Webinar

A super simple Year-End Campaign for small shops

Join fundraising master trainer, Chad Barger, ACFRE, ACNP, to discover a simple year-end campaign model that produces results for small nonprofits. This multichannel campaign repurposes content to tell a cohesive story throughout Q4 that motivates donors to give. It is both economical and time-saving for that busy season when time is short and budgets are spent.

Learning Objectives:

• Understand a Multichannel Fundraising Approach: Learn how to implement a simple effective, multichannel end-of-year fundraising campaign that leverages repurposed content, creating a cohesive and compelling narrative to ensure maximum donor engagement.

• Maximize Efficiency and Cost-Effectiveness: Discover strategies for conducting a fundraising campaign that saves time and resources, making it ideal for the busy year-end season.

• Create Impactful Donor Communications: Gain insights into crafting donor communications that resonate and inspire action, utilizing storytelling techniques and repurposing content to maintain a consistent, persuasive message throughout the quarter.

Check out the slides from this webinar here.

Transcript:

Kate Kramer: Hey, everybody. Welcome. We're gonna give it a few minutes and let everybody get into the room before we get started. But while we're waiting, please drop in the chat where you're joining us from. And if you're joining from the East Coast like I am, in chat, maybe what you're doing to try to survive this heat wave we're having.

Chad Barger: Oh, thank goodness it's dropped to, like, at least five, ten degrees from what it was, but, yes, it's been horrible.

Kate Kramer: I, normally, basically, it's [inaudible]

Chad Barger: [inaudible] been a problem. There are West Coast people rubbing it in. So yep.

Kate Kramer: I'm actually in Philly right now, normally in Virginia, but it's been equally as hot in both places.

Chad Barger: Oh, Kelly. Sorry to hear about the tornado's bad weather, but, yeah, it's been a little crazy lately.

Kate Kramer: Well, a few housekeeping items before we get started. We are recording this webinar. We'll get this sent out by the end of the week along with Chad's slides. If you have any questions for us during the webinar, please put them in the QA box. We're gonna make sure that we save a little bit of time at the end and get those answered.

Hopefully, you guys are all familiar with Bloomerang, but if you are not, we are your organization's solution for donor management, volunteer management, online fundraising, payments, all of the things. There will be a chance at the end that you can let us know if you'd like to hear more about any of the products that we offer, as well as if you wanna hear more from Chad, who I'm now gonna turn that right over to. Welcome, Chad. We're so excited to have you back with us.

Chad Barger: Great. Well, thank you, Kate. Pleasure. Always love being with my Bloomerang friends. You are my favorite CRM for my midsize groups and a great tool. So, pleased to be here. And I am gonna go ahead and share my screen and make that happen, and then I'm just gonna pop into here. So, folks, this is a little bit of a tweak on a normal presentation for me. I typically do, like, twelve quick tips to maximize your, year end fundraising appeal. But I was thinking, like, you know, I give you all the tips and then you're still stuck. And you're like, alright. I know I need to change all of this and what I did last year, but I still don't really have the plan. Like, just how do I make this happen?

So that's the game plan here for today. We're gonna take it from twelve to maybe, like, five tips. Alright? Because I gotta give you some theory. I gotta give you fundraising best practices. Even if you don't do this simplified end of calendar year small shop campaign, at least take these best practices and do take what you did last year and maximize it. So we're gonna look at what works for the first half of our time here today, then we're gonna go into this simplified campaign.

So I'm putting this out for small shops. I'm guessing most of you, you know, we do our letter. Right? We gotta do that letter. Thirty percent of all giving happens in the last six weeks of the year. So we need something in physical mailboxes during those last six weeks. Hopefully, you're already doing that. And then I'm guessing you get the appeal out and maybe have a follow-up email. You know, maybe towards late December, we kinda say, hey. You know, we're still here. We'd love to hear from you. That's what I find most small shops do. They get the letter out. It usually runs later than they want because they got too many things to do. You probably have more than just fundraising on your job description. And then we shove that email out and that's kinda it. And it works. It raises money, but with a couple simple tweaks. So if we're gonna optimize that letter and optimize that email, we can make them perform better. And then a couple extra things we can do to really get that year end campaign fully optimized. So that's the game plan. We're gonna look at best practices, then we're gonna look at that campaign. Then we'll take your questions and comments. I'm sure there's gonna be plenty of them today because, in forty five, fifty minutes, I don't have the time to get into everything, but we'll stick around and answer those questions. I say use the chat feature. Kate says use the Q and A feature. You listen to Kate, not me. So, Q and A, put your questions in there, and we'll get to those at the end. As I'm going through, if you have any comments, questions, applause, outrage, put that in the chat. I keep the chat monitored as I go along. But folks, let's hop right into this.

