Webinar

How to get your board members to embrace fundraising

Do your board members run the other way when you mention fundraising? Gail Perry joined us for a webinar in which she showed us how to lower your board members' fear, make it fun for them, and put them to work.

Learning objectives:

  • Identify why board members resist fundraising and how to reframe it around relationships instead of money.
  • Apply hands-on board members fundraising training, such as the “why I care” mingle exercise, to build confidence and a first elevator speech.
  • Assign non-solicitation roles, like thank-you calls, tours, and small socials, so every board member contributes.
  • Explain how thanking and stewarding donors drives giving, including Penelope Burk’s finding that board thank-you calls raised later gifts by 39 percent.

Transcript:

Steven Shattuck: Thanks for being here for today’s webinar, “How to Motivate Your Board Members to Help in Fundraising.” My name is Steven Shattuck. I’m the VP of Marketing here at Bloomerang, and I’ll be moderating today’s discussion. Our guest is Gail Perry. Very happy to have you here, Gail. Thanks for being with us.

Gail Perry: Thank you.

Steven Shattuck: For those of you who don’t know Gail, which I doubt any of you don’t, she is an international fundraising consultant, a trend spotter, a speaker, a trainer, and a thought leader. She has worked with literally thousands of board members, nonprofit leaders, and fundraising staff to give them the fundraising skills and inspiration to change the world.

Gail is a past president of the Triangle Chapter of the Association of Fundraising Professionals, which recently awarded her Outstanding Fundraising Executive of the Year. She launched her fundraising career at Duke University and also directed the fundraising program at the Kenan-Flagler School of Business at UNC-Chapel Hill. She holds an MBA and a BA with honors in English from UNC-Chapel Hill, and she is also a CFRE. Gail, this is quite an honor, so thanks again for joining us.

Gail Perry: Oh, come on. I’m a fan of y’all. It’s an honor to be here.

Steven Shattuck: This will be fun. For the next half hour or so, Gail is going to run through her presentation. Afterward, we’ll spend some time in an interactive Q&A session, so feel free to send questions through the chat box on your webinar screen. Gail and I will see them, and we’ll try to answer as many as we can.

We are recording this presentation. If you have to leave early, or want to review this content with someone else in your office, look for an email from me later this afternoon with the recording. You’ll also receive the slides from Gail. Gail, why don’t you take it away?

Gail Perry: Thanks so much. You can see a little about me on the slide. Of all my career feats, the most important thing I want you to know is my Twitter handle, because I’m very active on Twitter. If you are too, we can hang out and have some fun.

I was wondering if everybody could type into the chat box your organization and where you’re located. I’d love to know who’s here. It’s fun to see who’s here from around the country and the world. I see Big Brothers Big Sisters, symphonies, theater and arts organizations, autism organizations, YMCAs, literacy groups, Girls on the Run, a Jewish Federation, public housing, a school of acrobatics and new circus arts, a healthcare foundation, a Catholic radio station. Terrific. Thank you for sharing.

Let me tell you a little more about my story. I was a fundraising consultant, and I was so frustrated with the boards I was working with. They’d say they would, and then they wouldn’t. I’m sure you’ve run into that situation. So I hired an organizational development psychologist, a bona fide shrink, to be my business coach and teach me a different way to work with boards. He taught me team building and leadership skills, a total psychological approach based on motivational theory and group process. So the ideas I’m going to share with you are not traditional Board Development 101. I think that’s why I’m so popular: they’re realistic, they’re practical, and they’re kind to both staff and board members.

Another question: I hope there are some board members joining me today. If you are a board member, would you type that in the chat? I want to say thank you, because I think there’s a special place in heaven for nonprofit board members. I’m going to poke fun at the institution of nonprofit boards, and I don’t mean it personally. I want you to have some fun with me, because I think board members have a tough time because of the way they’re treated by staff. So this is going to be a pro-board-member point of view. I see a few board members fessing up that they’re joining us.

By the way, I do board retreats and workshops around the country. This is the Southern Appalachian Highlands Trust in Flat Rock, North Carolina. They were nervous to death about a board retreat on fundraising. They didn’t know what to think, and now look at them at the end. They’re fired up and ready to go. That’s the work of transformation that I want to teach you how to do for your board, if you don’t want to bring me or another facilitator in.

