Webinar

Your board did nothing wrong. Your onboarding did.

Most boards aren't passive by choice. They were recruited without a job and never given one.

Explore how to build the infrastructure that makes a board able to lead in the first place: clear roles, a real onboarding process, and a giving expectation set before someone joins rather than after.

Learning objectives:

  • Create roles that every board member understands
  • Design onboarding that prepares people to serve
  • Normalize giving conversations before someone joins

Check out the sessions slides here
‍

Download the One Board Seat worksheet here

Transcript:

Jess Cronk: Welcome, everyone. I’m going to give folks just a minute, but in the meantime, I’d like to introduce myself. My name is Jess Cronk. I am the VP of customer marketing events and partnerships here at Bloomerang, joining you from sunny Florida.

Today, our session is “Your Board Did Nothing Wrong. Your Onboarding Did.” with Lauren Tudor of Architect Philanthropic Collective.

Today is our second day of Fundraiser Focus Week. If this is your first time joining us, here’s what you can expect. Each session this week is thirty minutes. There is no live Q&A at the end of these sessions. I still highly recommend adding questions to the Q&A box, because on Thursday, Rachel Muir will be hosting all of our panelists from this week for an hour-long conversation that digs into those questions.

A few housekeeping notes before we get started. This session is being recorded. You will receive the recording and the slides after we wrap up today. If you have questions, again, please put them in the Q&A box so we can collect those and go through them on Thursday.

At the end of today’s presentation, we are also giving away a $50 Uber Eats gift card to a random attendee. You must be in attendance to win. If you join us on Thursday, we are giving away a $250 Uber Eats gift card that you can also share with your teams, so I highly recommend attending on Thursday as well.

If you are not familiar with Bloomerang, we are a giving platform built for purpose, created to help nonprofits build stronger relationships and grow their impact. Our tools like donor and volunteer management, online peer to peer campaigns, and custom donation forms are all designed to help organizations of all sizes thrive. We believe that when fundraisers like you have the time and insights they need, you can focus on what truly matters, making a difference in your communities. If this resonates with you, let’s connect. I’d love to help you achieve your goals.

I’d also like to invite you to our annual conference, GiveCon, the nonprofit conference that is moving fundraising and missions forward. With over 100 CFRE-certified sessions, an engaged community, and immersive experiences, this conference is a place to learn, connect, engage, and turn your ideas, especially those that you hear on these webinars, into action. Prices go up on November 1, so if you’re interested in joining, please use the QR code and register today.

Alright, and with that, I am delighted to introduce you to Lauren Tudor, a very, very special friend of mine. Take it away, Lauren.

Lauren Tudor: Thanks so much, Jess. It’s awesome to be here with you. Give me a second to share my screen. Okay, great. And we will jump right on into it.

Wonderful. Well, good afternoon, everyone. Great to be with you all here in community. I’m Lauren Tudor. Last year, I was asked to join a board seat. I get asked this question a lot. Clients tend to ask our team, but me in particular, to join their boards all the time, and we almost always say no, generally because it muddies what they hired us for.

But this one, I said yes to. I said yes to it because it was an organization I had known for a while and had a special connection to since I was a child. So I wanted them to win. I really wanted them to win, so it was an easy yes. But we put some conditions around it. I made it a temporary seat, and it had an end date to it. And quite frankly, the job was to chart a course, to get people pulling in the same direction, because that was the actual problem. The board itself wasn’t necessarily disengaged. Every single one of them cared to be on the board, but they were facing a funding shortfall that really would have flattened them completely. But they kept showing up anyway. So they were passionate, but just directionless.

I’ll go back there. In my first thirty days serving on that board, I got nothing. I am keeping the name private to protect the innocent and wonderful, but I got nothing. No role description, no onboarding, no job to do. And what do you do with that? A lot of folks have been in my seat before. The organization didn’t do anything wrong. They were underwater, and it makes perfectly logical sense that onboarding would be the first thing to go when you’re just trying to keep the lights on.

But what happens in the field and in the sector is that we end up calling these boards passive. We start putting labels on them, and we say they’re disengaged. They’re not fundraisers. I can’t get my board to fundraise. When a lot of the time, we are looking at a group of people who care a great deal and have no idea where to put that care to work.

