Webinar

The new donor playbook part one: Connecting your donor journey

New donors expect personalized, seamless experiences, but disconnected tools make follow-up slow and easy to miss. This webinar follows one donor from her first gift to recurring giving and her own peer-to-peer campaign. It covers tips for activating your network, simplifying giving, and automating new donor follow-up.

 Learning objectives:

  • Activate your existing supporters through peer-to-peer campaigns to find new donors.
  • Remove friction from online giving with mobile-friendly forms, multiple payment options, and shorter checkouts.
  • Automate new donor follow-up, from the first-gift phone call to volunteer invitations and birthday fundraisers.
  • Use unified donor data to spot high-potential supporters and move them toward a second gift and recurring giving.

Click here to download webinar slides.

Transcript:

Katie Gaston: Good morning, everyone. Welcome to our session this morning on the new donor playbook, how you can fuel your fundraising funnel. We’re going to get started in just a minute. Go ahead and keep funneling in. I know some of you, depending on where you are, may not have had your coffee yet, or you may be all the way to your lunch. We’re so glad you’re here. Go ahead and put in the chat where you’re joining from, and we’ll get started again in just a minute.

I personally am in not-very-sunny Boise, Idaho this morning. It’s getting a little cold. I know we have some other panelists on the call. Diana, where are you joining from this morning?

Diana Otero: Hi, Katie. Hi, everyone. I’m in Indianapolis, where it’s a cloudy, gray day.

Katie Gaston: I love it. Caleb, where are you joining from?

Caleb Jeffries: I’m joining from Brooklyn, New York, where it’s sixty-five and sunny today.

Katie Gaston: I’m jealous. Tiara’s with me in the mountain region. Go ahead, Tiara.

Tiara Stephen: I’m in Denver, Colorado. It’s a brisk fifty-four degrees, but nice and sunny. We’re getting more of that fall weather now, so very exciting.

Katie Gaston: I love it. We’ve got chilly Kansas City, Winter Garden, Florida, Erie, Pennsylvania. All over. I appreciate you all being here. And from sunny South Carolina, welcome, Darlene.

I think we can kick things off. We’ll keep letting folks fill in, but we’ve got a lot of great content to get to. First, a few housekeeping slides before we really jump in. We are, in fact, recording this webinar. That’s probably one question you had. If you registered, which you likely did since you’re here, we’ll send you the video and a copy of the slides later this afternoon. If you have any questions throughout the webinar, the best way to get them answered is the Q&A button at the bottom of your screen in Zoom. Click that and add your question there. As you’ve already started doing, you can use the chat for general discussion. If you hear something we say and you think, “Oh, I did that too,” or you’d like to throw out another idea, go ahead and put it in the chat. This is a community, collaborative session, so we love interactivity as we go.

To kick things off, we’re going to walk through the challenge around what makes it difficult to meet donor expectations all the time and build lasting relationships, particularly with new donors. What makes it challenging to grow your network today? We’ll walk through a scenario of what an ideal experience would look like, finding a new donor and cultivating them to become a lasting supporter, and then we’ll walk through why that’s actually really hard.

We’ll also explain some new donor tips and tricks. If you’re in a position where you’re trying to grow your donor network, we’ve got a whole section in today’s session just for you, with actionable takeaways you can apply this week. Then we’ll walk through what this looks like in the Bloomerang Giving Platform, wrap up with a few customer stories, and then take Q&A. Even though Q&A is at the end, we’ll be taking questions throughout, and we’ve got some points in the webinar where we’ll stop and get through them. So if you have a question burning on the top of your mind, go ahead and throw it in the Q&A.

With that in mind, I’m Katie Gaston, the director of product marketing here at Bloomerang. I’ve been here about three years, based in Boise, Idaho. But I’ve been in the nonprofit community, whether as a volunteer, a board member, or on the software side of the nonprofit space, for most of my life. I’d love to pass it over to Diana for an introduction.

Diana Otero: Hi, everyone. My name is Diana. I’m with our product marketing team here at Bloomerang, and I use my expertise in our CRM to help organizations like you strengthen donor relationships. I’ve been with Bloomerang for over a decade now, and my work is informed by my experience as a former nonprofit board member and ongoing volunteer with various organizations. I’m excited to share some practical tips with you today. And I think Caleb is up next.

Caleb Jeffries: Awesome. My name is Caleb. I lead our solution consultant team here at Bloomerang. If you’ve been on a demo with us, there’s a good chance you and I have met before. I bring about six years of experience at Bloomerang. Before that, I worked in the nonprofit sector briefly and got some database experience with really large databases, and I bring that to our customer conversations to help them understand the benefit of a purpose-focused CRM. Tiara?

Tiara Stephen: Hi, everybody. My name is Tiara Stephen. I’m also part of the product marketing team here at Bloomerang, as a product marketing associate. I got started through Bloomerang Fundraising, formerly Qgiv, about four years ago, so I’m passionate about all things fundraising, and acquiring new donors is certainly one of those things. I’m very excited about this topic today.

