Webinar

Best practices for recurring donor acquisition

Erica Waasdorp will show you how important recurring giving has become, and how best to bring them in - with minimal time and effort, but with the large focus these sustainable recurring donors deserve.

Learning objectives:

  • Compare monthly and one-time giving to build a case for recurring donors with your executive director and board.
  • Set up a monthly-only donation page and add a monthly nudge to your one-time forms.
  • Choose the channels and staff time that will drive monthly sign-ups each week.
  • Plan a retention approach so new monthly donors stay past their first year.

Transcript:

Steven Shattuck: All right, Erica. I've got 2:00 Eastern. Is it okay if I get this party started?

Erica Waasdorp: Sounds good.

Steven Shattuck: All right. Welcome, everybody. Good afternoon if you're on the East Coast, and good morning, I should say, if you're on the West Coast, just barely. And if you're watching this as a recording, I hope you're having a good day, no matter when and where you are. We're here to talk about recurring donors, best practices for unlocking the mystery that is recurring donors. I think after this presentation, you won't think it's so much of a mystery after all. I'm excited, because it's one of my favorite topics. And I'm so happy to see a full room. I'm Steven. I'm over here at Bloomerang, and I'll be moderating today's discussion as always.

Just a couple of quick housekeeping items. We are recording this session, and we'll send out the recording and the slides later today. You should already have the slides. I sent them out in a reminder email about an hour ago, but if I missed you, don't worry, we will get you everything. You can share it with a friend, watch it later, and catch up if you get interrupted, have another meeting, or a kid comes into your home office. We'll get that to you.

Most importantly, please feel free to chat in any questions or comments along the way. We love for these sessions to be interactive, and we're going to save some time at the end for a formal Q&A session. Don't be shy. There's a chat box and a Q&A box. Use whichever one you want. I'll keep an eye on both. You can even send us a tweet, and I'll keep half an eye on Twitter as well. We love to hear from you.

If this is your first Bloomerang webinar, an extra special welcome to you. We do these webinars every single Thursday. We've been doing them for about 10 years. It's my favorite hour of the week by far. If you've never heard of Bloomerang beyond these webinars, we are also a provider of donor management software. You can check out the videos and other content on our website. But don't do that right now. Wait about 59 minutes, because we have one of my favorites joining us from beautiful Cape Cod, Massachusetts: Erica Waasdorp. Erica, what's going on? How's it going? You doing okay?

Erica Waasdorp: It's pretty good. I'm really excited about helping you uncover some mysteries, if you will.

Steven Shattuck: This is great. Anytime somebody asks me about monthly donors, recurring donors, sustainers, whatever you want to call it, they've got to talk to Erica. She literally wrote the book on it, "Monthly Giving: The Sleeping Giant." It's behind me, somewhere over there. It's the book on monthly giving, so you're going to want to get that. She's the queen of monthly giving. She's an AFP master trainer, and she's also the U.S. ambassador for IFC, which is pretty cool. I don't think I knew... is that a new thing, Erica?

Erica Waasdorp: No. Actually, it's an old thing. I stopped doing that a couple of years ago. The last year, obviously, they did the...

Steven Shattuck: Okay. You used to be.

Erica Waasdorp: But I'm Dutch, so it was a great way to go home and get involved with some international fundraising.

Steven Shattuck: That's awesome. You're all over the place. You're speaking at conferences when we can, and you've done tons of webinars for Bloomerang. Thank you for that. They want to hear from you, so I'm going to put my pipe down. Nobody wants to hear from me. They want to hear about Erica's monthly donor secret. I'll stop sharing my screen here.

Erica Waasdorp: Great. Okay, I'll share my screen now. I do have subtitles as well, because I am Dutch, so some of the words might come out with my Dutch accent. When I used it before, it was really funny in some cases, so don't hang me up on it. I'm excited to talk to you about some best practice solutions for recurring donor acquisition mysteries. Thanks, Steven. Here is the cover of the brand new book. I'm hoping to send the final edits to my designer next week, and it's coming out this summer. I'm really excited about that. It's supposed to make monthly giving easier than ever before, because it's not that hard.