People say yes to joining your board because they believe in your work. That is an honor, something that should be regarded really highly, especially when they clear an evening or an afternoon or a morning to be with you every month or every quarter. These folks are being recruited into a seat, yet more often than not, nobody’s ever really giving them a clear job. Directionless.

So how I want to spend the next twenty-five minutes together, give or take, is we have the conversation. We have the conversation about money. You’re going to leave here with the slides. You’re also going to leave here with a worksheet. And my challenge to you is to take that page per seat and fill out just one of them, not all nine, just one. And you will have done more board development this week than a lot of organizations do in a year.

So what does a real role contain when we’re asking someone to join us in rowing in this direction? Well, quite frankly, more than attendance. Attendance is just a condition of the seat. It is not the job. It is not the job. A lot of times we’ll see descriptions that kind of look like this: they attend quarterly meetings, serve on one committee, maybe act as an ambassador, and generally make a personally meaningful gift. All good things. All great starter descriptions. But when you read that back to what a person is actually supposed to do on a Tuesday, like today: serve on a committee doing what? How explicit is that? Ambassador to whom? How explicit is that? Nobody knows. And so they end up attending meetings and just waiting to be asked something, and then we label them as passive.

So what a real role contains looks in part kind of like this. We encourage our clients, and boards that we serve on, to give them a territory. That’s where each member picks a committee that becomes part of their patch. If it’s development or governance or operations or something like that, the committee is the job, not necessarily just the box that they sit in.

So what does that actually look like in scoping it out? Well, we attach some metrics to it. If they have a territory, then they have a number attached to that territory. So we’re looking for three to five, just a ballpark to start with, warm contacts to the development committee, plus one committee task with a due date. Small enough to actually happen. This is where boards tend to get a little bit unfairly blamed, because those things aren’t clearly articulated. No one’s told them the number, and maybe they assume that someone else had it covered, like the development director.

After we attach a number to the metric, we have to think about what a counterpart looks like. Perhaps it’s a current board member who’s their buddy on the board, who can show them the ropes, who can check in with them before their first meeting and debrief with them after the meeting to make sure understanding is clear, and they can ask the questions that they maybe didn’t feel comfortable asking in the real meeting. Committee co-chairs are really wonderful, because then they get the chance to hand them that first task. And the executive director doesn’t become the only door that gets to answer those questions.

And then finally, making it really, really clear that there is an end date in tow. When does the term start, and when does it actually end? And it’s recorded the very week that they join. Mine was pretty temporary on purpose, but it was by design, because we wanted to make sure that we could chart a course for other board members to follow after me. And it forced me to focus. What that term date did was really, really force me to focus on what needed to be implemented during my tenure between then and term end. And the best part: who to hand it off to for its next iteration and its next evolution.

So my challenge to you is to pick a board member that you can probably do something like this with. Not your chair. Don’t pick your chair. Don’t pick your problem child either. We’re going to design this particularly for the middle-of-the-pack person that you like on the board, somebody who has all this potential but maybe hasn’t been sitting in the right seat yet to be activated. And if you have some scratch paper, go ahead and write their name down, because that’s who we’re building the rest of this session for.

What we ended up doing, too, was handing them a binder, which is really great. A lot of folks, I’m sure, have done that. And the binder is great. It has the transfer documents. It’s got everything that a great board member needs just to get started. But onboarding is the space that actually transfers confidence to the member who’s joining your team. A first year builds either caution or it builds confidence, and we are shooting for the latter. The onboarding absolutely decides which one happens first.

Nobody ever says this part out loud about a new board member’s first year, but they spend a lot of it trying to figure out what they’re allowed to do. And what if we could just mitigate that for them? What if they have questions around, can I call a donor? Should I ask the ED first? Is it weird if I forward this email to my college roommate who runs a foundation? Let’s make it really clear for folks what they can and can’t do. Otherwise, they end up doing nothing, and they end up doing nothing because they hadn’t been asked yet. By the time they work out the rules on their own, it is fourteen months later, and they have already decided that they are not a fundraiser. And then they hire some consultant like us who comes in and tells them, yes, you can do this.

