The intentional board
Why doesn't your board work the way it should? And how do you fix it?
If your board meetings feel like a formality instead of a force for good, you're not alone. Stroman's 17 Laws of the Intentional Board show you how board members can become highly effective in mutually beneficial, fully satisfying board service.
Learning Objectives:
- Understand principles for stronger governance
- Discover how board members can make greater impact
- Equip governance teams to make better decisions
Download the 17 Laws of the Intentional Board handout and quiz
Download the 5 Organizational Roles handout
Check out The 5 Most Common Ways Board Members Undermine Their Own Effectiveness
Transcript:
Jess Cronk: Hello. Good afternoon, and welcome to the third day of Fundraiser Focus Week. My name is Jess. I am the VP of customer marketing, events, and partnerships here at Bloomerang. I am joining you from sunny, well, kind of sunny, it’s somewhat cloudy, Tampa, Florida.
Today’s session is The Intentional Board with Kent Stroman of Stroman and Associates. To give you a quick overview of what you can expect today, it’s a thirty-minute session, just like Monday and Tuesday were this week. We will have no live Q&A at the end. Instead, I would like you to put your questions in the Q&A box, and we are going to save those and dig into them a bit deeper during our panel webinar tomorrow.
A few housekeeping notes before we get started. This session is being recorded, and yes, you will receive the recording and slides later today when we wrap up. At the end of today’s presentation, I will be giving away a $50 Uber Eats gift card. You must be in attendance to win, and if you join for tomorrow’s panel, we will also be giving away a gift card, but it will be for $250 so you can share with your teams.
If you’re not familiar with Bloomerang, we are a giving platform built for purpose, created to help nonprofits just like you build stronger relationships and grow your impact. We have tools like donor management, volunteer, online fundraising, peer to peer campaigns. They are all designed to help you thrive, and we believe that when you have the time and insights that you need, you can focus on what truly matters, making a difference in your communities and your mission. If this resonates with you, let’s connect. I’d love to help out.
I’d also like to invite you to our annual conference, GiveCon. This is coming up next May. This is the conference where fundraisers are moving missions forward. We have planned over 100 CFRE certified sessions. You will experience an engaged community of peers and immersive experiences. This conference is an amazing place to learn, connect, recharge, and turn your ideas, much like the ones you’ll learn on this webinar today, into action. Our prices go up on November 1, which is next week, so if you are interested in joining, use the QR code and register today.
All right. Without further ado, I would love to welcome Kent. Kent, please take it away.
Kent Stroman: Well, thank you, Jess, and it’s great to be here.
I glanced at some of the names as people were checking in. And how cool is that? It looks like the big debate today is how cold it is. And the good news is where I am, it’s not really cold. It’s a beautiful, beautiful fall day in Oklahoma. I’m trying to see if I can get my screen to share. So if you would just let me know, Danny, how that’s showing... Jess.
Jess Cronk: Looks great, Kent.
Kent Stroman: Okay. Great. Well, thank you for the opportunity to spend some time in the fundraising focus.
And the topic, The Intentional Board, where did that come from? Well, I’ll share a little bit more about that later. But it’s amazing to me how often I’ve had these phone calls. It starts with a phone call. So many times, someone will say... Usually it’s an executive director or a board chair. They’re having some kind of challenge in the boardroom. And so I’ll listen to them, and eventually, I’ll hear a phrase something like this: “I just feel like we’re not on the same page.” So it’s a common frustration.
So I’ll ask a couple more questions about it, and we get more of the same thing. We’re just not on the same page. So then I ask, would you please send me the page, the page that we’re not on? And almost always, the response is, “Well, we don’t have one.”
And that has given rise to this thing that we call the law of the page, one of the 17 laws of the intentional board that are in my first book, or excuse me, my second book, The Intentional Board. But here’s the reality: you can’t get on the page if there’s not a page. And so one of the things that we want to do today as it relates to board service and charitable organization leadership is give a little bit of focus on some of those basics. As I mentioned, The Intentional Board is built on this framework of the 17 laws of the intentional board, and we’re going to touch on just a couple of them during today’s presentation. What you see on the screen right now is the second edition of The Intentional Board, available on Amazon or wherever you like to get your content.
But why does board governance matter? Well, a lot of reasons, but one I want to point out is public trust. In charitable organizations, we are not owned by individuals, but we’re separate organizations, separate corporations that are established for the purpose of holding the public trust. So as board members, we have that responsibility. Also, governance is where we hold responsibility for relevant missions and clarity around vision, and then ultimately impact.
