Webinar

How to convert event attendees into donors

Join fundraising master trainer, Chad Barger, CFRE, CNP, for a workshop focused on converting one time event attendees into regular donors for your nonprofit organization. Chad will review a step by step process that you can immediately put into action with your next event.

Learning Objectives:

‍• Learn what is necessary to convert event attendees to regular donors.
• See real life examples of how this has been done at nonprofits and how those examples can be adapted for their fundraising operation.

Access Chad's slides here.
‍
View Chad's events webinar recording on this page!
‍
Access Chad's Fundraising Events Wishboard here.
View fundraising ideas evaluation sheet on this page
.
‍
Explore Chad's fundraising resource library here.
‍
Check out Chad's fundraising webinars on this page.

Transcript:

Kate Kramer: Hey, all. So glad to see you for our presentation of Fundraising Focus Week. I'm going to give it a few minutes while everybody's rolling into the room.

While we're waiting, please drop in the chat where you're joining from and what the weather's like, or what afternoon beverage you're having. Chad, I know you're on the road today. I am on the road too. I'm in sunny Scottsdale, Arizona. Just finished a board training with a bunch of great nonprofit organizations, and now I'm in their boardroom, talking to all of you. It's, you know, what, eleven o'clock, and I think ninety-nine degrees. So here we go. Oh my gosh.

We've got people joining from Winchester, Virginia. That's right near where I am. North Carolina, Knoxville. I don't want to take up too much of our time, because I do want to make sure it's a short and sweet presentation today. So we'll roll into a few housekeeping tips.

We are recording this webinar. You'll get the slides later today, as well as the recording.

A little bit different than normal. We're not going to take questions. Please do still put them in the question and answer box. We're going to save those and answer them tomorrow for our live panel. If you were not signed up for the panel, I think we can drop that link in the chat, and you can still get signed up for that as well.

We haven't had a chance to meet. I'm Kate Kramer. I'm the partner marketing manager here at Bloomerang. We are an online platform for all of your organization's volunteer management, donor management, and fundraising needs.

And until the end of the month, we have a pretty fantastic offer. If you buy fundraising success, you can replace our donate feature, Bloomerang Payments, and several others. I'll drop that link in the chat.

One last thing before I turn it over to Chad. We will be drawing another lucky Uber Eats winner today, so stick around till the end and see if your name gets called.

Now, without further ado, I'm so happy to have Chad Barger here with us today. He is the founder of Productive Fundraising. Welcome, Chad.

Chad Barger: Great. Thank you, Kate. So thrilled to be back with you all for another Bloomerang webinar. Thank you all for saying where you're coming from. We've got so much territory covered. I have this jam-packed today, so I'm going to cut the chit-chat, go ahead and share my screen, and hop right into it.

Okay. So today, we've had two days already. We've talked about the impact of events and major donors, and how those work together. Yesterday we talked about event design a little bit. I want to pick it up right there with event design and talk about, okay, it's after the event. Actually, even before the event happens, what can we do to make sure we are optimized to not just have one-time transactional donors, but to use this event as a way to form new relationships with long-time donors?

It's a process. It's not one simple magic bullet that is going to do this for you. If you want to go through this, it's a year-round process, or at least a six-month process. But let's start right here.

Two very different fundraising events. Here's the first one. You're all very familiar with it. You've probably been to many. It happens in the same hotel ballroom, with the same boring chicken and rice dinner, for multiple organizations in your town. That's not what we're after here. That is not how we're getting new folks interested in our cause.

Second event: you don't know where you're going. You sign up. Twenty-four hours before the event, you're given a parking location. You get there. It's a warehouse. You walk through a spotlit, unmarked door, and you see this. There's a red carpet, and you're entering underneath the train of the dress of a harpist. You get into the event, and they have completely transformed a warehouse with lighting and chandeliers and everything to be a host for an art gala.

Which one would you rather attend? Give me event number one in the chat or event number two in the chat, and let's see what we get. Rapid fire. Folks, we're seeing them coming in, lots and lots of twos. So we need to be thinking about what our donors actually want to attend, because if we're not getting new donors, the process I'm going to walk you through is pointless.

