And even if that person is a member of the board, I would ask, “Would you give us the freedom to step outside this executive session? We wanna make sure that nobody’s holding anything back.” Right? And if we don’t create that environment, it just won’t exist.
Rachel Muir: I love that. This is the question I’m gonna pose to everybody. Can you talk more about attributes and expectations of board members and/or officers? I think this is a good opportunity to talk about what realistic expectations are, and when and how we have those conversations with folks. Obviously, Lauren, you’re gonna go with onboarding.
Lauren Tudor: Yeah. I am. I’m gonna pick onboarding every single time, and then somewhere in the middle as well.
Kent Stroman: Well, when you have clear expectations in writing, that’s how we know they’re clear. But what we’ve found is the best time to introduce expectations is when a person’s in a position of not having something they want. Right? Nobody wants to get onboarded after they’re onboard. So how about we start the onboarding process with the prevote, and even pre-service, equip them to do the job, which helps them know if they wanna do the job and helps us know if they want to do the job? Because we’re more attentive.
And then there’s the whole thing about normalizing ongoing board development, how we do what we do and how we do it better. If that’s a rare thing that happens every forty years or twenty years or even once a year, then that’s the exception to the rule. But if it’s the stuff that happens in every board meeting, that’s what’s normal.
Rachel Muir: I love that. That brings me to a question, and I’m gonna invite you, Julie, if you wanna answer this. Going with what Kent just suggested, the bigger question is how do we create opportunities to date prospective board members? But the real question was, we’re small. We’ve only got three people. The warm body comment is how we had to start. We need to grow our board, but we can’t fire the three that we have. How do we work our way out of this hole? So the real question is, how do I start dating prospective board members before I get married and walk across the aisle?
Julie Shannan: I love that question. I have a Mission 500 club for smaller nonprofits, and it’s just one coaching session a month. A lot of times they’re small. They’re growing. They don’t know how. They’re like, “I don’t know anyone, and I don’t know anyone that knows anyone, because I don’t know anyone. Where do I start?” And so we started with friends of friends that may be willing to come in and do a tour and learn about what they’re doing and then give us advice. I think it’s really important to start listening, and when you’re starting out and growing like that, ask: who do you think we should be bringing around us?
That tour that we did last week ended up turning into this: she’s willing to do a workshop and invite her friends and invite new friends. The person we invited is super excited to be getting back into reclaimed wood, and so it’s kind of exciting for everyone. I would also say along those lines, to add on to your earlier question, they need to be required to see your programs in action. If they don’t see what you do, if it’s not possible to experience your mission, how are they gonna talk about it? How are they going to think about you? So I also think that’s important.
Rachel Muir: Love it. Jess, you’re back. We’ve got some winners, and I know you’re gonna do a poll to invite folks if they wanna hear more from Lauren, from Kent, from Julie.
Jess Cronk: Yep. I’ll go ahead and launch the poll. And before I announce the winner, Rachel, is there anything you wanna wrap up for the group today?
Rachel Muir: I’m so grateful to each of you. I’m gonna pop the links in here for folks who may have missed your sessions or only been able to go to one. You guys knocked it out of the park. So many pearls of wisdom. I’m just saying to everybody, if you missed any one of these three, go back and watch it. Check out Kent’s book, Lauren’s resources, Julie’s resources. You guys were fantastic and amazing. And if you’re not happy with the board you have now, just know that this is a process. It takes time. We don’t come out of the cereal box as great board members, and onboarding is a really important part.
Kent Stroman: Rachel, a cereal box. Are you kidding me?
Jess Cronk: Thanks for that, Rachel. So, yes, before we wrap up, please go ahead and respond to the poll. If you’d like to hear more from Kent, Lauren, Julie, or even us at Bloomerang, we’re regularly pushing out enhancements to the product. I mentioned it yesterday, but I’ll say it again because we’re very excited: this week, we launched DAFpay across all of our online fundraising forms. We’re just continuing to improve the system to help you all reach your goals, especially during this time of year, the year-end giving season.
Okay. Now the moment you’ve all been waiting for. Our winner for today’s $250 Uber Eats gift card is Tiffany Burnett. Congratulations, Tiffany. Hope you enjoy that, and I hope your team enjoys it. Awesome. Okay.
Kent Stroman: Yay Tiffany.
Jess Cronk: Thank you so much again, Kent, Julie, Rachel, Lauren, and for everyone joining us today. I wish you a great end of year and a very successful year-end giving season.
Julie Shannan: Thank you. Thank you.
Kent Stroman: Great job, you guys.
Rachel Muir: Thank you.
Lauren Tudor: Thank you all for having us.
Key takeaways:
- Board engagement improves when you make the work about the person you’re recruiting. Julie Shannan describes hosting a community roundtable (an hour and a half, lunch provided) that opened doors to lobbyists and community connectors. People would rather connect with their peers than learn about your organization.
- Stop asking board members for their network. Lauren Tudor says “who do you know?” becomes an awkward status question, especially for working managers. Start with who is already in their orbit, such as vendors, service providers, and company match programs, and invite those people into conversations about your mission.
- Evaluate the board before you evaluate the CEO, and make it normal. After a poll showed about 93% of attendees have never done a board assessment, Kent Stroman said the board has no authority to evaluate the CEO until it has evaluated itself. He also recommends an executive session on every agenda so it stops feeling scary.
- Equip your board instead of “training” it. Kent recommends a board moment on every agenda and at least an annual full-day retreat. Lauren recommends a half-day onboarding with check-ins at about 90 days and twice a year, and money conversations set before someone joins.
- Hold members accountable through the bylaws, and give them graceful exits. Kent says accountability belongs to a year-round governance committee, and that a rule either matters or it should be removed. Lauren suggests applying new term limits to the whole board at once so people finish with dignity.
Every act of generosity starts here.
Empower your team to connect deeply and fundraise confidently.