Two disclaimers. You're gonna see live examples today, from probably over the last five years. These all came in my mailbox. So if you send me mail, it might show up in a future webinar. So I love to feature good stuff. If it's not so good, I try to black out the organization, but it's a challenge, you know. So that's your disclaimer number one. Number two is the more important one. Personal preference does not equal fundraising best practice.

I gotta go big screen and say it again. Personal preference does not equal fundraising best practice. Right? What you like does not matter. What matters is what works, what is tested, what is proven. Now we're not gonna do anything unethical, any other things that way, but, you know, it's usually not us. It's our boss, our board, our development committee. It doesn't matter. Right? So the biggest roadblock usually to an effective end of year campaign is having to get it approved by, really, anyone other than you, but anybody more than just a boss or one person. If it has to go to a committee, death by committee is a real thing. They will take this and strip out all of my recommendations to you and make it this boring thing or this super glitzy thing. Glitz, super glitzy, doesn't work great either. So try this, because this might be the biggest win from this whole webinar. Talk to your boss now and say, hey. I'm gonna do something different with our end of calendar year campaign. Can you give me a little bit of leeway? Can you just let me try this and see what happens? And if they say no, then you say, can you let me take a twenty percent random sample of our audience and try this new way with them and see how that performs. So testing.

You know, because I'm giving you fundraising best practice. But, you know, maybe if you haven't been doing fundraising best practice, you would have trained your donor base to respond to something completely different. So you have to put this in place and test it and see what really works for your organization. So alright. Let's dig in.

Let's look at two appeals here to begin with and see what we like. Here's appeal number one. What a year. Twenty sixteen. I got some great photos. This year will be one for the record books. So far in the twenty sixteen fiscal year, we provided food and grocery products. We distributed nearly fifty million pounds of food. The number of meals and snacks we provided to children, the number of seniors we served. Yeah. It's a lot of "we." Right? A lot about the organization. I don't know how I'm playing a role here. Right? Blacking things out, trying to protect the organization. Alright? And then, here's the bottom of the letter. Yeah. Yeah. It's very small. Right? Got a reply card. I love those checkboxes with very specific calls to action. Let's look at the second one.

Cohen was only eight, but he was already at a crossroads. He had lost his father at age two. With no father figure in his life, he could have looked for guidance in all the wrong places, latched on to bad people, and walked the path no one should go down. But because of you, his life is different. Without your support, Cohen's mother may have never called Big Brothers Big Sisters, and it goes on. Right? We got a great photo. There's Cohen with his big. Page two, another one. We have bolded statements. We have a great P.S. statement there. There are over a hundred kids like Julian on our waiting list. We need big brothers, big sisters. Be their champion. Please donate today.

So my question is, which one of these appeals would you be more likely to give to? Put it in the chat, number one or number two. Which one are you going for? Number one or number two? I'm seeing lots of twos. My contrarian will throw a one in here. I know it's gonna happen. It's never straight twos, because, you know, we can train people to respond to other things, as I said. Alright. So number two. That is what we're aiming for. We're going more towards number two. Number two letter here has taken the bulk of my recommendations and put them into place. I can say this letter was a drastic change from the year before, and I believe the writer of this letter is probably on this webinar, and he'll call me on it. But I think it was a twenty two percent increase year over year, just by making some small changes. So alright. So let's look at these best practices.

What do I want you to do? I can't do everything today. I'll give you some book recommendations at the end that will teach you everything. You can go deeper into this. But let's look at maybe just five things that we wanna make sure are key in our appeal letters.

Alright. First off, begin with a story. A story that starts with an attention getting opening line. I'm gonna back up to our example again. Cohen was only eight, but he was already at a crossroads. Right? You're kinda drawn in. Right? Like, what's going on with Cohen? He's only eight. I wanna make sure he's okay. Right? It's kinda what we're thinking there. So attention getting opening line is really our key. And begin with the story, and we're going right into the story. Not "let me tell you a story about Cohen who was eight years old when he came to our organization." You've already bored me. No? Get right into the story. Start with the story.