What I'm going to talk about today is how important recurring giving is, especially after what you saw last year during COVID. How do you bring those recurring donors in with minimal time and effort? It doesn't have to be hard, and it doesn't have to take a lot of time. You can put more time into it, and the more time you put in, the better off you are. But it doesn't have to be a lot, because I know all of you are busy.

We're also going to talk about how recurring donors are sustainable, how important they are, and why they deserve your focus. Let me start with a poll. Steven, I think you can launch that as well. The question is: what's the annual value of your recurring donors? Is it less than $5,000? Is it between $5,000 and $25,000, between $25,000 and $100,000, or are you not sure? That's a really exciting statistic. Steven, you're going to keep an eye on questions and answers in chat, and I have a couple of polls today, so I might ask you what questions are in the room.

It looks like... I'll give you one more second. All right, I'm ending the polls. So, 36 percent say less than $5,000. Then another third say between $5,000 and $25,000, and 17 percent say between $25,000 and $100,000. Some of you are not sure. Great. We're going to talk about the importance of recurring giving. I've been preaching this for a long time, and it's taken a long time to get to this stage, but they are really important. Even if you're getting $5,000 from your recurring donors now, what if you could improve your number of recurring donors? How many do you have now, and what's the value? And what if you could get 200 monthly donors?

On average, we're seeing about $24 a month. That's $288 a year, so almost $29,000 a year is what you could be getting from 100 monthly donors. If you want to chat about how many monthly donors you have now, just let me know. Steven, you might shout that out when you get some responses. If you could go from 50 to 100, or from 100 to 200 monthly donors, that's almost $60,000. It's very powerful. You can plan on the money being there. Who would have thought we'd still be in the middle of a pandemic? We're used to hurricanes, tornadoes, fires, but nobody could have thought about a pandemic. The money kept coming in from the recurring donors you had. And last year, a lot of organizations were able to bring in new recurring donors.

People ask me all the time what percentage of donors you can expect to convert. It depends on how many donors you have now, how many email addresses you have, what you've done to get there, and how much focus you can give to growing it. Steven did a study a while back looking at Bloomerang customers. Organizations with between 15,000 and 25,000 donors in their database saw an average of 9 percent of donors giving monthly. The bigger organizations, with 25,000 or more donors, saw smaller percentages of donors giving monthly. So if you're an organization with fewer than 5,000 donors, the average is 8 percent giving monthly. What can you do to get there? It's a good statistic to set a goal against. I hear other studies showing about 15 percent of donors give monthly, but it all depends. It's not something that happens overnight. Steven, did you have any numbers from folks on the webinar?

Steven Shattuck: Yeah, a pretty wide variety, from single digits to triple digits. Even somebody had over 7,000. So, good job to them.

Erica Waasdorp: Wow, that's awesome. You could be teaching that webinar today. So why does it take so long for organizations to jump on the monthly donor bandwagon? If you see these statistics, you say, "Wow, I've got to get going." Monthly donors give more money. If you're sending out appeals, the average gift from appeal donors was $58. Online gifts are typically a little higher, between $96 and $111, depending on which study you look at. About 12 percent of donors are giving online, so a lot of money still comes in offline. But if you can get people to give monthly, that varies. I've seen studies going from $261 a year to $612 a year. It depends on your organization, but it's double, quintuple or quadruple the value of a one-time gift. That's the key.

The other piece is that a monthly donor doesn't stop giving additional gifts. Twenty-eight years ago, when I started in monthly giving, the thinking was: once someone gives monthly, we keep them updated a little, but we don't ask for more. That has totally changed, because monthly donors are really loyal. If you segment monthly donors out in your email and your mail, you can track how they respond. Every time monthly donors get an email so far, open rates and click-through rates go up. So becoming a monthly donor doesn't mean they won't give more, and that's even more powerful.