I want to start with a story that has many teaching aspects. I have a friend in Raleigh named CC, who was chair of the board of the Raleigh Little Theater. When I was writing my book, I interviewed her as board chair. “How do you feel about fundraising? Are you involved? What’s working? What’s not?” She said, “Ugh, fundraising! I told them I’d be board chair and I’d do anything but fundraising.” She was hyperventilating. I said, “Okay, back up. Let me ask you another question. What if you were the ambassador from the Raleigh Little Theater to Progress Energy?” That’s our big utility company here in town. “You didn’t have to ask for money, but you were in charge of the relationship. You were like the account manager.”

She said, “Oh, I would have so much fun. I could give them free tickets. I could bring them to cast parties. I could take them backstage.” She was smiling and laughing. Then she said, “I wouldn’t mind going along on the solicitation if I had done all that.” And I thought, “Lord have mercy, lady. You just told me you would never touch fundraising with a ten-foot pole, and here you are volunteering to go.”

What’s the learning? If we don’t make fundraising about money, and instead make it about developing the relationship and having fun with it, board members will jump right in and help in lots of ways. I’ll bring this theme up over and over from different angles.

I call on Albert Einstein, who said, “No problem can be solved from the same level of consciousness that created it.” We can have fun applying that to our nonprofit boards. The reluctance and nervousness board members feel about fundraising was created from a certain level of consciousness, and if you shift the way you’re thinking, you can solve the problem.

So, let’s have some fun. Is this your board? Board meetings can be like these Egyptian statues, frozen in time, calcified, and everybody so self-conscious. I show these slides at all my board retreats and people love them. They laugh. One time a lady in the audience raised her hand and said, “I know the person second from the left.”

Is your board bored? If you have boring meetings, you’ll have a bored board, and a bored board isn’t going to get excited about doing anything, much less fundraising. So it’s important that staff and nonprofit board leaders focus on giving board members a terrific experience. We can change our consciousness, as Einstein said, approach board members from a different angle, and get amazingly different results.

This is what happens when you raise the fundraising word to board members. They think it’s the F word, and it’s a deer in the headlights. I show this and people die laughing because it’s true. Board members don’t understand fundraising, so they make up myths about it. Before I was in fundraising, I thought these exact same things. Most of us on the call are professionals who are well trained and do this all the time, but we’re dealing with volunteers who have a completely different perspective.

First, they think it’s begging. They think of the tin cup syndrome: “Please help me. I have nothing.” And they envision themselves begging. They think fundraising is making cold calls and asking strangers for money. We know that, for well-trained professionals, it’s not about the ask, it’s about the relationship. I never believe in making cold calls, and I would certainly never send my volunteers out to make them. It’s never about the money. I’ll talk about that in a second, too. Board members also think fundraising means rejection. Why would I send wonderful, good-hearted people who want to help my cause out to have such a difficult and sad experience?

As I thought about what board members really think when we approach them with the F word, I came to realize there’s a dark side to fundraising that people don’t talk about much. It’s when it’s all about money, and not about the kids, the project, or the wonderful thing we’re doing in the world. I love this picture because I don’t know which face is worse. You mention fundraising and you get these looks on people’s faces. It doesn’t have to be that way. It’s our job to make it not about money, and I’ll show you some ways to do that. That will bring relief to a lot of people.

Board members are also not well educated about fundraising. All of these things I’m bringing you are training opportunities. Board members are smart people, and they like learning new things. Staff members, you could trot in front of your board meeting, show a PowerPoint, “blah, blah, blah,” and there are a few questions, and board members think, “Oh, that’s interesting. I’m glad she’s doing such a great job.” But board members would actually love to know more about how fundraising works. A great place to start is the cost per dollar raised of various fundraising strategies. If your board members understand your fundraising program and the strategies you use, they’ll be more helpful, and they won’t bother you with off-topic questions. We could spend a lot of time on this slide, but I wanted to include it so you can use it as a basis for discussion with your own board.

Here are a couple of other slides I use all the time when I’m training boards. Board members don’t understand the whole fundraising adventure. But many board members have some sales background, and when they look at this fundraising cycle, they recognize the classic sales cycle. I was trained by Xerox in the ’90s in professional selling skills, and I use it every day in my fundraising.

The takeaway from this slide, which lays the fundraising cycle out as a sales cycle, is that you’re beginning to show board members that fundraising is not all about the ask. There are other activities they can do that are very supportive and directly affect the bottom line, so that when you ask, your prospect is ready to be asked and your prospect loves you.