Most appeal letters start with something like this. Right? "ABC nonprofit finish the year strong by meeting its fundraising goal and serving three hundred additional children this year." That's great. I'm thrilled you met your goal. I don't really care about your goal. I care about the kids. You served three hundred of them. Fabulous. Tell me about one of them. Right?

So often, our correspondence, our writing looks like this. Right? Shout out to my good friend, Tom O'Hearn. He put this up on a screen, like, ten years ago. I snapped it. Sorry for the old school cell phone, greenish image background there. But, yeah. It's so true. We just talk about ourselves. It's jargon. No. Not what we wanna do. That ends up in here. Right? That ends up in here. So we don't want all those facts and statistics. They serve a purpose. We need them for grants. They're great for annual reports. Even annual reports, I want them to be story focused. So facts and statistics tell, but stories sell. Right? It is those stories that work.

These first lines, these first sentences, some great examples. "Johnny didn't go to school last week because something was wrong." What's wrong with Johnny? I'm gonna keep reading. "Just the other day, Marcy walked into our facility with a big problem." What's Marcy's problem? I wanna know. This natural curiosity that we have, that's what the first sentence of any appeal, whether it be an email, whether it be a mail appeal, has to inspire, and that's what it has to bring out. Right? "Last week, I was walking down the hall and stumbled upon something magical." Magical. What was that? And you're seeing here, like, I'm using some first person. Like, this letter can be informal. It can be just me talking with you, having a conversation. Like, imagine you're sitting in a coffee shop, meeting with a donor, and telling them stories about the amazing work your organization has done in the last year. That's what our appeal letter should also be. But all of a sudden, we get into this formal situation, and we're like, oh, no. "On behalf of the board of directors of ABC." Or no. Informal, conversational is really, really our key here. So I'm saying stories. Let's talk a bit about these stories, what they should be, where they come from. So it's a compelling story. Compelling story about one. One person, place, or thing. I really wanted to be about a person. Because that person could be, you know, my kid, my parent, my neighbor, my boss, my coworker, whoever. Right? That's relatable.

Now if you don't serve people, like, my historic preservation people are always on my case here. They're like, we preserve buildings. But tell me about the people that use those buildings. Tell me about the kid that came in and saw something they've never seen before. Right? Almost everybody can do people. My animal rescue people, they're always saying, no. We talk about the animals. Well, talk about the life changing experience that a person had because of that animal. I still need you to include the cute photos of the animal because cute kids and animals, it just sells everything, wins every Giving Day contest ever. Right? We all know that. But, yeah, the person, the human touch. So compelling story about one person, place, or thing.

Rich detail. So I need you to give me enough details so that I'm imagining what's happening. So, like, I have a picture in my mind of what that looks like. Is it the right picture? No. Because I don't have the full context, but I can kinda create that. You're taking me deep into the story. If I have any true crime podcast people on here, it's exactly what they do. Right? They recreate the situation. Like, they're just telling you the story and you're sitting in your car driving and you're, like, scared crazy of what's gonna happen next. Right? That's kinda what we're doing here. Rich detail.

And it's a solvable problem. So we take care of this when we talk about one. When we talk about one person instead of the three thousand two hundred and twenty nine people our organization served last year. That's huge. Like, what does my hundred dollars do for three thousand two hundred twenty nine people? Not much. What does my hundred dollars do for one person, for one family? Right? That can probably put food on the table for a whole month, through one of our great food and security organizations. Right? They do amazing things. Right? A hundred dollars goes a long way when we're talking about one family. Not when we're talking about three thousand two hundred and twenty nine. So solvable problem. That's our formula. Compelling story, rich detail, solvable problem.

Now where do I find this thing? Right? Oh, you want a story example. Let me get you a story example. Apologies. Fundraiser chat did not pull the story example in advance. Well, I don't have it, so I'm gonna tell you the story off the cuff. Here we go. Good test.