Retention also goes up. On average, retention is still about 46 percent. If you can get someone to give monthly, they'll stay with you much longer. That retention rate goes to 90 percent or higher if they give by electronic funds transfer, or ACH.

Recurring giving is really about caring about the donor. It fits every stage of life: younger or older, single or married, with kids, grandkids or pets. Gifts fit the donor's budget. It's easy to do on a desktop, a phone or a tablet, and it's very donor-centric. More donors can give this way. Fifty percent of baby boomers give monthly, and 60 percent of younger donors are on some type of subscription model, whether that's Netflix, a meal service or something else. They want to give monthly, but they can't write big checks. That's why recurring gifts are so powerful.

I'm going to do another poll. Which recurring gift acquisition mystery would you like to solve today? Is it how many asks I should make? How much time I should assign to it? Which channels I should use? Or something else? Steven, while people fill out the poll, do you have any questions from the audience?

Steven Shattuck: There are a couple, but I think you're going to cover them. I'll come back for sure.

Erica Waasdorp: Okay. It looks like pretty much everybody is voting. Thirty percent say, "How many asks should I consider?" Twelve percent say, "How much time should I assign?" And 51 percent say, "Which channel should I use?" Then some other. Great. We'll move that to the side.

The key to growing your recurring giving program is putting somebody in charge. Somebody has to be the driver. It doesn't mean you have to do everything yourself, but you need to track it and say, "I want to move this forward." If you're on this webinar, you're probably going to be in charge, or you're going to assign somebody to be in charge. If you don't have somebody in charge, things fall through the cracks and stay ideas that never get implemented. The person who had 7,000 monthly donors is probably really motivated, but they started at some point. You need somebody in charge.

One hour a week can go very far. I coined the phrase "monthly donor Monday." Every Monday, sit down and ask: How did my email do last week? Can I create another email? What are my trends? What can I do to keep my monthly donors going? One hour can take you very far. More is always welcome, but if nothing else, take that Monday morning and get it done, because I know fundraisers are busy and wear multiple hats.

When I started monthly giving, a lot of these tools didn't exist. Online giving didn't exist. It was all mail and phone. Now you have online giving tools, a donor base and thank-you processes. It's a matter of tweaking what you have and customizing it. Your systems can handle recurring gifts. Use the chat to tell me what you're using. Is it Bloomerang, DonorPerfect, Blackbaud, Little Green Light, Salesforce? There are so many systems out there, and every one can handle monthly giving now. That's exciting. When I first wrote the book, that wasn't the case.

All of these systems can send an email thank-you and an email landing page. The minute somebody submits your online form, they get a thank-you. Make sure your thank-yous are what you want them to be, customized and as warm as your system allows. Every system is different. Some have a lot of space, some look like a receipt, and some have very little space. Make sure the thank-you says "thank you for your monthly gift," or "your quarterly gift," depending on the frequency you offer. I always recommend monthly as the main focus, because that's what people typically do, and they give more if you ask monthly. Some systems offer other frequencies too.

Set up what I call a monthly-only page, and drive people to it. If your system doesn't allow that, we'll deal with it in a minute. But if you can accommodate it, do it, so you're not distracting people when you send them there.

If you have a one-time giving option plus a monthly gift, which is the case for nearly all donation pages now, look for a spot near your online form to add a nudge. In some cases it goes right on the form. You may have to build it into the site the page sits on. Some people call this social proof, but it's that extra push, like "Your monthly support prepares us for every challenge and lets us plan for the future." Add a monthly giving nudge if you haven't already.