When I work with board members, I take solicitation off the plate. Take a deep breath and listen to this. I say, “You do not have to ask for money if you do not want to.” But every board member does have a job to help. You can make thank-you phone calls, you can host tours, you can welcome guests at an event. Every board member does have a job, and let’s all pitch in. When you approach board members like that, they’re gung-ho.

Then, like my friend CC at the beginning, if they’re involved in the relationship development, it’s not awkward to go along on the solicitation. What is awkward is cultivating a major donor yourself and then bringing a board member in at the last minute to help with the ask. The board member doesn’t know this person. It’s awkward. So use a different consciousness, make it fun, lighten up, and give them other jobs that don’t involve soliciting. Then they’ll warm up.

This pie chart represents one of my big “aha” moments when I wrote my book. I took the fundraising cycle and broke it into a pie chart showing how much time and energy we spend in each part. The ask is one tiny part. We spend a lot of time cultivating, a bit of time identifying, and a lot of time thanking.

Of course, you know the definition of sustainable fundraising: you do such a great job thanking that the thanking prepares the donor for the next ask. You can short-circuit the fundraising cycle with your donors. Your core group of supporters, the ones you really want your board members to love a lot, is nothing but thanking, acknowledging, and stewarding. We can talk more about that as we go.

I’m making a list of everything board members don’t understand about fundraising. My point is that they’ll help you more if they understand more about how it works. I’m from the South, and I’ve raised millions of dollars, but I’m from the soft-sell school of fundraising, where we have low pressure but very high intention.

Among the things board members don’t understand is whether they’re losing or gaining donors. They don’t understand the whole issue of retention, which, of course, Bloomerang is all about. I’m so excited that Bloomerang is beating the drum of retention. This is one of my favorite slides from their series of infographics. I would take their infographics about retention, show them to your board, and have a discussion.

This is important. If you want to do fundraising training with your board, do not make a presentation. Put this up on the PowerPoint, or use it as a handout, and say, “What are your impressions of this slide? What does this mean to us?” And force them to talk about it. I do an enormous amount of training and study adult learning like crazy, and studies show adults can only handle a maximum of ten minutes of being talked to before they lose interest. If you want your board members to really understand fundraising, you have to get them talking about it. It’s fun for them, and it’s easier on you.

Board members also don’t understand who’s doing what in the fundraising office, and they don’t know what their own role is. So this is a long list of things you can begin to stage educational conversations about with your board. I’ll bet they would enjoy it. They want to know this stuff.

Lastly, they don’t know what their real job is as board members. I’ve worked with a lot of organizations that say, “We have these expectations and everybody signs them, but then nobody does them.” If I go on a board and I’m given those expectations, I think, “These are weird. Sure, I support the mission. Sure, I can come to meetings. But what else do you want me to do?” So one thing I love to do at a board retreat is have the board members talk about what their job needs to be. And then I ask, “What are the top three issues this board needs to deal with in the coming year?” They’re all over that and ready to dive in.

I’ve just finished a long list of things board members would love to know more about, and I’ve poked some holes in the myths they make up. These are educational opportunities. But as I’ve said before and I’ll say again: if you want different results, change yourself. Make it fun and lighten up.

Here are my strategies for opening up your board members and motivating them. The first is to ask board members why they care. This picture is the Appalachian Highlands Land Trust I showed you at the beginning. The lady on the left is a very formidable and famous environmentalist and well-connected city leader. She’s chair of the board, and the young man is an heir to a very prominent North Carolina family with a foundation. When I stage board members in a mingle exercise, going around and telling each other why they care, it’s a very, very powerful conversation.

When I send my follow-up email, since I have everybody’s list, I’ll send a couple of articles from my blog on how to set up this mingle exercise. It’s easy, low-pressure practice talking about why they care. Board members love it, because it dips them in their passion for the cause. I never talk about fundraising without doing this exercise. It takes only ten minutes. You get them out of their seats talking to each other about why they care. It’s a team-building exercise, it’s fun, and it builds energy in the room.

And guess what else they’re doing? They’re practicing their first elevator speech. The number one thing we need to train board members on is how to talk about our organization. A board member once came to me and said, “Gail, when I have a chance to talk about our organization, what do I say?” I said, “Talk about why you think it’s important. Tell your own personal story.” She said, “Oh, okay, I can do that.”