In addition to that, here’s what I want to say. When we are attentive to governance, when we have stronger boards, ultimately, we raise more money. And money’s not the only important thing. I think money’s not the most important thing. But the most important things don’t happen if we don’t have adequate resources, money being the most common of those. And so be attentive to board practices and strength, if for no other reason, just for what it means from a money resource standpoint.
A lot of times we have this question: why do we even have a board? Or what is the primary purpose of a board? There are a lot of answers we could give to that, but there are two things that are really essential and crucial. What is the role of the board? Number one, to establish policy.
So when we say establish policy, what are some examples of policy? Well, bylaws. That’s usually the highest form of policy that a board will establish. Also, the board is responsible to articulate the mission and the vision for the organization, and long-term strategic goals. The responsibility also lies with the board for answering those three D questions: What’s our direction? What’s our destination? And what’s our duration? When do we want to get there? Another form of policy is financial policy, and that’s the budget. Most organizations, hopefully all, will establish an annual budget before the year begins, and in many cases, we’ll look at a multiyear budget as well. And then member expectations: what is expected of those who make up the governing body? That’s another form of policy. And then things like the confidentiality policy, conflict of interest policy, and we could go on and on and on.
But essentially, the board’s primary purpose isn’t to operate the organization. Rather, it’s to establish policy and then assess performance against policy. So here’s what we said was important. Do we come back and check in to see how we’re doing on that? As I mentioned, the contrast is for the boardroom: it’s not operations. It’s not to execute programs, but rather to establish policy and assess performance against policy.
Some of the big questions we want to ask as it relates to policies: What policies do we need that we don’t have? These are some great questions that you can take back into the boardroom and do some evaluation. What policies do we have that we don’t need? You ever had one of those? There was a purpose for it one time, that purpose is gone, but the policy is still in our policy manual. Let’s evaluate that. Are there any policies that we have that don’t need to go away, but maybe need to change? What policies do we have that we don’t follow? Wow. I hope the answer is none. But if you’re not asking that analytical question and doing that review, you’re not going to know where you stand in that regard. And then another question: what else needs to change to elevate the board’s effectiveness and the board members’ satisfaction? These are topics that should periodically be addressed in the boardroom so that as board members, we can be confident that what we are supposed to be doing is actually getting done.
Now, I don’t know if you’ve heard this quote, but it says boards don’t own what they don’t create or what they don’t help create. Think about that for a moment. Oftentimes, people tell me, “We’re suffering with low board member engagement, and it seems like our board just isn’t paying attention to stuff.” Well, think about this: boards don’t own what they don’t create. And in reality, I think we can say that even differently. It’s not just boards, not just board members, but people don’t own what we don’t create. And so rather than trying to do the work for the board, which isn’t productive, we want to do the work through the board, equip board members to do their job. We’re going to touch back on that in just a moment.
But first, I thought it would be helpful to give a distinction. We’re going to talk about the board, but we’re also going to make reference to board members. What is the board? A board is a collection of people who are elected or chosen according to the bylaws of the organization. They hold that public trust, and they establish policy and assess performance against policy. That is the work of the board. That’s the work of the group. By contrast, we have board members. A board member is an individual. The individuals collectively make up the board. They are not the same thing, even though the board is comprised of a series of board members. I think it’s helpful in our terminology to distinguish between what is the work that belongs to me as a board member. That’s “me” work. And what is the work that isn’t “me” work, but it’s “we” work? It’s the responsibility of the group.
I wish we were able to interact, because it’s so interesting to see how different people view these questions and these topics. But be alert to the activities, the expectations, and the performance. Are we assessing individual performance at the collective group level? Are we assessing the performance of the group and trying to attribute that to individuals?
So ultimately, what we want to do is equip board members for success. In fact, here’s another question. Again, I’m going to share several of these questions, and I hope that you’ll take something from today’s presentation that you can actually put to use. In fact, as we wrap up, I’m going to ask you what’s your number one top takeaway from today. But what do our board members feel unequipped or ill equipped to do? Oftentimes, we have this assumption that because they were selected to the board, they know exactly what needs to be done, how to do it, and when. And I want to challenge that. In fact, the question: how do we know what board members feel equipped, unequipped, or ill equipped to do? Don’t guess. It’s a great opportunity to ask the person who has the answer, and that person is the board member.