Depending on your system, if you have a monthly option and a one-time option, make the monthly amounts different from the one-time amounts, typically about a third lower. If your one-time form asks for $100, your monthly form could start at $25 a month. Always include the lowest amount possible, which is $5 a month in some systems and $10 in others. Offer lower monthly amounts, because nobody is going to give $100 a month. Start low and get a high response. You want the donor to feel they can make a difference within an amount they're comfortable with.

Some consultants say you should pre-select the monthly option on a one-time giving page. I disagree. I want the monthly donor to choose, and be deliberate about it, because you don't want a bad donor experience. I've seen donors say, "Oh, shoot, I wasn't meaning to make a monthly gift." Then they have to call or email to stop it, and that's not great. Some consultants say pre-selecting gets you more monthly gifts, but you also get more refunds. So I wouldn't recommend it. You want donors to know what they're doing. If your form allows it, add electronic funds transfer, ACH, direct debit or automatic bank withdrawal. Then you're totally set. I'm from the Netherlands, and Dutch people are used to giving their bank account information everywhere, but that's not the case here. It is growing, especially with younger people. I'm seeing about 5 percent of monthly donors give by EFT, and donors might change a bank account only every 12 to 14 years, if ever. So it's an option if you have it built in. Look at your forms, because you may have set one up a year ago, and things have changed. Systems like Bloomerang are always trying to improve.

Some donors won't want to click a submit button. So offer a downloadable form they can fill out and mail. Put that option on your website. Some donors are not comfortable with online forms, and having a form is great.

Some systems allow a lightbox for a one-time gift checkout, and this is an example I agree with. The donor is committed and knows what they're doing. When somebody makes a one-time gift and hits submit, a box pops up: "Thank you. Before we process, would you consider making it go further and make a monthly gift?" The donor can say, "Yes, please process my monthly gift of $20," which is close to a third of the one-time amount, or change the amount, or say, "No, thanks. Complete my one-time $50 gift." This technique works really well. I'm seeing more lightboxes or modals over one-time giving amounts. The studies I've seen show it doesn't reduce the number of one-time gifts, but it does increase monthly gifts. Donors are very committed when they do this.

Those are a few things you can look at right now and say, "Is that something I can test?" You don't need a lot of resources to start. Start small with low-hanging fruit. Become a monthly donor to your own organization. You might also become a monthly donor to similar organizations, including big national ones, so you can see what they're doing. I support more than 40 organizations monthly just to see what they all do.

Start with yourself, and invite your board. Some board members aren't big check writers. You may want every board member to give $1,000, but you can ask them to consider $85 a month, which adds up to $1,000 a year. That might work for some board members. Volunteers and staff may want to support you that way too. Start with that low-hanging fruit. Whoever gives monthly becomes a supporter and advocate who can invite other people to become monthly donors.

We're in the middle of a pandemic, and people ask, "Should I be asking for recurring gifts right now?" The answer is absolutely yes, you should not be afraid. If nothing else, now is a really good time to try new things. What do you have to lose by sending an email here or there and trying a couple of things?

The good news is that online monthly donors are growing. In 2020, 18 percent of online donors made monthly gifts, which is higher than the 8 percent I showed earlier. How do you get there? Start with that low-hanging fruit. Ask a board member and a few existing monthly donors for a testimonial: "Why are you giving monthly?" Have them type it up, say it on video, or do a Zoom call. Then ask, "Can I use that to reach out to other potential monthly donors?" Video is really powerful. I put the link in the chat so you can listen to one of these on YouTube.

How about taking over your homepage for a month, maybe May, [inaudible], or July? Some of the bigger organizations do this. Sierra Club, for example, has a big sustainer drive every July, and everything focuses on monthly giving. Talk to whoever manages your website and say, "I really want to focus on this." That plants the seed. If you have a monthly-only page, link to it, so it's very clear that donors can give monthly.

Use your emails too. Add one email a month that asks for a monthly gift. One organization, in the middle of COVID, added a second button to every email. The first button says "Will you give monthly?" and the second says "Yes, I'll make an emergency gift." Every time they send, they get new monthly donors. It's one email, so add it to what you already send. What do you have to lose by asking?