Katie Gaston: Thank you all for being here to present this topic with me, and thank you on the line for attending and listening in. Let’s kick things off. We know relationships fuel fundraising growth. It’s a pretty obvious connection: if you have strong relationships and continue to build and cultivate them, you’ll raise more for your nonprofit. But why is that hard today?

Donor expectations have consistently been increasing over the last few decades, and in particular over the last ten years. Think of a consumer experience. You buy something at a store or online, and there’s an ease that comes with it. You tap your card, or they know who you are and your preferences. You quick-buy on Amazon, and they know everything you’ve bought. Consumer experiences don’t always translate to fundraising, but I feel that what donors have experienced in the consumer world has heightened their expectations for personalized, seamless experiences when they give.

To compound that, we know that fewer and fewer donors have been giving over the past few years. So to meet donor expectations, you have to find those fewer donors and also meet their higher expectations. Why is that hard? A lot of reasons. You’re probably overloaded and wearing a ton of different hats. How do you have time to write personal communication for every donor, or to look at five or ten different ways for them to give, depending on their generation or their approach to giving? To try to solve that, you probably have a variety of systems you’re cobbling together to make it all work, to meet expectations, to save time, and to cultivate and build your network as quickly as possible.

The research shows, in the Chronicle of Philanthropy tech survey from this year, that most nonprofits use between ten and fifteen tools every single day. If that resonates, put it in the chat. How many tools have you used so far today, or how many types of tools do you juggle every week? It’s hard not just to learn all those tools, but to figure out how to get data from one system to another. And that matters because we know donors who are connected with your mission’s impact are more likely to give. To understand those donors so they can be connected to your impact, having a holistic view of them is really important, and that’s really hard if you’re using a lot of different systems.

So the first part today is what a path for a new donor could look like. As we go through it, there will be tips and tricks you can think about if you’re trying to acquire and find new donors. We’re going to start specifically with John. The path we’re following today is for Melanie. Melanie doesn’t know your organization yet, but she knows one of your board members, John. You had the idea to try to engage your board. We all know that engaging your board and getting them to serve or participate can be a really big challenge. Some of our nonprofits, using our peer-to-peer tools, host board peer-to-peer events. They give every board member a fundraising page, and each board member reaches out and cultivates their network. The transparency and accountability around how much they’ve raised for your nonprofit is really compelling.

So you heard that from a friend and thought, “That’s a really cool idea. I’m going to try it with my board.” You engage John. He’s got his peer-to-peer page, and he reaches out to his network and asks Melanie to give. Melanie really respects and appreciates John, and she also feels personally connected to the mission of your organization. So she decides, “Yeah, I’ll give to John. This is great.” A great way to find new donors is through a relationship they already have, not a direct ask. That’s tip number one.

At this point, Melanie isn’t in your systems yet, other than the peer-to-peer tool. You don’t know her personally, but she just gave through John for her first gift. Your first step, ideally, is to bring all of that information from the peer-to-peer tool into your CRM so you have it in one place. But to do that, you have to export from your peer-to-peer tool and import into the CRM, and that takes quite a bit of time. You still don’t know who Melanie is personally. She’s just one of seventy donors who gave in this campaign that you’re trying to get into your CRM.

Now you want to figure out who could be a really good donor prospect among those who just gave. So you say, “Now that they’re in the CRM, I’ll overlay some wealth insights.” If you don’t know what those are, they’re things like how much she gave last year, the biggest gift she’s ever given, or organizations she typically gives to, so you can see parallels with your mission. After all of that analysis, which takes quite a bit of time because it’s not just for Melanie but for the other seventy donors, about four hours, you realize Melanie could be a really good prospect for a deeper relationship.

At that point you say, “I want to invite Melanie to volunteer with my organization.” That’s a great next step in her journey to continue to engage. So you invite Melanie to volunteer, though again, this takes a while, because you’ve identified a good number of new prospects you also want to volunteer, and you’ve got to write emails and make sure they go out to those specific individuals.

Melanie is thrilled. She loves the mission. She signs up to volunteer as soon as she hears from you, though she was a little disappointed that when she gave that first gift, it took her a while to hear from your organization. Again, it’s a process. It takes time to get through each step. As soon as she volunteers, she has a great experience. She’s wonderful, engaged, and passionate. But all of her hours are logged in your volunteer management tool, so you have to export all those hours and import them into her record in your CRM, and that takes a while because it was everyone who went to that volunteer event.

But you say, “Of all the people who volunteered, there are a few I really want to cultivate to give again.” So you bring Melanie, as one of a hundred other donors, into a donation campaign, trying to nurture those donors, but that takes a lot of emails, texts, phone calls, and meetings. Ultimately, it works for Melanie. She gives again. And here’s the tip: a second gift is a huge milestone. So it’s not just about how to grow your new network, but how to get them to that second gift. That’s very opportune for growing and sustaining a larger network of donors.

Melanie gives, and you’re thrilled. She’s been engaged and volunteering all year, so you want to continue to recognize and cultivate her. You host a volunteer event. That takes a while for staff to put on, but it pays off. Melanie deepens her commitment and becomes a recurring, sustaining donor for your organization. That’s the ultimate goal: moving someone from a new donor to a sustaining giver.