One of the positions we’ve taken is just to say you cannot expect board members to do anything that you have not equipped them to do. Why do we say that? Again, we have this assumption that because somebody’s elected to the board, they know what the work of the board is, they know what the organization is, they know what our pressures and priorities are, especially when it comes to fundraising. I think people in general are poorly equipped for fundraising, because it all starts in grade school where we’re selling candy bars, pizza kits, wrapping paper, and we’re told that’s fundraising because that’s how we’re going to replace the broken-down swing set on the playground. Well, if that’s where it starts, think about what that person brings with them when they come into your boardroom. What they’re equipped to do as it relates to fundraising is probably very different than the expectations. And so we want to be really intentional about equipping members of the board and equipping the board as a group to do what is needed to fulfill those responsibilities.
Quick question. I want to bring it in as a challenge: what results have I equipped our board to deliver? If ever there is a time where there’s any frustration, whether it’s frustration on the part of the CEO, the senior staff, board officers, members of the board, if you feel there’s a disconnect, we’re not on the same page, ask a little bit about that. What’s the source of the frustration? What is needed to do the job that we’ve agreed to do? And what are we doing to make sure that that’s in place, that those resources are in hand?
Here’s a quote that I love, and this is attributed to the United States Navy SEALs. It says, “Under pressure, you don’t rise to the occasion. You sink to the level of your training.” They say that’s why we train so hard. When you think about the missions that are executed by the military, in this case particularly US Navy SEALs, we want them to train hard, so that when these occasions occur, they’re sinking to the level of their training rather than rising to the occasion. And that quote actually comes out of a book that, if you haven’t already read it, I would really encourage you to get a copy of: Extreme Ownership. The subtitle is How US Navy SEALs Lead and Win. But this isn’t primarily a military tome. This is leadership. And ultimately, if our organizations are going to perform well, it’s going to be as a result of not just ownership, but extreme ownership and how we lead our organizations.
I just want to share one of the other laws. This is law number eight of the laws of the intentional board, and it says: whatever we focus on expands. Now, what’s the significance of that? One of the things I would encourage you to do as an evaluation of the board’s effectiveness is to look at the minutes of the last six board meetings. What did we actually do? And then you’re going to see some themes. Oftentimes, the theme that we see is negative rather than positive. A lot of times it’s, “Well, here’s what’s not happening.” Somebody once told me, “What we do in every board meeting is we spend a lot of time complaining about what didn’t get done since the last meeting.” Well, that may be needed, but that’s an example of a negative thing, as opposed to how we are celebrating the success from what we’re achieving as an organization.
Well, think about this: whatever we focus on expands. And ask the question: what is it on our agenda, and what is it in the interaction in the boardroom, that we want to see more of? Somebody shared a quote with me one time that said, whatever we praise, recognize, and reward, we will see more of. So what is it that we want to see more of? How are we planning to address that, to focus on it, so that that can be what expands, and we will see more of it as a result?
By the way, I just wanted to say a big thank you to Bloomerang for hosting this week’s focus on fundraising. I was telling Jess before we got started today, I’ve been a big fan of Bloomerang before there even was a Bloomerang. There have been times when I’ve used it directly, and I often recommend it because of its strong functionality to those that I have the privilege of working with.
Quick tip: to improve board effectiveness, evaluate board performance. I wish I could see everybody’s faces today, because one of the things I’ve noticed, we have the opportunity to work with a lot of different boards. Oftentimes, it’s a lead-up to a major capital fundraising campaign. But a lot of times, we have struggles in the boardroom, things that maybe aren’t meeting the standards we’d like. And so I’ll hear this comment about performance evaluation: the board is all focused on evaluating the effectiveness of the CEO, and yet they’ve never assessed the effectiveness of the board, either the board in total or the individual members of the board. Well, if we want to improve board effectiveness, we need to evaluate board performance. What is it that is important to the organization as a board? How are we doing on that measure?
Here are just some evaluation questions. How are we doing as a board? This is a really important question to be addressed in the boardroom. If you’re not on the board, you can’t answer that for the board. How are we doing as a board? What would we like to change? Do we know what members of the board would like to change? How often do we give an opportunity for these kinds of questions to be addressed? If we’re not having these evaluative discussions in the boardroom, then if it is taking place, it’s probably taking place in a venue that isn’t impactful. How might that happen if we wanted something to change?
And then a big question I would put out there is that of legacy. What legacy would we like to leave? That’s a great question both at the individual level and at the collective level. As we come to the end of this year of our organization’s leadership, what do we want our legacy to be for the year? As individual members of the board, when it’s my time to step off the board, what kind of legacy do I want to be able to leave behind?