Add an extra button. One organization septupled its number of monthly donors just by adding a button to the bottom of every email: "Make a one-time donation" and "Become a monthly donor." It doesn't cost much.

Then send some specific emails. The more the merrier. If you send a newsletter once a month, or an email a week, consider sending one email a month to your monthly donor group. This organization calls its monthly donor group its "Trailblazers." Send recurring-specific emails. It's one email a month, and you'll pick up donors who become monthly. Nothing to lose.

Matches are magical. They work everywhere in fundraising, and monthly giving is no exception. Say, "I want to generate 50 new monthly donors by this deadline." Then say, "I found a donor, or a group of donors, or a board member who will give $5,000, or $10,000 if we reach this goal." You're going to reach that goal. The match email is a series. You launch the match, then send a reminder the week before, the day before, and the day of: "We're this close. Help us get to the finish line and break through the 50 monthly donors." If you're considering a match for Giving Tuesday or a local giving day, consider a match for monthly donors too. Some of the big organizations run a big match drive once or twice a year, and it works.

If you have an email newsletter, put a little testimonial in there every month. Put a note about monthly giving in there. You want to plant the seeds, and it doesn't cost you anything, because you're already sending the newsletter. Add it to your email signature too: "Become a rock star." Support the organization with $10 a month, and link straight to your monthly-only page.

Do you use welcome email series? The earlier you get people to give monthly, the longer they stay and the more retention you get. If you have an automated series through Mailchimp or Constant Contact, give people the chance in the second or third email to say, "Welcome. Will you please consider a monthly donation?" Use your welcome email if you have one. Steven, do you know if anybody is using welcome emails?

Steven Shattuck: Yeah, a couple of people. A couple of people have also said they're doing some of the other things you suggested, like the dedicated page. So it seems to be resonating.

Erica Waasdorp: Great, awesome. Social media is also great. When you send emails, share them on social media too. Consider special messaging. Video works great. If you have a video of someone giving a testimonial about why they give monthly, put it on social media. The key, which I recommend to keep you sane, is to link to your monthly-only page on your website. Don't send people through Facebook Giving or another social or crowdfunding platform. Send them to your monthly donor page. It all feeds into the same system, otherwise you'll go utterly crazy. Use your social media.

This Perkins example had a series of emails and also ran everything on social media. It all had the same look and feel. Make sure it fits, so donors think, "Oh yeah, I just got that email, and now I'm seeing it on Facebook." If you have Google Ads or Google Ad Grants, consider monthly donor ads too, linking to your monthly-only page. Use whatever you have.

If you're an advocacy organization and you ask people to sign a petition on social media, that's a great opportunity. After they sign, send a thank-you: "Thank you so much. We love what you just did. Could you step up your support by becoming a monthly donor?" It doesn't cost much. It's a thank-you email after the petition. You can do the same thing with a question. If you're an animal organization, ask "Are you a cat lover or a dog lover?" The donor answers yes or no and lands on a page with a thank-you for answering, and then you ask for a monthly gift.

It's all about not being afraid. There are so many opportunities right now. You have the tools. You just have to start asking. What's the worst that can happen? Somebody signs up to become a recurring donor. Donors who worry about how much they'll have to give can see recurring gifts as a way to support you within their budget. So just go do something.

A few other things don't cost much, and they're about planting seeds and continuing to ask. Monthly giving is not something you do in January and then forget for the rest of the year. Keep working at it.

If you have a print newsletter, put a message about making an ongoing gift in it. If you have a testimonial, put it in the print newsletter too. It's okay to repurpose. I can't repeat that enough. If you got a testimonial for an email, put it in the print newsletter. No donor is going to say, "That's the same testimonial you used over there." You can absolutely reuse content.