And Melanie is so connected to your mission that the final step in this journey is that she wants to give back. For her birthday, she hosts another peer-to-peer event, where she brings in her network. Again, the cycle of continuous growth pays back for your organization, because she wants to multiply her impact for what she’s experienced.

So this is an ideal journey. Right? Kind of. Our estimate is that it takes up to two years and a lot of time to get from step to step with those ten to fifteen tools you’re probably using today. And despite your best efforts, it’s very possible Melanie won’t get to that final step. She may not host her birthday fundraiser. She may not attend that volunteer event. She may not give the second donation or volunteer, and you may not even know she’s a good-quality donor prospect, because at every step there’s a failure point from the lack of connection between systems and how much time it takes to get from one step to the next.

We fundamentally believe, and we know, that there’s a better way. Imagine if Melanie’s journey didn’t require so many hurdles, and every step was connected and automated throughout. If the donor story looks like Melanie’s but without the inefficiencies, imagine how much more your nonprofit could achieve and how much larger your donor growth could be.

So, introducing the connected donor journey. Take the same path we just looked at with Melanie. As a new donor, imagine that as soon as she gives, she’s automatically added to a volunteer campaign that invites her to that first volunteer event, trying to engage her more deeply with your organization. You then overlay generosity and engagement data for everyone who volunteered, and you can immediately see, without four hours of analysis, that she’s a really good donor prospect. And at every single step, all of the next journeys are automated, whether that’s a repeat donation, a recurring gift, or the milestone of volunteering a certain number of hours. The process of getting from step one to hosting her own peer-to-peer fundraiser is much more likely and much easier for you, because there are so many fewer chances for things to fall off. If you could do that, imagine how much more you could do as an organization.

That’s the promise of the giving platform. The Giving Platform from Bloomerang combines volunteer management, fundraising, and CRM into a single solution that helps you fuel your next-level impact. Imagine how much more you could do within your community by not having to go through that [unclear] curve for every new donor. It means less guesswork and more growth for you. The best part is that it was purpose-built just for nonprofits like you, by people at Bloomerang with extensive experience working within and supporting the nonprofit community.

By bringing these tools together, CRM, volunteer, and fundraising, we can do things you can’t do with separate tools, like personalizing campaigns in meaningful ways for new donors, or doing volunteer-driven fundraising. Volunteers are a type of donor we may forget to cultivate as potential donors in our network, or to engage at a deeper level. All of these things are possible because one platform brings them together into a single, unified solution.

With that in mind, I’m going to transition and pass it to Diana, who will share tips and tricks you can take from some of what we talked about, no matter where you are in your journey with technology, to grow your donor network. Diana, take it away.

Diana Otero: Thanks, Katie, for walking us through the perils of a disconnected donor journey and the promise and potential of a connected one. Now let’s look at some practical tips to help you bring this new donor playbook to life.

One of the most powerful yet underutilized assets any nonprofit has is its existing community of supporters. These are people who already believe in your mission. How do we empower them to become ambassadors? This is all about activating your network.

First, consider launching peer to peer campaigns. I love this because it’s a year-round fundraising solution where you empower your supporters to create their own fundraising pages and reach out to their personal networks. I know for myself, I’m more likely to give to an organization I know nothing about if a friend or family member is doing a peer-to-peer campaign than if a nonprofit reaches out to me cold. I think that’s true for most people. It’s more personal and more compelling than a generic appeal. And the data backs this up. While ten percent of donors in the US and Canada already participate in peer-to-peer fundraising, there is so much more room for growth. These campaigns extend your reach exponentially, bringing in new donors you might never have connected with otherwise.

Second, make it incredibly easy for them to share your mission. You in the fundraiser seat live this every day, but that isn’t necessarily true for our donors and supporters, and it doesn’t have to be hard for them. This can be as simple as a page on your website with prewritten social media posts, powerful images ready to share, and links to your donation page. When you remove the friction, you make it effortless for someone to share a post, send an email, or text a friend about your cause. You’re giving them the tools to tell your story for you.

Finally, recognize and reward your advocates. This doesn’t have to be a complex or extensive program. You can acknowledge top fundraisers in your newsletter, give them a social media shout-out, or share exclusive updates with your most dedicated ambassadors. A little appreciation goes a long way in showing your supporters that their efforts are valued, and it encourages them to keep advocating for your mission. By turning your supporters into active partners, you don’t just raise more money. You build a dedicated community that will fuel your growth for years to come.

We have some great tools at Bloomerang to help with this. For example, we have great peer-to-peer fundraising tools, and because the data is unified in Bloomerang, you can see who your top supporters are and easily recognize and celebrate them with our built-in communication tools.

The next thing I want to talk about is how to engage across generations. A one-size-fits-all approach no longer works. As Katie mentioned earlier, donors don’t just want personalization. They expect it. Our supporters span multiple generations, and each group has unique motivations, communication preferences, and ways of giving. To truly connect, we have to engage across generations by tailoring our approach.