And so we try to walk a table just like this sequence here. In week one, they get a call from their board chair, ideally within forty-eight hours of being voted onto the board, and they’re paired with who their buddy on the board is going to be. I know some boards are really, really small. They’re probably like two or three people, and that’s okay too. People can have multiple buddies. The orientation gets recorded, and it gets reused as a refresher. And before their first meeting, they get the chance to have some time with the ED and the chair, and they get the chance to ask some of their questions that maybe they didn’t know. Perhaps this is first-time board service for them. Maybe it’s first-time board service in this particular area of interest. All of those things can happen in that first meeting there.

By the time three months comes around, we want to make sure that they’re in a committee. They’ve got a giving plan. They know what the work is before them, and they also know exactly how long they have to do that work.

And when we have the six-month check-in with them, we’re asking them four questions. What’s still fuzzy for them? What don’t they know? What do they want to know? Is the committee that they’re on the right fit? Do they not want to be on this committee? Are they more interested in that committee over there? You’re asking them where they are in their personal giving plan. We are teeing up this money conversation and continuing to beat the drum for it. And then finally, we want to ask them what would make this more useful to them. Because what that does for you is it catches a quiet board member before they drift away. Those are the four questions you want to ask about every six months, maybe even every four months, depending on how frequent your terms are.

Board members really need structured support and two practical tools to engage with their own networks. We have the responsibility to give that to them, not just a pep talk on ambassadorship, but actual tools.

And so when we looked at the board packet for the temporary service that I was on, here’s what was there and here’s what was not there. What was really great was that a lot of these files that existed were really good. They were fantastic, even. Mission and overview, the board backgrounds, and all of that stuff. But just as equally wonderful and pretty as those things are, the unsavory pieces, the more reading-heavy, very dense pieces also need to be in front of that member, because they should know what parameters they have to work within. So the bylaws and the descriptions and the directors and officers confirmation, they should know all of that in a really succinct packet that gives them a very clear picture of what they signed up for. And what that does for you is it defines the job, exactly what the role is, where and when the giving expectations should come into play, and how it all protects you as the executive director or the development director.

When we were in this particular arrangement, this happened. We had a board member who, again, was passionate and had figured out, okay, I think I can do something, especially with this funding shortfall. This is what happens when somebody gets a very clear job. He looked at his own company’s vendor list and was able to help cultivate, steward, and solicit them. And two of the vendors of his company actually became corporate sponsors to that nonprofit organization. That was a wonderful example of what it takes when we have properly prepared a member to fundraise on our behalf and do great stewardship and proper governance, too. He wasn’t really asked to fundraise. He was curious about what it looked like to cultivate three to five warm contacts, and he thought to look at his own vendor list. It was something small enough to unlock a yes for that organization, because we want our board members to introduce us to that next great prospect in addition to making sure that our doors stay open. It was really wonderful to watch that happen for that organization.

And so we always have to make sure, too, that we are having the money conversation pretty early on. The order of operations that a lot of us use is something to this effect. We recruit someone. They’re immensely flattered. They say, “Yes, I am absolutely down to join this board,” and we welcome them. We hand them that binder. It’s glossy. It’s thick, and it’s got all the stuff in it. It’s got half the stuff in it that it probably should have. And then somewhere around that third meeting, they stop bringing that binder around, and the development director says, “Okay, so about this give-or-get policy.”

And now this person is sitting there doing the math in their head about whether or not they can afford the seat that they already accepted a hundred days ago. They’re rationalizing these thoughts in public, also in front of people that they just met. So, of course, they get really quiet around fundraising, because we made their first money conversation an ambush. I can’t see you on camera, but I can kind of feel that a lot of us have probably been close to this scenario. And that doesn’t feel good. It doesn’t feel good to be in an ambush conversation.

So our recommended fix is just a timing change. Just talking about it a lot sooner. Not necessarily a policy change, but, yes, a timing change. It goes into the recruitment conversation at the first onset, before we even ask them to join the board. It goes in the same breath as the rest of the role, and we get really, really clear about what we’re saying to them.

So we talk about it before we get the yes. And we say something along the lines of, “Before you say yes, let’s talk about money. Honestly, I’d rather you hear it from me now than feel surprised three months from now. Every member of this board gives or gets $5,000, $2,500, $10,000, whatever your particular threshold is, a year. Some of you will write a check. Some of you will open the door to the person who writes that check. Both count the same. What we ask is that we are one of your top three gifts while you serve.” That’s a very clear conversation to have. It’s not yucky. It doesn’t feel like a bait and switch, and everybody’s clear about what they’re walking into. $5,000, again, might be one organization’s number, but you can swap in whatever that gift is for you. Both do count the same.