Studies show board members want fundraising training that is practical and hands-on. They do not want to be presented to. They don’t want to sit passively while you present the PowerPoint. So when I do a board retreat, it’s hands-on, practicing, engaging, working with them, because that’s the only way you’ll get adult learners and adult decision makers to embrace these powerful concepts and get over their myths. I can’t overemphasize how powerful it is to ask people why they care and to have board members share that over and over.

I sent an email to Laurie Taylor, a brilliant fundraiser in North Carolina, after we did a board retreat. I asked, “Did it land? Did anything work?” She’d also read my book, and I asked what she pulled out of it that was useful. She was all over this concept of asking them to talk about why they care. She asked her trustees, “What legacy do you want to leave from serving on this board?” She said, “You would have thought I opened the floodgates, and the board members poured out their hearts. One man cried.” She said it was the best meeting she’d had in three years because she had started that way.

Pay attention to the last line of her email, which I’m quoting directly: “Gail, I can’t change them, but I can change me.” What’s the learning? It’s like Einstein: shift your consciousness or your direction. It’s just like your children, your spouse, or your colleagues. If you shift the way you approach them, you get different results.

So I’d say to you, my friends and colleagues, that you have more power than you think over your ability to motivate and lead this wonderful group called board members. They respond to new energy and new ideas if you approach it right.

Whenever I do this exercise, and when I’m doing a lot of training on the elevator speech, there are four parts to the elevator speech, and we go through them. Board members love it, because I’m showing them how to open the door without being pushy. Of course, anybody would want to know how to open the door without being pushy. I tell them they get to sneeze on everybody they know. The sneezing is a concept from Seth Godin’s “Unleashing the Ideavirus”: ideas are like viruses, and they’re contagious. So board members become sneezers. They laugh. Most medical foundations don’t like it when I use this metaphor, but it’s very powerful, because I’m saying you sneeze on everybody, and the ones who are interested will let you know. That’s an easy way to be an advocate in the community for my organization.

Good old Ralph Waldo Emerson said, “Nothing great was ever achieved without enthusiasm.” So part of the elevator speech training is modeling the kind of energy they need to have. Once they start talking about the cause, they need to know how to engage somebody in a conversation, and they need to know when to shut up. So part of my training shows them they can turn the elevator speech into a conversation by asking, “What are your impressions?” They eat it up. They get a kick out of knowing they’re not supposed to talk a lot about their organization. They’re supposed to stop talking and let the other person talk. That’s a kinder, gentler approach.

I have a blog post called “The Fundraiser’s Kiss of Death” that you’d get a kick out of. My website is GailPerry.com, and also FiredUpFundraising.com. Both go to the same place. There’s a search bar at the top and the bottom, and you can type in some of the key phrases I’m sharing and pull up an easy-to-read article. A lot of people send my articles to their board members and say, “What do you think about this idea?” It’s a great way to start a conversation.

I’ve spent a lot of time on the elevator speech and teaching board members how to talk about your organization. That’s fundamental to training and motivating them, because when they start talking about why they care, they’re talking themselves into being motivated.

Part two of this deep motivational training is data. Part one is emotion. Part two asks: what are we really raising money for, and where does the money go? I bring the executive director and the development director up in front of the room, and I play Oprah. We sit down and relax. I say, “All right, let’s talk about where all this money goes. What is our organization’s budget?” Board members sit there thinking, “Do I know?” One person says, “It’s about $1.2 million.” The board members start taking notes.

Then I ask, “How much do we have to raise every year out of that $1.2 million?” “Oh, we have to raise $600,000.” You’ve presented this data to them before, but they didn’t get it because you had them in overload with too many numbers at once. This is a really powerful tool for spoon-feeding any group of adult learners key data in a way that lands and that they don’t forget.

I ask simple questions one by one, the responses dribble out, and board members are sitting on the edge of their seats. Then I ask the development director, “Of the $600,000 you need to raise every year, how much do you have to bust your butt to raise?” The development director says, “About $400,000.” Board members really want to know how much you have to bust your butt to raise.

Then we talk about where the money goes. I’ll ask, “Why do you need so much staff?” Say you’re Big Brothers Big Sisters. “You’re running volunteer mentors for the kids who need them.” It turns out the staff has to manage all of those volunteers and recruit them. “Oh, we need insurance. Oh, okay.” We break the budget down into why we need to make all of these expenditures, and board members suddenly get where the money is going.