First, the message itself. We need to craft generation-specific messages. For Gen Z and millennials, that means focusing on immediate social impact, transparency, and authenticity. They often connect with causes through dynamic social media content. While we know women make up sixty-seven percent of donors, we also see that younger donors are far more likely to be inspired to give through a social media post. On the other hand, Gen X and boomers often respond more to stories that show long-term results and legacy-building opportunities, which can be delivered through channels like direct mail and email. The message must match the mindset.

Second, we need to diversify our giving channels. It’s all about meeting donors where they are. For tech-savvy audiences, or digital natives as we like to call them, a seamless, mobile-friendly donation page or a text-to-donate option is essential. Any friction in the process can lead to a lost donation. At the same time, we must ensure that traditional methods of giving, like mail-in forms or in-person giving at an event, stay simple and accessible for supporters who prefer them.

Finally, giving isn’t always about money. We should highlight different ways to contribute for generations who may have more time than income at this point in their lives. Showcasing volunteer opportunities or digital advocacy roles can be a powerful way to get them involved. For more established donors, providing clear information on planned giving, endowments, or major gifts allows them to make a lasting impact that aligns with their financial goals. By understanding and respecting these generational differences, we can build stronger, more meaningful relationships with every supporter and make sure our mission resonates for years to come.

You can tailor your messages and giving options to any generation with our built-in communication tools and our robust set of fundraising tools.

The third thing I want to talk about, as much as I love data and numbers, is that we need to be visual and show our stories. Facts and statistics can validate our impact, but when it comes to connecting with donors on a meaningful level, nothing is more effective than showing the true story behind your mission.

First, find and share authentic stories. Bring forward the real voices of the people you serve, stories that help donors see the change they make possible. A personal story about a single life transformed creates an emotional bridge that no data point can. That kind of authenticity moves someone from interest to action.

Second, visualize your impact. Address the different modalities our donors have. Use infographics, progress photos, and even short videos to bring to life the difference donations are making. Instead of just saying “we served five hundred meals,” show the faces around the table, or a time-lapse of your work in action, or a house being built from the ground up. We know that thirty-two percent of donors are most inspired to give after seeing stories and visuals on social media. So let your supporters see the transformation happening in real time.

And finally, keep your narrative alive. Donor relationships are built on ongoing trust, not just one-off successes. When people feel included in your evolving story, they become part of your mission, which leads to longer, more committed support. So show, don’t just tell, and your donors will want to help write the next chapter with you. We have some great tools in Bloomerang to help with this: our built-in communication tools, and one of our newer features, Journey Automation, to guide donors along that experience.

The next one almost feels funny to say, because everybody should be doing this by now, but it still bears repeating: we need to simplify giving. Think about this. You’ve inspired a potential donor with your mission, and they’re ready to make a gift. This is a very critical moment, and any friction in the giving process can cause them to abandon it entirely. That’s why creating a seamless giving experience isn’t just a convenience. It’s essential for turning interest into impact.

First, optimize for mobile. More and more people are engaging with causes and making donations directly from their smartphones. If your donation form is difficult to navigate on a small screen, you’re losing money. This has happened to me. A friend invited me to an event, and I went to register, and no matter how I rotated my phone, something always covered the donate button. I kind of gave up and thought, “I’ll just show up and hope there are tickets.” Luckily, there were. But imagine how many potential donors did that and never gave you that gift. A clean, responsive design is non-negotiable. The data shows that mobile-optimized pages see a fifty percent increase in completed transactions. You really have to make it easy for someone to give on the go.

Second, offer multiple payment options. People expect the same ease of use from a donation page that they get from their favorite online stores. That means accepting not just credit cards, but also digital wallets like Apple Pay, Google Pay, and PayPal, and direct bank transfers. By offering a variety of choices, you remove barriers and let donors give in the way that’s most convenient for them. The goal is to say yes to every possible form of payment, so you capture donors when they’re inspired to give. Say I’m scrolling and I see a friend fundraising for their favorite cause. I may not have my wallet on me, but if I can donate through my phone with Apple Pay, that’s so much easier, and it removes the likelihood that I’ll forget later, when I’d have to go find my wallet.

Third, simplify the checkout process. Every extra field a donor has to fill out and every click they have to make increases the chance they’ll walk away. Review your donation form and be ruthless. We’re heading into a really busy giving season, so I’d encourage you to test the process yourself. If you find it frustrating to fill out, your donors will feel the same way. A fast, simple process respects the donor’s time and makes sure their generous impulse is captured before it fades. By making the act of giving as easy as possible, you show donors you value their support, and you make it far more likely they’ll complete the gift and come back to give again.

Bloomerang helps with this in many ways. Bloomerang Fundraising has a suite of tools that supercharge your online fundraising and give you higher conversion rates, higher average donations, and higher one-time gift amounts. Who wouldn’t want that?

To sum it all up, we’ve given you a lot of tips, and really, you want to leverage tech for growth. Whatever technology you’re using, you want it to work for you. In today’s world, the most successful nonprofits aren’t just passionate about their mission. They’re also smart about their operations. Technology allows us to scale our efforts, deepen our relationships, and ultimately drive more impact.

How do we do that? First, automate your outreach. Think about the critical touchpoints in a new donor’s journey: the welcome message, the thank-you note or phone call, the first impact update. These can and should be automated. Setting up simple email journeys ensures that every donor receives timely, personalized communication without adding hours of manual work for your team, like Katie showed us earlier with that disconnected journey. That consistency builds trust and keeps your organization top of mind.