Before we do that, let's remind ourselves of the purpose of events. This is not the purpose of events everywhere, but this was always my purpose of events. I'm going to be very honest. When I was a frontline development director for twenty years, my least favorite thing was fundraising events. They were just so tiring. It took so much time. Yes, it's fun. You get to engage and see your donors, but it's so much work. So if I was going to do it, I wanted to really get a return on investment, and for me, that meant getting new people there. For me, the primary purpose of a fundraising event was always acquisition. I wanted new donors there, people who had never interacted with our organization before. A win for me was an event with thirty to forty percent new people, people I then had the opportunity to connect with and build a relationship with. Acquisition is what I'm after.

Let's look at our Giving USA chart. Where does most of the money come from? From individuals. Sixty-eight percent is where that comes from. This is my best way to meet new individual donors. But we have to structure our event in a way where that is communicated. We need to let our event committee know. Our board, instead of bringing the same three couples they've brought to this event for the last five years, maybe they bring three new couples and ask the folks who have been attending to buy their own tables. Communicating that one of our key goals is to have a high percentage of new-to-us people there is key. The people who come all the time would probably respond to our mailings.

So the primary purpose of a fundraising event should be to find new individual donors. I can raise money other ways. There are more efficient ways to raise money. But it is hard to find new donors, and this is oftentimes one of our most public, exciting things, if we structure our event in a way that it's actually exciting, and not just another breakfast, another awards dinner, or another gala in the hotel ballroom.

I want to look at a couple of characteristics of unique events that donors actually want to attend. I have a couple of examples. Yesterday we all spent a good bit of time on event design, and I'm going to walk you through my step-by-step road map of how we get these new-to-us people who attend this event to become good lifelong friends of the organization by responding to mail appeals and other fundraising forms. So, not the goal. What do we want?

This event I talked about in the beginning was structured like this. It was called the Red Carpet Soiree. I put it on with an organization I was the executive director of for ten years, in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, called the Cultural Trust in Richmond Fund. It was a United Arts Fund, so it raised money on behalf of thirty different arts and cultural organizations in the region. It's a crowded event scene. We knew we couldn't use the hotel ballroom and compete with some of those groups. So we did a nontraditional gala, where we took over a new venue every year that was never used for events. We transformed spaces. We took the money we would have spent at the ballroom and used it to transform the space.

We did things like this. We took a building about to be imploded, and we held the gala in it. We took down walls. We used lighting. It looked magnificent. In the daytime, it's the ugliest space ever, and then they got to see it. We could paint on the walls and do amazing stuff, and it blew up, like, the next week. We put up a clear-top tent in the middle of February in Pennsylvania, underneath the capitol dome.

So there are things you can do. And my favorite was the first year, where we took over the local airport. Two hours prior, there were lines of people in ticketing, right here, and it was transport. This one was a little over the top, but it cost the same amount as the hotel ballroom would have. It just took some creativity and having those conversations about what you actually want to attend. That's how we created that event. We put together a panel of people we saw at every event in town. Instead, if there was one more thing on your social calendar, what would it be? And we designed that event with them. A lot of fun.

Other examples: experiential events. Something different, and something where I can actually experience the mission. A lot of my friends in the vision services organizations will sometimes do a dinner in the dark, or here in this situation, blindfolded. So they're experiencing what it's like to try to eat a meal while you're visually impaired. They don't do this all night. Typically, after the fifth glass of wine is knocked over, then we take that off, but we're just going to have that conversation.

My public education foundation, Baccalaureate, had a chance for you to do something: 3D chalk art. Every single family is going to stop and take a photo at the spot where it tells you to stand, with the grad. It's a great way for you to have a conversation and say, thank you so much, parents, do you know what your education foundation does for you, and hand them some information. You know, experience.

This was an example my friend Lynn Wester shared, from Cornell veterinary medicine. It's a virtual event, but not a virtual fundraising event. Look what it is. You pick your flavor. You can tune in to see puppy cams or kittens playing at certain times. Great. A little bit of stress relief, a little bit of self-care.