These are great questions to ask your board members. Another one is “Why does it cost so much, program by program?” This is my favorite slide. For example, I was working with Big Brothers Big Sisters, and it turns out it costs $1,000 per kid per year to be managed and mentored. They were turning away 100 families a year who were begging for mentors for their kids, and the families left in tears because they were so worried about these kids and there was no help.

The board was afraid of having to raise $100,000 more for those 100 kids. But they could tackle five kids at a time. They decided to go to the Rotary Club and say, “Do you want to tackle five kids?” and to local churches and synagogues, and their community tennis club, “Do you want to underwrite a kid this year?”

Remember way back when I talked about making it about the project and not about money? This kind of discussion helps you turn it into a project and not about the money itself. I’d like to spend more time explaining it, but I think you get the gist. Use the panel discussion format, ask questions one by one, and your goal, of course, is to get board members to ask questions too, so they’re engaged in the discussion: “How much does it really cost? Why do we need to spend the money? If we had another $500,000, what would we do with it?” That’s a very important question for everybody to know. It keeps the staff from feeling like they’re whining and puts it on a more business-like footing.

Now I want to go back to the earlier theme of giving your board members a terrific experience. It’s up to us to make sure they enjoy their experience on the board and get a lot out of it personally. That means it’s not business as usual. I think you need to liven up your board meetings. I have a blog post called “Twelve Ways to Liven Up Your Board Meetings.” Look for ways to make them as interesting as possible. Give them social time, because studies show board members want to meet the other board members. And give them something specific to do.

When I’m on a board, I don’t want blah expectations. I want to know, “What do I need to do to be a good board member? Tell me what you need me to do this month, between now and the next board meeting. Give me one thing and I’ll do it. But don’t give me 15, and don’t be vague. I need to be managed, and I need to be well staffed. I’m really busy. If you’re clear, I can deliver. If you’re not clear, don’t make me think about it.”

By the way, with these action items, I think the psychological approach of putting peer pressure on the board is a huge factor in motivating people, because nobody wants to look bad in front of their colleagues. If I know I have to make a report in front of my colleagues, you’d better believe I’ll bust my butt to get the work done. That’s human nature. So clarify their job and what you want them to do.

Here are a couple more ideas that lighten the fundraising load and make it more fun for board members. I’m throwing a lot of concepts at you without explaining them thoroughly, but I hope you get the gist. You can buy my book on Amazon at a discount, and most of it is written up in short, snappy articles on my blog, so you can search there.

I believe in focusing board members on friend-making. Take soliciting off the plate. I tell them I’d rather have die-hard friends of my cause than donors, because die-hard friends stick with me in and out. They’ll do anything they can, and they’ll give me money if they can. So let’s concentrate on friend-making, and maybe redefine fundraising as friend-making.

More and more studies, the retention studies, the bloggers, and the latest research all show that if you slather love and attention on your donors, they’ll stick with you. So maybe you should treat your donors like friends, maybe like family. Board members who are nervous about asking for money can spend their wonderful time and energy there.

Here are a couple of my favorite jobs for board members. I love parties. My Christmas party in Raleigh is famous, and I’m having three parties this month at my house for different causes. None of them are fundraisers, but they’re all cultivation events with a purpose. Board members can host small coffees or socials to introduce friends to the cause. When I was a board member of the Carolina Ballet, I hosted a porch party and invited people to meet the new director. It was a wonderful little event that opened some key doors. Board members can also host tours. I’m a huge fan of a tour if you do it well.

Lastly, and this is one of my favorite data points in all of fundraising research, I’d actually start my whole conversation about board members with this slide and ask, “What are your impressions?” Because if board members systematically thank your donors, your donors will give more money. This is data from Penelope Burk. The research has happened over and over in organizations of multiple sizes. They pull a group of donors to receive thank-you phone calls from board members within 24 hours of receiving the gift, a very fast turnaround. Then they test five months later and solicit both groups, including the ones who didn’t get the call. They all got the same communications: the regular paper thank-you, newsletters, everything. But in study after study, the ones who got the phone call gave 39 percent more money than the other donors.

So, my friends, this is living proof that board members can directly impact the bottom line without having to ask for money. Yay! I’m going to say it again: board members can directly impact the bottom line without having to ask for money.

A final thought. I’m a huge fan of “The Matrix,” and I watch it all the time in TV reruns. Every time Morpheus says this line, I think, “Oh my god.” He says, “There’s a difference between knowing the path and walking the path.” We know the path, but taking it and walking it is a whole other game. So that’s my call to action: try to walk the path.