Second, centralize your data. If your donor information is scattered across spreadsheets, email lists, and event rosters, you can’t see the full picture. Use a giving platform that brings everything into one place, one that tracks every interaction, every gift, every volunteer activity, and every event attendance. That’s the foundation for effective personalization, and it lets you understand your supporters at a deeper level.

Third, use that data. The right technology helps you uncover hidden trends. Who are your most consistent donors? Who has the potential to become a major giver? The data has those answers. By focusing your outreach on the most promising segments, you can maximize your efforts. We know that nonprofits using automation and CRM tools can see a sixty-one percent increase in matching gift revenue alone, simply by identifying eligible donors and automating the follow-up.

Finally, we’re seeing that AI is transforming how nonprofits connect with their supporters. It helps you work smarter by predicting donor behavior so you can focus on the right opportunities at the right time. With AI, you can also personalize outreach like never before, so you can create meaningful connections that inspire action. It also streamlines your efforts by analyzing data and offering insights to optimize campaigns, saving you a lot of time and helping you maximize your impact, all while helping you achieve your mission more efficiently. By embracing the right tools, you free up your team to focus on what you do best: building relationships and fulfilling your mission.

I know I just talked a lot, so I’m going to pause for a quick check-in with Tiara. Do we have any questions at this point?

Tiara Stephen: It doesn’t look like we have any questions, but I do have one for you, Diana. With all of these wonderful tools and strategies you’ve mentioned, what is the benefit of having them all in one place, as compared to using third-party tools?

Diana Otero: With third-party tools, there can still be an integration, but you’re limited in what that integration looks like. You’re not really sure how things are going to come in, or whether you’re getting all of the information. Sometimes it’s not integrated at all. If everything is under one platform, it gives you peace of mind that all of your data is in one place. You’re not miscommunicating with donors because of bad information, and you’re preserving those relationships. That doesn’t even include all the time it saves you from collecting data and validating that it’s coming across correctly, the way you want it. To me, all of that sums up as peace of mind, so you can communicate with your donors confidently.

Awesome. Yeah.

Katie Gaston: I was going to jump in and add something, Diana, but if you want to continue, you’re welcome to.

Diana Otero: I was going to say I think some of our panelists might have passionate opinions about this too.

Katie Gaston: I do, which is why I jumped right in. Your point about third-party integrations versus having everything under one roof is really astute, in the sense that you don’t always know exactly how an integration is going to be built. The power of having everything in one ecosystem is that information can flow from one system to the other, and potentially back. For example, I mentioned earlier that if you haven’t thought about your really impassioned, engaged volunteers, research shows ninety percent of volunteers also want to give to your mission and typically will. That’s a really good opportunity to find new donors, and donors are probably going to volunteer with you too. So if you haven’t thought about it, bring that data not just from your volunteer management to your CRM, but back into your volunteer management. It can help you show engagement across the board.

Diana Otero: Love that. Thanks for the question, Tiara. I’m excited, because I’m sure Caleb is going to show us a story using our actual tools. Caleb, please show us how this works in action.

Caleb Jeffries: Awesome. Give me one second here. Is everyone able to see my screen?

Diana Otero: We can.

Caleb Jeffries: All right. Let’s start where Diana started a little while ago, when she talked about activating your network. What do we mean by that, and how can we help? Katie gave the example of what many of our customers are doing right now, which is enabling their boards to fundraise through a peer-to-peer campaign. If you’re like me, the first time you saw a peer-to-peer campaign was probably through an endurance event, maybe someone running a 5K or a marathon to raise money. Our customers have gotten really creative with this, so we mocked this up based on some of what we’ve heard from them.

You can throw it in the chat: does your board of directors have a fundraising requirement to be on the board, maybe a give-or-get? In this case, we’re looking at a board member who does have one of those requirements. Virginia is pretty early in the process. She has one two-hundred-and-fifty-dollar gift and a long way to go. What’s cool is that we’ve enabled her with this tool so that when she goes out to fundraise, she can send this page to her network. Even if the folks in her network don’t know about your organization, they know Virginia, and she shares her personal story right here with anybody who sees this page. She’s able to bring in money for that fundraising requirement.

Let me be the first to say that the money from a campaign like this is great. It’s great to get the money in. But what we really want to focus on is the activation of Virginia’s network, because she’s an advocate for you. She’s already activated. She’s on the board. Now it’s on her to tell that story, and we want to give you the tools to put in her hands so that when she sends this out, she knows the donations that come in will be automatically attributed to her, so she knows where she stands on her fundraising goal.

But this also brings all of that information directly into your CRM, and that’s the benefit of having it all on a single platform. If somebody makes that two-hundred-and-fifty-dollar gift, yes, it’s great that you got it, but you also have a new donor you can cultivate. That’s the connected journey Katie showed, and how we can take advantage of it. So that donation comes in. What’s next?