You might run a small ad, if you have a magazine. Put in a little ad: "Sign me up. I want to be an ocean partner." Make it easy for the donor to find and respond. There's literally no end to what you can do.

If you send a welcome letter or a thank-you letter in the mail, consider asking for a monthly gift in it. Like the welcome email, early is great. I've worked with organizations that get the highest number of monthly donors from their thank-you letters. Every time they send one, they get some monthly sign-ups. Build in the option to consider it.

If you don't want to be that direct, you can add a little lift note or buck slip to plant the seed. The more direct you are, the better off you are, so consider all of your options. A lift note or buck slip helps too. Keep the amounts low. That's really key.

Use your appeal reply form. It has become best practice to put a monthly option on every appeal reply form: "Please charge my monthly gift. Yes, I will become a monthly donor. I would like to give monthly from my credit card. See below." One organization is very direct about it on every appeal reply form, because they want to grow their monthly donors. The more direct you are, the more monthly donors you'll generate. Keep that in mind. Monthly donors shouldn't get this version. If someone is already monthly, send them an appeal that says, "Thank you for your monthly gift," with only the "Yes, I'll make an extra gift" option. Don't ask them to become monthly again. Keep that in mind when you segment your appeals. Appeal reply forms won't bring in oodles of monthly donors, but you will get some, and it doesn't cost much more. It could be a laser-printed version, and you can test it. Heifer has done this for a while: "Yes, I will help lift with a monthly gift," and "Yes, I will do a one-time gift." The more specific you are, the better.

If you have room in your communication schedule, add a special appeal, but target it. I wouldn't send it to your whole donor base. Send it to donors who gave most recently, who gave two times or more, or who gave $10 or more, and ask them to consider a monthly gift. You'll pick up some monthly donors, and you'll get some one-time gifts from people who aren't ready yet. If you send a special appeal and then a few emails after it, eventually they'll say, "I thought about it, and I'm going to do it." That's why these approaches work.

Phone calls are great too. Not every organization can use them, but many donors love hearing from you. If you make thank-you calls, that's a chance to talk. Last year, a lot of donors were home, and many organizations called to say thank you. A lot of donors say, "I could do more." Those are magical words. That's when you ask, "Would you consider a monthly gift?" The donor might say, "Yes, I saw that in the newsletter, and I've been thinking about it. I'm going to do it." You have nothing to lose by asking.

Text giving is becoming more common and popular too. As long as the donor has given you permission to text, that's another opportunity. We just came off a whole election season, and some political organizations were using text asks, so more donors are comfortable with them. Consider it as part of your overall campaign.

I'm going to launch another poll. What will you do next to grow your recurring donors? Will you spend one hour a week? Set a goal? Create a plan and stick to it? Something else? Steven, while people fill out the poll, do you have a question for me?

Steven Shattuck: Yeah, we have a lot of questions here, Erica. If you're ready to roll into Q&A, that's cool with me. We have about 10 minutes to get to them, so if you haven't asked a question, now is the time, because we've got an expert here.

Erica Waasdorp: Okay. Pretty much everybody has voted. If you chose "other," type what it is in the chat. Twenty percent say, "I'm going to spend one hour a week." Twenty percent say, "I'm setting a goal." And 52 percent say, "Create a plan and stick to it." I love that. Seven percent say other. So it's up to you. Set some goals, create a plan, and stick to it. If nothing else, make the commitment to spend one hour a week looking at your program and making it grow. That's the key, because the best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago, and the second best time is now. That's what recurring giving is. I love this quote. It's even in my book.

I'm going to open it up for questions. If you had questions early on, send me an email. I'm very responsive by email, with no obligation. Go to my website for the monthly donor recurring roadmaps and lots of resources.

Steven Shattuck: Thanks, Erica. This was awesome. There were so many good nuggets, little tweaks and real actionable stuff, which I always love. We've had some good chat, and there are a lot of questions, probably more than we can get to. I'm not playing favorites, folks. I'm just going to grab things. Do connect with Erica. Email her, and follow her on Twitter if you're a Twitter person.