Here I am with some fellow board members at my favorite board, Lillian’s List, and we are fired up and ready to go. This is a volunteer board, and you can create this too.

To wrap up, here are some articles on my blog that you may enjoy and your board members may like: “Show Me the Money: How to Move from Friendraising to Fundraising”; “Top Ten Things to Understand About How Fundraising Really Works Today,” which is an important one to share with your board; the write-up about the mingle exercise for your board; and “How to Be a Personal Advocate for the Cause,” which is all about sneezing and spreading the word. A lot of this is already written up, and you can get more information there.

Thank you, Christy. I’m glad you loved “Donor-Centered Fundraising.” I do too. That’s Penelope Burk’s great book. Christy asks, “Aren’t board members often being asked to support multiple causes and organizations?” I would say you don’t want anybody on your board who isn’t going to make your organization one of their top three philanthropic priorities. I’d tell people when they join that one of our expectations is that we’re among your top three philanthropic priorities. You don’t want your board members spread too thin in terms of what they support, do you? My three parties this month are all for different things and I have different roles, but I worry sometimes about representing too many causes at once.

Steven Shattuck: I’m sorry about your pie chart. I don’t know what happened there, but you recovered quite well. Capital campaigns is a good one, Gail.

Gail Perry: Andrea Kihlstedt wrote the book on capital campaigns. When I started out in the ’90s, I clutched that book to my heart. She and I have a blog called Capital Campaign Magic. We’re doing coaching on capital campaigns virtually, writing a lot about them, and doing free webinars. Capital campaigns are complex and sophisticated, and board members have a particular role. The first place to start with your board is getting them to understand the unique strategy capital campaigns employ that will raise millions of dollars. We could go on and on, but that’s a long and deep topic.

Next: A hundred percent personal donations required by board members? Absolutely. You need a fellow board member to say, “Let’s put our money where our mouth is. We all have to be giving.” I resurrected an article on Twitter yesterday called “Seven Steps to Solicit Your Board.” This was my strategy when I was a staff fundraiser, and it really worked for me.

Casey asks, “If you can’t get board members fired up, how do you guide them to take a step down without potentially damaging a relationship?” First of all, I’d buy Simone Joyaux’s book “Firing Lousy Board Members.” But let me tell you what a friend of mine did, the executive director of a big nonprofit here in Raleigh. They didn’t demand a lot of their board members, and it was a high-performing group. He would go see a non-performing board member and say, “Is there another way you would like to serve our organization, since you haven’t been able to do such-and-such?” He said almost invariably the board member was relieved. They were feeling guilty, and they jumped at the chance to shift to a different role. It’s dicey, and you need to protect yourself politically. Getting rid of a board member requires being very careful. I wouldn’t say I’m an expert on that.

Steven Shattuck: There’s a long question here from Charity. She supports a high school band group, and it’s hard to keep donors on when their kids are in the band. Often the requested donation isn’t given by many families, and they need to raise money for uniforms. What’s a good strategy for meeting with companies for the first time?

Gail Perry: If I’m meeting with companies for the first time, I try not to make a cold call. I’d start with a prospect list of companies where we already have existing relationships, such as acquaintances of the school or school members, because cold calls aren’t particularly successful. Use a particular relationship. And talk about cost per kid. “We’ve got ten kids who can’t afford their uniforms, it’s $100 each. Who wants to sponsor a kid in the band?” Kids in the band are such a lovely cause. I think people would jump at the chance, but you have to present it in a very powerful and exciting way, using emotion. Don’t make cold calls. Maybe there are vendors at the school. Who serves the food? I’d even go to the local Walmart and Target, because those managers have discretion over smaller grants, they’re more accessible, and they like this sort of thing. Those are my places to start.

Steven Shattuck: Samantha asks, regarding personal donations from the board, do you recommend setting a specific minimum amount or a give-what-you-can policy?

Gail Perry: I like to say every board member should make a proud personal gift every year. I think a proud personal gift is an honest, caring way to call on board members to reach for their highest calling. Having said that, when I solicit board members, I like to put a number in front of them and ask for a specific amount, and I’ve varied the amount based on their ability.

You can take one approach, which is to keep secret the amount you’re soliciting and ask individually based on capacity. Or the board members can all agree that we’re each responsible for $1,000 or something like that, and if we can’t give it, we need to bring it in. That’s the give/get. There was a big discussion on #fundchat yesterday. If anybody’s on Twitter, you can search for it. A bunch of us were talking about soliciting boards and give/get policies.