Another event, in my own community, is a take on the traditional fashion show. How do we freshen that up? Make it something a little different? Nobody wants the stuffy fashion show. Why shouldn't I say nobody? But our new donors, especially our younger donors, don't want the traditional fashion show at the country club luncheon. So the Salvation Army in my market does a Shoe Strut. It is a Friday luncheon, primarily with businesswomen, and it is all about shoes. They get about six hundred women in attendance. They fill the ballroom. They have a fun little fashion show with shoes. They partner with DSW and some of the other discount shoe stores. They had tons of auction items and a lot of fun, a great text-to-give, and they use all of the digital marketing tools that folks like Bloomerang offer to us, and they really have a unique, different event that sells out every year.

So think outside the box and have conversations with your donors about what might happen if we were to do something. I highly encourage you to do that. Or how can we transform our current event to make it more marketable, or make it easier for our current donors to bring folks with them? That's the first step. If you're not doing that, the rest of the stuff I'm going to talk about isn't going to work, because you just don't have that many new people there. The same old crew comes year in, year out. So reinvent that event and make it something people want to come to.

How do you pick what to do? I'm going to share a great tool that my friends Alice Ferris and Jim Anderson with GoalBusters Consulting created. This is an evaluation sheet. It looks at five categories: potential revenue, effort, likely success, and the last two are perfect. Uniqueness: is it something different in our community? And mission match: does it make sense for us to do it, based on who we serve? Is there a way for them to experience the mission through this event? It looks something like this. You can figure it out. This also gives you data to take back to your event committee. We're developing community. You want to sell it on why we should make this move, not just because Fundraiser Chad said so. Have some data for them.

Alright. What you tuned in for today: converting event attendees to donors. Once we have our event optimized and set up to attract new folks, what is the process we walk them through, before, during, and after the event? Well, here it is. This is my favorite slide of all time. Look at it. It's all fancy. Yes. Everything's moving.

I'm going to walk you through each of these steps with some concrete examples. At the end, I'll talk about some resources, and in our follow-up email I have examples and resources and where to go for some of these pieces, which you'll be getting along with my slides and the recording.

First off, before the event, I want to transform that event communication. Often I purchase tickets and I get the generic email from our portal, whether it be Bloomerang or Eventbrite, whatever we're using. It's transactional. I bought something. I bought a ticket. That still goes, but I want to use that opportunity to build excitement ahead of the event.

Mystery. That event I talked about ahead of time worked really well, because they didn't know where they were going. Each year, it was kind of like, oh, what are they going to do this year? And it would sell out super early because of that, a week or two before the event. We still didn't have the names, because it's impossible to get those names ahead of time. But pre-event excitement is a mystery.

One of my favorite things to do is, if we have some kind of auction, especially a silent auction, take a picture of a portion of the item and play a guess-what-it-is game. We can build some excitement on social media that way. Talking about the event, people are guessing. There's engagement that boosts our organic reach. These events need to be exciting. Maybe something like, do you know why you're coming? We have a little mission ahead of time, so they're not just finding out about the cause and what you do at the event. They've learned ahead of time.

Set up a live stream. People love to see things transformed. Here we are in the morning, with a time-lapse of the room being set up. It's pretty simple to do these days. Just set up a camera, check it later, and post it a couple of hours before the event. There are lots of things we can do to build excitement, and not just the stuffy "here's your ticket, park here, here's what to wear." We can have some fun. Sometimes we're too formal, and we need to just be engaging and let people in a little behind the scenes. So: exciting pre-event communication.

Number two: a positive and unique story-based event experience. At the event, I need them to learn what they're supporting. Not just thank you for attending, but multiple times. There is a station where they can do an activity that the kids do in our programming. There is a video, or better yet, a beneficiary speaking about the difference our mission has made in their life. We have a video of that which they receive after the event. I'm skipping ahead, but let's have that person do it both ways: deliver it live and also have some video.

There are stations where they can touch things. My museum friends, I love it. If you have a white-glove station, bring out some non-precious artifacts, things you have thirty of, and let them have the experience of putting on white gloves, picking it up, and touching it. Nothing precious, nothing one-offs, things they could probably touch without the gloves, but the gloves are an incredible experience. My library friends have a book unboxing and labeling table. Save the deliveries from, like, two months. Let them do it at the event. I love the unboxing. It's what the kids like to do these days. But some kind of at-event experience where they actually see the mission.