And then similarly, to improve board member effectiveness, we need to evaluate board member performance. One of the things that we recommend is an annual report card, both at the individual level for board members and at the collective level for boards. What is expected of board members? Are we reviewing those expectations and the results that have come from the individual board member? And are we communicating that both to the individual board member and then collectively to the board? A lot of times we say board attendance is important. Do we know what our board attendance rate is for the last year, for the last eighteen months, or twenty-four months? It’s good to do those assessments and then share the results with those who are part of the overall governing team.
One other thing I wanted to touch on: we work with all varieties of charitable organizations across the country, but we’ve also been a student of organizations, whether it’s corporate, community, governmental, or charitable. Here’s one of the things we found: in every organization, there are these five functions. To govern, to lead, to manage, to micromanage, and to execute. Every one of those functions exists in every organization, and they’re all important.
What kind of activity goes with each function? Well, to govern has to do with the mission, the direction, the policy, and assessment. We’ve talked about that. To lead has to do with delegating and directing. Management is overseeing. Micromanagement is to count or to control, being attentive to what we call minutiae. And then execution is implementing what we said is important. Each of those organizational roles is assigned someplace, and you’ll notice the green stripe at the top is assigned to the board. So it’s the board’s responsibility to govern. It’s the CEO’s role to lead. It’s the job of supervisors to engage in management. The administrative staff tackles micromanagement, and then our program staff executes.
One of the most helpful things we can do, whether it’s in the boardroom or outside the boardroom, is to distinguish the things that we’re dealing with. Is it governance, or another term that I’m going to share with you in a moment, not governance? Everything is either governance or not governance. If it’s governance, it belongs to the board and it belongs in the boardroom. If it’s not governance, then it belongs in one of these other areas: two, three, four, or five. If it is not governance and it’s in the boardroom, we’ve got a problem. If it is governance and it’s being addressed outside the boardroom, that’s a problem. So in simple terms, just think about everything that comes up, ask yourself which one of these it is, because it has to be one or the other. It’s either governance or not governance. And make sure that the right function, the right role, is being addressed by the right party.
Well, I think it’s probably a good time for us to come to a conclusion. I would love for you to take a moment, whatever is the most important point that you’ve picked up on today, and drop it in the chat box. And Jess, I want to turn it back to you.
Jess Cronk: Thanks, Kent. There are some amazing questions about how to face board resistance showing up in the chat and the Q&A, so we will definitely dig into that more tomorrow. Before you wrap up, I am going to launch a quick poll.
All right, everyone should see that now. If you would like Kent to follow up with you to dig in more on some of the concepts that he shared today, please respond in the poll. And if you would like to know more about Bloomerang, let us know in the poll as well. We regularly add new enhancements. Like today, we just launched DAFpay on our online donation forms. So even if you’re already a customer, we’d love to connect with you.
Now for our raffle. Again, today we are giving away a $50 Uber Eats gift card, and if you join us tomorrow, it will be a $250 gift card. Without further ado, our winner is Brian Long. So thank you very much for joining us today, Brian, and congrats. I hope you enjoy your gift card. Maybe get something special for dinner.
Thank you so much, Kent, for joining us, and thank you, everyone, for being here. We hope to see you on the panel tomorrow and look forward to discussing things a bit more. Have a great day, everyone.
Kent Stroman: Thanks, Jess.
Key takeaways:
- Nonprofit board governance starts with a shared, written page. Kent says “we’re just not on the same page” is the most common frustration he hears, and you can’t get on the page if there isn’t one. Bylaws, mission, vision, the budget, member expectations, and confidentiality and conflict-of-interest policies are that page.
- The board’s job is to establish policy and assess performance against policy, not to run operations. Kent suggests asking which policies you need but don’t have, which you have but don’t need, and which you have but don’t follow.
- You can’t expect board members to do what you haven’t equipped them to do. Don’t guess what members feel unequipped for; ask them. Many arrive with a view of fundraising shaped by candy bars and wrapping paper.
- Evaluate the board and its members, not just the CEO. Kent recommends an annual report card for individuals and the group, tracking attendance, and asking what legacy the board wants to leave.
- Sort every issue as governance or not governance. The board governs, the CEO leads, supervisors manage, administrative staff micromanage, and program staff execute. Kent also notes that whatever you focus on expands, so review the last six sets of minutes to see what your board is actually focusing on.
Every act of generosity starts here.
Empower your team to connect deeply and fundraise confidently.