I will say the higher-performing boards I’ve worked with do have a give/get. Usually it’s more prestigious and larger organizations where it’s a clear expectation that if I’m going on the board of the Museum of Modern Art in New York City, it’s going to cost me X or Y. Smaller organizations may not be at that place, and it may not be appropriate. It has to be something your board members themselves agree upon if you’re going to do a give/get. I’m careful about that because I don’t want to be heavy-handed. I’m Southern. Heavy-handed doesn’t work as far as I’m concerned.

Steven Shattuck: Gail, what’s your opinion on term limits for board members?

Gail Perry: Please go to my blog and pull out “Why Your Board Needs Term Limits.” If you do not have term limits, the energy on your board isn’t going to be refreshed, you won’t have new ideas, and you’re in terrible danger of calcifying your strategies and your mission and not changing with the times. You’re also in danger of your board becoming a social club, a martyr club (“Oh, we work so hard, we’re such martyrs”), or an “we own this organization” club, none of which puts the mission first. It’s all about us.

I worked with a big-time board in the New York City area, and a huge investment banker on the board said to me, “If we’re ever going to get serious about fundraising, we have to have term limits.” Boom. I can’t be strong enough about it. It’s part of every list of good board practices you’ll ever find. I know it’s hard. “Oh, we can’t find any new board members.” Well, maybe you need to try harder, or something is going on. Look at yourself about that. Thank you. You found the article.

Steven Shattuck: I did.

Gail Perry: I was poking fun.

Steven Shattuck: A really good question from Anne: when horses are your main tool of intervention, how do you convince the owners that supporting the hay and grain and vet costs is equivalent to other overhead another nonprofit would have, like a building or equipment?

Gail Perry: Maybe you need to talk about adopting a horse. How much does it cost to maintain one horse? That might be more fun than paying for hay. Look at what’s most sellable, what’s the sexiest. “Oh, gosh, I’m riding a horse named Blaze. Isn’t he beautiful? I get a picture of him every time I make a gift. I can go out there and feed him apples.” Hay and grain and vets don’t sound as fun to me as underwriting a horse. So maybe you need to package your costs differently.

Steven Shattuck: Cynthia was wondering, do you have a recommendation for writing the best thank you letter after a donation?

Gail Perry: I do. I have several articles on my blog about thank-you letters. I think you need to wear your heart on your sleeve with that dang thank-you letter. Penelope Burk has a four-line letter in her book. Let me quote it: “Dear Mrs. Carbunkle, you must have heard the shouts of joy in the hall when we received your gift of (blank) underwriting the Children’s Music Program. We are so thrilled. We’re going to put your money to good use,” and here’s the person’s name and phone number who directs the program. “We can’t wait to give you a follow-up report about this project, and we want you to come down and visit.” Something along those lines.

Your thank-you letter needs to be casual in tone, warm, and personal. You need to ditch the lofty, institutional language and be as warm and fuzzy and lovey-dovey as you can possibly be. Some organizations can’t bring themselves to do that because “we have to be formal; this is a very important nonprofit.” But if you make it personal, the donor’s heart will go throb, throb, throb, and they’ll love you more, and they’ll probably give you more money. That’s my quick and dirty recommendation.

Steven Shattuck: Love it. We’re about out of time, but I’d encourage anyone who’s been sitting on your hands to send us anything you’re wondering about.

Gail Perry: George wanted to know about resources for smaller nonprofits. A lot of my articles apply to both large and small nonprofits, because I’m very practical and very humanistic: “You do this. This is not hard.” Any-sized organization can get a lot out of it.

I also have a webinar series from Fired Up Fundraising, my blog, where I bring in the very best fundraising gurus in the world for a couple of free webinars a month. It’s a broad-based training program to educate you and your staff on fundraising. We do the basics and also the latest twist on the basics, so that if you’re going to implement a basic, you might as well implement the latest version: the best way to do the thank-you letter, the best way to do the Internet, the best way to do your major gift prospects and program. I’m all about being efficient and effective. Effective means we raise our money, and efficient means we save time doing it.

Steven Shattuck: If you aren’t following Gail on Twitter or reading her blog, you’ve got to do that. It’s one of the best in the sector.