And so a person may have time to think about that, and some will say yes, and some will say no. That is okay. A person who declines over the giving expectation was going to be quiet about money for three years, and you were going to spend those three years really, really frustrated with them. So you consider the no a gift, because it is one. You’re not losing a prospective board member, either. You’re finding out eighteen months early, for free, that they were never going to be in that position for you. That is a distinction to get very comfortable with, especially as we’re having the money conversation in advance.

The people on the board, they say yes to you. And if they’re still willing, which a lot of folks are, just quietly willing, waiting for a clear ask to come through, they believe in you. We handed them a binder, and we handed them some hope. Let’s stop doing that. Let’s hand them a road map instead.

Remember the name of the person you wrote down a few slides ago? The challenge before you, before the end of this week, before Friday, is to just send them an email. Not a survey, not a binder. Send them an email and tell them one part of your fundraising that you’d like them to own or help you with. Ask them outright if that would be something that they would want to do. And that’s the whole email. Just two lines. Here’s what we’re thinking. Can you help? Really simple. Should take about ten seconds overall.

And then, with the worksheet that you’ll get after this call, it’s called One Board Seat, and it’s in the resources. Take the time to fill out the territory, the number, the counterpart, and the term. Start thinking about what that quantification of impact for actual job clarity and distinction looks like for your organization. Fill that out for each person if you have the time to do that, and see what transforms for you in a month, in the next quarter. Or, you know, we’re in Q4 now. This is a great prework exercise for going into Q1 2027, if you want to start with a clean slate there. Because if they’re still willing, give them a job. Think about what that looks like for them and what kind of rewards you and your organization get to seek.

I know the chat is blowing up. I can see some things coming in, but I am on the Ask the Expert panel this Thursday with Rachel and a few of my other peers. Bring me your messy questions. We want to answer them live on that call, especially if you didn’t put them in the chat today. Those are some of the things we want to help you tackle. And I think I’m right around time for a few other announcements. Thanks for having me here.

Jess Cronk: Thank you so much, Lauren. Folks, just give me a second. I’m going to launch our poll, and then I will get into the raffle.

Okay, wonderful. You should be able to see the poll now. If you would like Lauren to follow up with you with more information about board onboarding, please respond in the poll. And if you would like an online tour of Bloomerang, even if you’re a current customer and have questions, please go ahead and fill that out as well.

Okay, now for our raffle random selection. Congratulations to Jenny Harmeyer. You have a $50 Uber Eats gift card. Our team will be reaching out to you shortly so that you can use that for maybe dinner tonight.

Lauren Tudor: Yeah. Go, Jenny. Well done.

Jess Cronk: Congrats, Jenny. Alright, that’s everything for today. Thank you, everyone, for joining us. Thank you, Lauren, for joining us as well and lending your expertise. We will see you again on Thursday. And for everyone else, I hope you will join again tomorrow at 2:00 Eastern. Look forward to seeing you there. Okay, have a great day, everyone. Bye.

Key takeaways:

  • Boards labeled “passive” usually were never given a job. Lauren Tudor describes a board where every member cared but got no role description and no onboarding, because onboarding is the first thing to go when an organization is just keeping the lights on. The fix is clarity, not blame.
  • A real board role has four parts: territory, number, counterpart, and term. Each member picks a committee as their territory, gets a number (such as three to five warm contacts plus one committee task with a due date), is paired with a board buddy, and has an end date recorded the week they join.
  • Strong board member onboarding builds confidence instead of caution in a member’s first year. Lauren’s sequence runs from a call from the board chair within 48 hours, to a recorded orientation, to a committee and giving plan by month three, to a check-in every six months built on four questions.
  • Have the money conversation before the yes. Lauren recommends a timing change, not a policy change: state the give-or-get expectation during recruitment so it isn’t an ambush at the third meeting. A person who declines at that point has saved you eighteen months of frustration.
  • Give members one small, specific job and ask directly. One board member looked at his own company’s vendor list, and two of those vendors became corporate sponsors. Lauren’s challenge is to email one board member before Friday, name one part of your fundraising you’d like them to own, and ask if they’ll help.
Helping You Help Others

Every act of generosity starts here.

Empower your team to connect deeply and fundraise confidently.