Erica Waasdorp: I'm not a big Twitter person, but I post some of the... I just want you to know that...

Steven Shattuck: You've got some good stuff occasionally.

Erica Waasdorp: I'm more of an email person, but if we don't get to a question, feel free to ask me afterward.

Steven Shattuck: We're going to send the slides and recording too. A lot of you asked for that. There were a lot of questions about the board, Erica. What's the connection? It seems like board members becoming monthly donors is a good thing for a lot of reasons. It's equitable if they don't have as much capacity as someone else. It's easier on their budget, and it's less of a friction point than a big one-time gift. Have you seen that be successful?

Erica Waasdorp: Yes. Some organizations are lucky to have board members who can write big checks, but I see many boards made up of program-focused people. They care about the program and the mission, but they're not big check writers. Every organization should aim for 100 percent board giving, and a monthly gift may be the way they get there. They may not be able to write a $1,000 check, but they can say, "I'm here to help with other things you need, and I can give $85 a month," which comes to about $1,000. Give them that option. I've heard of boards where some members give $1,000 a month. It depends. But it's another way they can make a considerable gift.

Steven Shattuck: I love it.

Erica Waasdorp: It's an investment in the organization, and it shows their commitment. It takes away the fear of "I can't write the big checks." You can make a monthly gift.

Steven Shattuck: And $85 a month is...

Erica Waasdorp: Especially if they're still working and have kids, grandkids and all that.

Steven Shattuck: Yes, I love it. What about planned giving? I feel like I've seen research that most planned givers were also monthly donors before that. Is that true? Have you seen it?

Erica Waasdorp: Yes. I've talked to friends in the UK, where monthly giving programs have run much longer. They can track every will that's made, and they know how many organizations are in each will. They can share information without naming specific organizations: the average person has about seven organizations in their will, and the average bequest is this. And monthly donors are six times more likely to leave you in their will.

Steven Shattuck: Wow.

Erica Waasdorp: They're small donors, but they're committed and invested in the organization, and they'll leave you in their will. This isn't a planned giving session, but if your organization has 7,000 monthly donors, look at your legacy gifts. What was their first gift? What was their last gift? When was it? How many gifts did they make? You'll often see they were multiple givers, with smaller donations over time. For organizations that had monthly giving for a longer period, I've worked with one that had 70 percent of its legacy income last year come from monthly donors. They're the $10, $15 and $20 donors, and they care, and they've been giving for a long time, multiple gifts, before they leave you in their will.

Steven Shattuck: It makes sense. They're committed.

Erica Waasdorp: They're not necessarily your big check writers.

Steven Shattuck: No. Giving monthly is a much stronger signal than the dollar amount. That's what I'm hearing.

Erica Waasdorp: Yup.

Steven Shattuck: That makes sense.

Erica Waasdorp: Yeah, great question.

Steven Shattuck: How long should someone be a monthly donor before you bring up those things? It seems like you wouldn't want to do that right away.

Erica Waasdorp: We're only talking about acquisition today, but you want to upgrade your monthly donors at least once a year. If they've been giving monthly for nine or ten months, reach out and ask for an upgrade. It doesn't have to be a big jump, maybe $2 or $3 a month. Some donors will say no, and others will say yes. About 12 percent of monthly donors upgrade, and about 6 percent make at least one extra gift a year. Do both. They're committed and they care about you. If you keep them up to date in the right way, and you say thank you and show gratitude, they'll consider an upgrade, because costs go up. You get to make the case.

Don't send monthly donors a thank-you letter every time. Send them a thank-you letter when they join. In that letter, tell them they'll get a tax letter in January. In that January tax letter, you could add a buck slip, or a legacy brochure, which plants the seed. Talk about planned giving and legacy gifts in your print and email newsletters too. As you reach out to monthly donors with all those tools, plant the seeds for the next step. It's really about planting seeds.