Gail Perry: I just try to be supportive and have some fun. It comes out every Friday morning. “Avoid nonprofit jargon,” thank you, Richard. I have a blog post called “Words and Phrases Fundraisers Love to Hate” about jargon.

Steven Shattuck: Jenny asks, do you have any resources specifically for nonprofit theater companies?

Gail Perry: I have an arts background. If you’ve got people who love theater, those are your people to cultivate. I was a ballet dancer and I love ballet, and my very first job was with the North Carolina Arts Council. You need to find those passionate theater people and give them special experiences. Invite them to cast parties, give them backstage tours during intermission, give them free acting classes.

A lot of people in the arts think, “We can’t raise money because we’re not hungry children.” But when the Carolina Ballet did “The Nutcracker,” my girls and I got a backstage tour during intermission, and there were the beautiful ballerinas warming up, ethereal, alien, beautiful beings, and I’ll never forget that experience. You can give that experience to the people who are passionate about theater. I don’t want anybody to say, “We can’t raise money because our cause isn’t sexy,” because to your supporters, it is.

Steven Shattuck: Emma was wondering, should the amount required of board member contributions be related to the size of the budget, the number of members, or both?

Gail Perry: Neither. The required board contribution needs to be based on, first, their capability, and second, whatever they agree they should be doing. There are two ways: you can have board members decide what their expectation of each other is going to be, or you can privately solicit board members based on their capacity. I wouldn’t relate it to the budget. Some people say the board needs to give 10 percent or 20 percent of the budget. It depends on who you have on the board. You may not have the money in the seats, and you don’t want to make people feel bad. It’s up to you to enlist people who can make those kinds of gifts.

Steven Shattuck: I was talking to Jay yesterday, and he told the story of an organization that had Bill Gates on the board. Someone asked him for a donation, and Bill said, “How much did everyone else give?” The fundraiser said, “About $75.” Bill said, “Okay, sign me up for $75.” So they only got $75 out of Bill Gates based on what everyone else was doing.

Gail Perry: I’d have made the case for exploring his interest in funding a project. You have to push Bill Gates differently. I’d say, “Listen, everyone else is paying $75. What do you think would be appropriate for you?” “No, really, now, Bill.”

Steven Shattuck: “Come on, Bill.” We’re about out of time, so I want to give you the final word. Where can folks find you online?

Gail Perry: You can send me an email at GP@GailPerry.com, or go to my website, FiredUpFundraising.com or GailPerry.com. You can also Google “Gail Perry fundraising,” and I’m afraid you’ll get a lot of hits, because I’ve been blogging for so long. I love to hear from people, and I respond to almost all emails unless they’re really offbeat or weird. I’m going to send you a follow-up email with the PowerPoint and a couple of links.

Steven Shattuck: You’ll get the slides from Gail, and I’ll send out a recording in the next couple of hours so you can relive this presentation with your board members or anyone else. We do these webinars once a week, totally free and educational. We’ve got some great ones coming up. Anne Peyton will talk about how to develop a stewardship program, and Kivi Leroux Miller will talk about videos and infographics. Check out our webinar page.

Gail Perry: Don’t miss Kivi. She’s one of the leaders in the field, and she’s amazing. I want to sit in on that.

Steven Shattuck: You should, Gail. Thanks again. Thanks for joining us, and have a great rest of your day.

Gail Perry: Everybody take care and good luck, and onward to the cause. May you get one idea from today and put it to work so things shift in your organization and raise more money. Bye-bye.

Steven Shattuck: Bye!

‍

Key takeaways:

  • Board members fundraising training works best when it isn’t about money. Gail Perry’s story of a board chair who “would do anything but fundraising” until she imagined being the relationship manager for a corporate partner shows how reframing fundraising as relationship building changes the response.
  • Solicitation can come off the plate. Board members can make thank-you calls, host tours, welcome guests at events, or host small socials, so every member has a job even if they never ask.
  • Training has to be hands-on. Adults tune out after about ten minutes of presentation, so use mingle exercises, panel-style budget conversations, and open questions like “What are your impressions of this slide?”
  • Start with why they care and where the money goes. A ten-minute “why I care” mingle gives board members their first elevator speech, and a walk through the budget helps them understand what the organization needs to raise and why.
  • Thank-you calls from board members drive revenue. Research Gail cites from Penelope Burk found donors who received a board member’s thank-you call within 24 hours gave 39 percent more later.
Helping you help others

Every act of generosity starts here.

Empower your team to connect deeply and fundraise confidently.