Bloomerang has a really cool way of engaging with different donors depending on the journey you want them to go through. This is Journey Automation, and it automates parts of your communication to donors based on things they’ve done. In this case, the person who donated to Virginia’s campaign made a first-time gift, so they’re in our first-time donor automation. What happens here? The first step can be a call, a task, or a time delay. For a first-time donor, we want this to be a call, and you should want this to be a call too, because we know donors who receive a phone call within forty-eight hours after their first gift are dramatically more likely to make an additional donation. So we want to make sure that first step is a phone call, not just an email.

You make the phone call, and then you can say, “We’ll wait two days.” After that, they get an email specifically for them that tells them a bit more about your organization. Again, this person knows Virginia. We don’t want to assume they know anything about your organization. So make sure you have a message that thanks them for the gift and shares a little about what you have going on.

A great next step in cultivating them, which we saw on the donor journey slide, could be inviting them to come volunteer. Maybe the ultimate goal is to get them to give a recurring gift, give a major gift, or fundraise for you, but they just gave a gift. You don’t want to make it another ask right now. You want to share more about what’s happening. So you can invite them to volunteer. As part of the Bloomerang platform, we actually have a full volunteer management tool. She gets the email, it takes her to a page where she can read about your different volunteer opportunities, and then she can register to volunteer. This is the form your volunteer would fill out.

So they’ve made the donation, they got that second email in the series, and now they’re here, registering to volunteer. They answer volunteer-specific questions, potentially sign a waiver, and tell you about their availability and skill set, and then they may actually come and volunteer. But again, this isn’t a disjointed platform. You’re using Bloomerang Volunteer with Bloomerang. What that allows you to do is this: as soon as someone signs up to volunteer, if you go into the CRM and look at a profile like this, I can come over to the profile tab and see that they’ve automatically been tagged as a volunteer right here. As they move through that journey, I get a full picture of them on this profile view, so I have a holistic understanding of all the contributions they’re making to my organization: the donations, the volunteerism, the volunteer hours, all showing up here. In that disjointed journey, you could still get all of this into a CRM, but you’d spend a lot of time moving data from system to system, and you’d potentially miss opportunities along the way.

Let me show you an example. If I come over to the summary tab for Harold, you’ll see two bright red lines. We hear from Bloomerang customers all the time that this is one of their favorite features, and here’s why. It gives you insight into their relationship with you, but also their potential relationship with you as an organization. The engagement meter shows a summary of everything they’ve done with us. That could be a donation, multiple donations, or volunteer hours. Are they opening emails? Are they clicking on links? It’s very holistic, but it’s all related to you.

The generosity score comes from our partners at DonorSearch. It helps you understand their giving potential based on data in the public record: wealth information, real estate information, things like that. If you’ve used a wealth tool, you’re familiar with this data, but we provide it to customers so that if someone signs up for a peer-to-peer event, buys a ticket to a gala, or signs up to volunteer, you get their name and address, and that’s all you need to get this generosity score information. If you have disjointed systems and you’re importing your data from another tool into Bloomerang, yes, that’s a lot of work, but you also might miss an opportunity to cultivate a donor in person. How much better would it be if you knew someone was a potential major donor before your event, as opposed to after the fact, when you do that import? That’s a huge missed opportunity. We can use this information to understand that this person is potentially a really generous donor, and we can put them into another journey.

If they had only volunteered once and given one donation, their score would be a little lower, but we’d see there’s a lot of opportunity to cultivate this person. I can go back to the journey automation page I was looking at a second ago, and I want to show you a couple of other ways you can continue cultivating people.

Down here at the bottom, I have a birthday automation. In the same way that you can use a first-time gift as a point to automate a communication series, you can also use their birthday, if you have it. You probably remember a few years ago, you couldn’t get on Facebook without seeing a birthday fundraiser someone was doing for a nonprofit, but we want you to have the tools to facilitate that directly. If you have someone’s birthday, they get a happy-birthday email that invites them to set up another peer-to-peer fundraiser. You could also do this with a donor anniversary. We know not every organization has everyone’s birthday, so you can use the one-year anniversary of their first gift as another entry point. Let me show you what this looks like. Give me one second. I thought I had all my tabs pulled up, but I don’t. Here we go.

You’ll use the journey automation tool to send them to a page like this. Maybe it’s for their birthday. You’ll have this link in their email first thing in the morning when they wake up, and you’re not just wishing them a happy birthday. You’re inviting them to partner with you to raise funds, potentially in lieu of birthday gifts. They can come here and create their own fundraiser, set their own fundraising goal so they can set a reasonable goal for themselves, and then we make it really easy for them to share on Facebook, by email, or anywhere their friends might look on their birthday. That’s one way to get people who only found out about you through that network activation to get really involved in your organization and activate their own network, and then the cycle continues.

I don’t have the chat open, but are there any questions about what we’re looking at here?

Tiara Stephen: It doesn’t look like we have any questions yet, Caleb.

Caleb Jeffries: All good. Sweet. I don’t know who I turn it back over to, but I’ll turn it back to Diana.

Diana Otero: Thanks, Caleb. Just to recap, and I’m sure this will give people time to think about their questions, we wanted to show you how the Bloomerang Giving Platform can help you attract new supporters. Attracting new supporters is all about making it easy for people to engage with your mission. With tools like high-converting forms and peer-to-peer campaigns, we help you reach new audiences and turn that interest into action.