At that event, I want them to take a first step. It's not going to be a donation. Maybe it will be, but a lot of folks won't do that. It's some kind of transaction where they get used to doing something for our organization. Let's look at some examples. You could do a fund-a-need. At the end of the auction, ladies and gentlemen, I know not everybody was able to purchase something tonight, so we're going to give you the opportunity to make a direct donation to the organization by raising your paddle. Who will give me a five-thousand-dollar donation? We come the whole way down to a hundred. Pure pressure can kick in there a little bit.

We could do a raffle. We have a couple of baskets, and maybe there's a table captain. Somebody at each table says, how many of who would like to buy? How many tickets? We fill a spot on a wish board. A wish board is a board like this, where we have spots, and they're making this commitment. When we fill the board, it raises five thousand and fifty dollars to fund something very specific, like scholarships for fifty children to attend a week of summer arts camp.

Pledge cards. This is kind of the traditional breakfast model. If you're going to do pledge cards, encourage monthly giving first. In all of these, you ask, and money is being raised, but it's not really about the money. It gives me their contact information. A lot of times we don't know. We just have a name, especially at a corporate table. We might have an email address, but probably not. This lets us collect full contact information, mailing address and email, so we can be in touch with them after the fact.

Next, make them feel appreciated at the event. There are multiple thank-yous. Engage your board. Send your board members to various tables to say thank you to everybody, making them know how special it is. Have them be greeters. Thank them from the stage. Maybe there's a little thank-you gift, nominal, as they leave, but they don't feel like it was just about money, and they are a key part of it.

The one you're going to cringe about is the day-after impact email. Yes. They often go out on Sundays. It's going to a lot of times the personal email addresses, when they read it. You can have this pre-written before the event. All you have to do is, maybe when you wake up on Sunday at one p.m., go in, insert a number or two, do a final proof, and hit send. We can do everything ahead of time, but that quick turnaround lets people know, oh, I'm appreciated. Wow. This organization has its act together.

Next, later that week, the final results email. We finished tallying things. Here's what we raised. These dollars are going to help with this. Here's a video of our program in action, an embedded YouTube video right there. Use our tools. That shows them the connection from the event to what the dollars do, and we're starting to build that support. It started that night. It actually started before the event, in our pre-event communication. And now we're showing them: oh, wow, now I'm a part of this. Because I bought that trip, or that auction item, or that raffle ticket, I'm helping to make this change in my community. I'm a part of it. Bring it to life for them.

Seven: handwritten thank-you note. Never doubt the value of a handwritten thank-you note. Within the first couple of weeks. I actually like to wait a little bit here. From number six to number seven, eight, nine, and ten, I like to space them about six weeks, because six weeks is the point where folks are about to forget about the event and organization, and then we keep reminding them. So this handwritten thank-you note comes. Use your events committee. Use your board. Spread it out. Get these little notes. They can be short. Three sentences doesn't need to be a lot.

Six weeks later, we invite them to some kind of engagement activity, something where they come and see our mission in action. My favorite is an immersive experience, where we actually bring them in and show them what we do. My favorite story of an immersive experience happened with my friend Rod from college. Rod is not really charitable, but somehow one of his friends convinced him to give fifty dollars to a Save the Pelicans type organization. He lives on the West Coast. He does so, and he forgets about it. He was just trying to shut up his friend, basically.

Then he gets an invitation to a donor reception on the beach. This isn't it, but this is what I picture it looking like. I don't do donor receptions on the beach in central Pennsylvania, where I'm from. He goes, and he said, "You know, I was just really there for the free drink." But on the way out, a truck pulls onto the beach. They gather everybody around, say a word or two, and they open the doors. These pelicans stepped out and flew off over the ocean in unison. He said he looked around, and people were choked up and crying. Then he realized he was shedding a tear. He had been moved. He did not care about this cause. He was going for the free drink. But at that event, they moved him, and he went home and became a fifty-dollar-a-month donor to that organization. So immersive experiences are incredibly powerful.

After hearing this story, one of my coaching clients did something similar. This was Heather Brown at the High Raptor Center in Ohio. Here's a video of what they did with their birds. It works. Incredible stories from it. So what does an immersive experience look like at your organization? An orchestra seats people on stage during dress rehearsal, beside their favorite instrument. That's a lot of fun. But think about what that could look like for your organization. We're almost through our process. We get some kind of engagement. Get them there: a behind-the-scenes tour, something where they come and interact.