Steven Shattuck: I love that, and the upgrade idea. I've been giving the same monthly amount to organizations for years, and I know I should bump it up. If they asked, I'd do it, $2 more or $7 more.

Erica Waasdorp: You don't want to do it automatically. I just wrote a blog about that. Do not do an automatic upgrade. If somebody talked you into that, no. You want to ask the donor to consider a monthly upgrade, and they get to choose the amount and when they do it.

Steven Shattuck: Yeah, we aren't the cable company here.

Erica Waasdorp: Yes, no.

Steven Shattuck: I love it. You mentioned a lot of ways people can give, and I love that downloadable form. I don't want to stereotype, but is there an age difference between monthly donors? Some questions here ask whether older donors feel secure giving credit card information. Have you seen that in the data?

Erica Waasdorp: There aren't a lot of statistics on monthly giving yet. It's built into a lot of other things. On my website, if you search for statistics, there's a page with pretty much every statistic I've found about monthly giving, and a couple of new ones are coming out soon. Right now, the average donor is about 64 years old, but monthly gifts are trending younger, based on a recent Data Axle study. Younger people are comfortable doing everything on their phone, including giving their card and bank account information. Older donors often don't like giving credit card information online. My husband is a bit older than I am, and he doesn't like to give his card online. I often have to say, "Okay, you do it." But he'd be comfortable printing a form and mailing it in.

Steven Shattuck: So give people the option.

Erica Waasdorp: Yes, give them all the options. It also depends on the type of organization. Animal welfare and religious organizations tend to have older donors, and they've found that a downloadable form makes donors more comfortable. COVID has pushed more people online. Two years ago, 8 percent of donations came in online. In 2020, 12 percent came in online. That still means a lot of money comes in offline. Mail still works. COVID has proven that too.

Steven Shattuck: Good point. I feel like we could talk about this all day, but there's so much. Erica, this has been awesome. People should reach out. Is that okay with you?

Erica Waasdorp: Yes, absolutely. If you have questions I didn't answer, send me an email, and I'd be happy to respond.

Steven Shattuck: Awesome. We'll email everybody the slides and the recording, so be on the lookout. I'll send it right when we conclude. We've got some cool webinars coming up. I'll highlight next week's. Our buddy Chad Barger is joining us for a good old-fashioned donor acquisition presentation. That's a good dovetail with Erica's. Same time, same place next Thursday, exactly one week from now, minus one hour. It's totally free. Chad is a great guy.

Erica Waasdorp: Yes.

Steven Shattuck: We've got lots of other cool topics on the webinars, really diverse stuff. Check it out. We'd love to see you again. If you can come back every week, I'd love that. Hopefully we'll see you next week. If not, have a good rest of your Thursday, have a good weekend, stay safe and stay healthy. We need all of you out there doing your good work. We'll talk to you again soon.

Erica Waasdorp: Great.

Steven Shattuck: Bye now.

Erica Waasdorp: Thanks.

Steven Shattuck: See you.

‍

Key takeaways:

  • Monthly donors give more and stay longer. Erica says monthly gifts can be double or more the value of one-time gifts, and retention can reach 90 percent or higher when donors pay by ACH.
  • Give one person ownership and an hour a week. Erica suggests a "monthly donor Monday" hour, and says someone has to drive the work or it stalls.
  • Test these recurring donor acquisition tactics on your forms first. Offer a monthly-only page, add a monthly nudge to one-time forms, set monthly amounts about a third of the one-time amount, and don't pre-tick the monthly box.
  • Ask for monthly gifts in every channel you already use. Erica names email buttons, welcome series, thank-you letters, appeal reply forms, thank-you calls and texts as places to ask.
Helping you help others

Every act of generosity starts here.

Empower your team to connect deeply and fundraise confidently.