Also, personalized journeys. Once you’ve connected with your supporters, the next step is building those relationships. Our Journey Automation feature lets you create tailored experiences, whether it’s welcoming a first-time donor, stewarding a major gift, or celebrating different milestones. It’s about making every interaction meaningful.

As we mentioned earlier, and as Tiara asked about, unified data is where the magic happens. By bringing all your supporter information into one place, you can see the full picture and the full breadth of their giving. That means you can identify your most engaged donors and act on those insights to strengthen those relationships.

And finally, certainly not least, it’s about turning your supporters into champions. Whether they become volunteers, recurring donors, or fundraisers, Bloomerang gives you the tools to activate their passion and keep them engaged in your mission. At the end of the day, Bloomerang is designed to help you work smarter, not harder, so you can focus on what matters most, making a difference. Next, before we head into our formal Q&A, let’s hear some customer success stories from Katie.

Katie Gaston: Thanks so much, Diana. I always love talking about customers within our nonprofit network achieving their goals. It brings me joy, and I’m sure everyone else on the line too. The first I want to share is the Delores Project. The Delores Project was a small development shop, and they explored Journey Automation, which Caleb and Diana both talked about. It’s one of our newest features, about automating what that journey looks like and giving you the tools to cultivate a donor from new donor to someone who supports and sustains your mission long term.

That’s what they were trying to do, but in their prior solution, which was Mailchimp, they had a hard time figuring out how to do that efficiently, and ultimately it wasn’t solving their needs. So they used Journey Automation to build an email and task flow. Within the first six months of using the tool, they gained five hundred new donors. Even better, they saved a significant amount of time every week. We asked for their estimate, and it was one to three hours saved, which they could invest back into relationships with their donors.

The other customer I’d love to share is Brother Wolf Animal Rescue. Brother Wolf used Bloomerang for customized reports, and ultimately moved from another CRM to Bloomerang. They needed better data hygiene. We could all attest that your CRM or your solution is only as good as your data, so having a system that prioritizes clean, impactful data is important. They used the Bloomerang giving form specifically to launch an emergency response fundraising campaign, which helped them create clear data entry rules, and in this campaign they raised over a million dollars. Really impressive impact, and a significant number of new donors: over five thousand new donors just for the animal rescue.

Even more impressive, by bringing all of those systems together, they didn’t let those five thousand new donors be just one-time donors. They maintained a sixty-one percent donor retention rate, which is some of the best I’ve seen in the industry, probably fifteen percent better than the standard baseline. Really powerful, impactful results from two customers who have gone through the exact journey we talked about today: not just finding new donors, but cultivating them to become sustaining advocates for your organization.

With that in mind, I want to go through what’s next, and then we’ll take any questions you have. This is the first webinar in a series we’re doing. If you’re trying to level up your skills, get ready for fundraising season, or get ready for the new year, you’re in the right place. The New Donor Playbook is the first of three webinars we’ll be doing, and we’ll repeat them on a monthly basis.

The next one I want to highlight is the Donor Cultivation Playbook. We talked a little about that today, but we’ll go even more in depth with tools, tips, and tricks. I’m sure you’re here because you want more donors, but we talked not just about getting new donors, but about the importance of cultivating them. We’ll walk through all of the tips and tricks you need to maximize that middle part of the journey and move donors from one-time to recurring, sustaining givers.

Some other webinars to put on your calendar if you’d like to learn more before giving season: “Where Strategic Planning and Fundraising Meet,” on November sixth. And finally, “Contact Info Cleanup: Practical Prep for Year-End Outreach.” We just talked about that with Brother Wolf, but the quality of your data impacts the quality of the relationships you can build, so make sure your data is clean before you start your year-end outreach.

With that in mind, we’ve got some questions. Tiara, where should we start?

Tiara Stephen: Absolutely. We have a question from Jackie. She’s asking, is it easy to segment donors by age group or generation?

Diana Otero: That’s a great question, and it really depends on what data you have about your donors. If you don’t have specific data on their generation or age, you can look at donor behavior. Do you see them responding to your emails more? Responding to your letters more? Giving online versus giving at events? Even if you don’t have that specific demographic data, you can still look at behavioral data to point you in the right direction and see what they’re more receptive to. Any additional insights from our other panelists?

Caleb Jeffries: I think you nailed it. There are obviously ways to get some of that information. When you have an initial donation form on your page, you don’t want to ask a billion questions of your donors. You want to keep things really simple. It can be tempting to ask, “What’s your birthday?” or things like that you can use later. There are a lot of opportunities to get that further down the road, so be strategic about when you ask. Data can be really powerful, but you don’t want to create a scenario where it takes too long to complete your donation form and the donations never convert at all.

Tiara Stephen: Amazing.

Katie Gaston: Does anybody else have any questions? Feel free to drop them in the chat or in the Q&A. It looks like you all did such a great job with the information that you shared. I’ll call out Leslie, who has been really good at putting questions in the chat. Earlier in the session she asked how to connect her donor engagement welcome series. Caleb, I know you talked about that, but maybe we can address it as a question. When a new gift comes in, how does that get triggered in Journey Automation?