Number nine is our impact letter. "It's been four months since you so generously supported our organization at so-and-so event. In that time, we've used the dollars raised to one, two, three, four, five examples of impact. We couldn't have done it without you. Thank you so much for your ongoing support." All right. We closed the loop. We told them what we did with their money. A lot of us miss that step. We miss it with our regular donors, and we definitely miss it with event donors. Our gift acknowledgement letter does not do that. It says what we're going to do with the money, not what we did with the money. There's a big difference in donors' minds, and this sets our organization apart. They say, oh, wow, they actually told me what they did with my money. That never happens. I like this organization. I can trust this organization.

And then finally, we do our ask. I like to do it by mail, with an email follow-up sequence. It looks something like this. Here are some key components. We can use our end-of-calendar-year appeal, or whatever our favorite appeal is from the year. We have to adjust the language. They are a separate segment, and we mention that they first supported us during the event. We repeat the impact that has happened since the event. Then we ask them to consider joining us in supporting this cause with an unrestricted donation. I love to get them in as monthly donors. Would you consider supporting our organization with a twenty-dollar monthly gift? That helps with retention from the start.

People always ask me how much to ask for. I like to start with the price of the ticket. If I can get them to give an unrestricted donation in that ticket-cost amount, that's pretty powerful, and we can grow from there.

So that's the process. It's ten steps. It starts before the event. But very few attendees will convert to annual donors on their own. They have to first be stewarded, engaged, and cultivated, and then finally asked. Sometimes we just throw them into our newsletter and solicitation loop, and we think they'll convert on their own. Very few will. We have to walk them step by step through this curated path, one that educates, informs, and leads to a personal solicitation they will be ready to respond to, because we have done all of the previous steps.

I want to close with a few additional fundraising event resources. You'll get the links to all of this in the email. I always love to recommend a book anytime I do a webinar. Sarah, I know we have a poll. If you want to pop that up, people can indicate whether they'd like the recording, links, and more information, and all of that, so we can do that while I roll through here. The book was by the late, great Kathy Kingston. She's certainly missed, but this is my favorite one on how to maximize an auction.

This component is actually part of a full hour-long webinar I do on events. That's my free gift to you today. It's usually only available for my clients and all-access pass holders, but I love my folks at Bloomerang, so we'll help out today. I have the full recording available, which is coming to you on the resources page as well.

If you'd like to connect with me, or you have a specific question, I'm happy to do that. I go by Fundraiser Chad on all of the social media channels, with the exception of TikTok. I don't dance. I don't know what to do there, but everywhere else, connect on your platform of choice. And with that, I'm going to say thank you. I'm looking forward to tomorrow, to hearing your questions, if you have specific questions about a step in the process or event design. I can't wait to do that with my fellow presenters and the great Rachel Muir. And with that, I'm going to toss it back over to Kate to wrap us up today.

Kate Kramer: Thank you so much, Chad. This was fantastic. As promised, I do want to draw a winner for the Uber Eats gift card. Today, the winner is Susan King-Cope. Susan, I'm going to email you here in a little bit, so be on the lookout for that.

We hope to see everybody back here tomorrow. If you haven't signed up, you still can, and we'll send you that link as well. We will be giving out a gift card tomorrow to any attendee, and then we're going to draw a second one for somebody who's attended all four sessions, so a little double incentive there. Thank you all. Thank you, Chad. I'll see you tomorrow. Take care, everyone.

Key takeaways:

  • Event attendee to donor conversion takes a step-by-step path, not one ask. Chad says very few attendees become annual donors on their own, so they need to be stewarded and engaged before they are asked.
  • Design events to bring in new people. Chad's goal is for 30 to 40 percent of attendees to be new to the organization, and he suggests asking board members to bring new guests.
  • Build excitement before the event. A mystery theme, a silent auction teaser and a behind-the-scenes setup video give guests a reason to care before they arrive.
  • Give attendees a small first transaction and an immersive experience. Paddle raises, wish boards and pledge cards collect contact details, and an immersive visit six weeks later can move people toward monthly giving.
  • Report back on what the money did. Chad says most organizations send a gift acknowledgement that describes what they will do with the money, but few send an impact letter about what they did.
Helping you help others

Every act of generosity starts here.

Empower your team to connect deeply and fundraise confidently.