Caleb Jeffries: I might let Diana add if she has anything. The simplest way is that we have those really donor-specific entry criteria. Think of a first-time donation, a next donation, or an initial recurring donation. Those are the larger entry points. Within that, you can add more granularity. If you want to say, “This is the path for someone whose donation came through peer-to-peer,” or “This is the path for someone whose first donation came through a birthday campaign,” you can customize that for those specific things. When it comes to your specific engagement, every organization tracks that a little differently, but you can actually use adding someone to a group as a trigger. Even if you have something really complicated, adding someone to a group can trigger a journey. If you have questions about it, our team can help in a more one-on-one setting, whether you’re an existing customer or a potential customer. We’d love to talk more about it.

Diana Otero: To add to what Caleb said, I’d bring it a little higher. I’d start with what you’re trying to do. What are your goals? For example, for next year, are you trying to improve your first-time donor retention rate? Get more first-time donors? Get more recurring givers? That will tell you which segments to focus on. I’ll tell you right now, you’ll be tempted to do everything, and you need to think about your bandwidth and your appetite, and prioritize. What is the most important thing? Which segment is the most important to be communicating with right now? And how do you envision the journey for that specific segment? If you’re focusing on new donors, what is the new donor journey you want to take them on? If you’re focusing on major donors, what’s the journey you want to take them on? Think about what that journey looks like, and then start building from there.

Katie Gaston: Awesome. It’s a great question, and I’ll add one more point. I talked about the customer that moved from Mailchimp. When you think about Journey Automation and why we built it the way we did, we built it based on what a nonprofit needs. Even if you had another solution where you could trigger something in Mailchimp, the way the new donation criteria works is based on what you might have, just like Diana said, and what types of journeys you need for your donors.

When you’re thinking about year-end fundraising, Diana, your point about not boiling the ocean is great. Just start somewhere. Think about what you need in the next three months. If you’re feeling overwhelmed, thinking, “Oh my gosh, I can’t build all these journeys right now,” that’s okay. What’s going to happen in the next three months? You’re probably going to get a lot of new donors. So maybe you just start with a new donor journey. Then maybe next year, if you’re doing a capital campaign, you look at identifying your mid-level donors, which we’ll talk about in the next webinar, shameless plug, and how you can cultivate them to become major donors. Seasonally, maybe set a goal of doing one type of automation every quarter, or once a month if you have the time, and align it with what you think is happening in your donor base at that time.

Diana Otero: That’s the beauty of it, as Katie said. It becomes automated. You set it up now, and it just keeps going. The next time, you don’t have to redo it. You can move down your priority list and keep automating things, so you don’t have to keep doing them over and over.

Katie Gaston: Tiara, I’m going to take your job. Leslie asked a really good question: what’s the best way to learn the system? I get excited because we have a lot of really good tools to learn Bloomerang. I’ll mention some, and Caleb and Diana, feel free to jump in. We have Bloomerang Learning, an in-app education experience. No matter what you’re doing, there’s a guided e-learning module you can go through at your own pace whenever you need to understand how to achieve that thing. If e-learning doesn’t work for your learning style, we also have weekly group webinars. You can register for those in Bloomerang Learning. We also have a customer conference next year called GiveCon®. If you love getting to know other individuals in the nonprofit network and walking away with a ton of actionable tips and tricks, look it up. Registration is open right now, but it does fill up. If you’re a Bloomerang customer, or you’re not yet but want to learn more, that’s a great opportunity.

Diana, Caleb, anything else? We’re about at time, so maybe we can wrap up with this.

Diana Otero: The last thing I’ll say is that a lot of our customers say one of their favorite things about Bloomerang is that it’s easy to use. If you can get in there and test a couple of things, I promise you’re not going to break anything, and it will give you a confidence boost to keep learning and using the system.

Katie Gaston: Thank you all for taking the time today. We hope to see you at the next session in about a month. Have a wonderful rest of your October and a great rest of your day. Thanks so much. Bye.

Key takeaways:

  • New donor follow-up starts with the first gift. A second gift is a major milestone for growing a lasting donor network, so plan what happens right after the first gift, not just how to find new donors.
  • Call new donors within 48 hours. Caleb Jeffries notes that donors who get a phone call within 48 hours of a first gift are far more likely to give again. Follow the call with an email that introduces your organization, then a volunteer invitation instead of another ask.
  • Activate your existing network. Peer-to-peer campaigns, such as board-member fundraising pages, bring in new donors through relationships they already have. Make sharing effortless and recognize your top advocates.
  • Remove friction when donors are ready to give. Optimize forms for mobile, offer multiple payment options, and cut unnecessary fields. Mobile-optimized pages see about a 50 percent increase in completed transactions, according to the presenters.
  • Connected, automated journeys prevent drop-off. Disconnected tools create failure points at every step, while automating welcome, thank-you, volunteer, and birthday touchpoints keeps new donors moving toward a second gift.
Helping You Help Others

Every act of generosity starts here.

Empower your team to connect deeply and fundraise confidently.