Alright. So the story comes from the Spring Valley Library in Wyomissing Township, Pennsylvania. The story is about a guy named, I believe, Ron. Right? So Ron was coming into the library all the time. He was a fixture. He'd show up. He came in. He watched job training skills videos. You know, he'd show up every day. Staff got to know him. And then all of a sudden, he came up to the circulation desk one day and he asked if they knew anybody that might have some job clothes. And they connected him with a local church that had a clothing pantry, and he got everything he needed. And they saw him for a while. He was wearing his nice clothes, and then he just disappeared. Just disappeared. They didn't see Ron for, like, two months. One day, Ron randomly shows back up, and he comes in and says thank you. And he hands the circulation desk volunteer fifty dollars. And he says, thank you. I wanna give this back to the library. You all helped me. I was at the bottom of the road. I was at wit's end. But every day, you were supportive. You saw what I was doing. I was trying to improve myself, trying to get the job, trying to do what I needed to do, and I got that job. And I would never have gotten that job if you hadn't sent me to the church to actually get something respectable to wear, and I'm just incredibly grateful. And I wanna make sure you guys are always able to help people like me moving forward and be that resource for the community. There's our story.

Now we take that and we say, you know, there are a hundred and fifty Rons that walk through our doors every single year. Your support ensures that we are always here to make sure people like Ron get the assistance that they need. Mhmm. Alright. That was a decent off the cuff story. I didn't get every element there. You don't need to see two of me. Here we go.

Yeah. But that's a great story. So where do we find it? Right? We also can flip the script a little bit. So we don't have to tell the story. We can have our organization, our building, our mascot, somebody else tell the story. This is one of my favorite appeals of all time. "Dear Chad, I thought my life was over. My family put me out in the trash, and I was sad. I was sad because I knew that there was so much more life left in me. I kept looking out for someone to save me, and person after person passed me by like I was invisible, like I was trash. And then you passed me. You hit the brakes and turned your car around. Before I knew it, you scooped me up because you wanted to make a difference. You heard that the common wheel could use donated bikes for their programming. And when you saw me sitting sadly on the curb, you knew you could find someone who would love me once again." So this letter is from a bike. This letter is from Becky the bike. We've given her a name. Right? Down here, you can see the ask happens. I don't have the scan in here, but Becky actually signed the letter by running a tread across the signature block. Right? So we can get creative. We can have a little bit of fun. One of my book recommendations for you today is gonna be, where is it at? Should be somewhere on here. Creative Deviations, by John Lepp. John tells you how to get really creative. John's with Agents of Good out of Toronto, Canada and, lift notes, all kinds of things. Like, we don't have to be stuffy, but we have to make sure it is tested in something that works so we can have a lot of fun. Sally Anne, I see your question in the chat. That is Creative Deviations, and I'll share a screenshot of the book when we get to the end here today. So, alright.

So next step was story. When? This is the problem. We have the stories. They're around, but we wait until, like, late October, early November, the week before US Thanksgiving, and that's when we try to write our appeal letter. And we're like, oh, I don't have a story. No. Work on the story in September. September is for story finding. Right? So find that story then. Also, my recommendation, I think I have a slide saying this coming up, but use a story you've shared in the past. Right? Use a story. We can reuse things. A story that worked great three years ago, let's use it again. Donors aren't gonna remember that we already shared that, and we can give an update. Like, share the story and at the end say, some of you may remember that we shared this story back in twenty twenty one. We're pleased to report that Alice is doing amazing. Because of your support, she still continues to. Right? But September, that's your focus. Find that story.

People struggle with getting stories. Like, where do I find these stories? So, for many years, I was a development director for a museum, and this was my trick. So if you're in any kind of arts organization, public serving organization, anything like that, this worked really well. Every other month on my way into work, I'd pick up a box of donuts. I'd put them in the volunteer break room. So we had docents, a bunch of volunteers doing different roles. They all had radios. I'd pop on the radio and say, hey. It's Chad, everybody. Hope you're doing well. There are free donuts in the volunteer break room. And then I would quickly go sit beside my box of donuts. And every time somebody reached into my box, I'd say, John, great to see you. Thank you for being such a loyal volunteer. You know, what have you seen around here in the last month that was just really incredible? You know? I know that school group came in last week. Was there anything, like, different or fun or exciting you saw? Anything neat the kids said. Right? So I just had little prompts I'd ask them, and I would get the most amazing stories. I'd be like, well, yeah, this kid, you know, he came in. This was an antique auto museum. It's like, he'd never seen a car older than, like, something built in the mid nineties. And we showed him. I let him sit in it. And then he started talking about this grandpa and, you know, we just get these great little stories. So find a way, you know, because my problem then was my office was upstairs in a cubicle away from everything. Like, I saw none of that. It was all happening around me, but I didn't get to witness it. So find a way to connect with that program team, whether it be staff or volunteers. What does that look like? Some of you have amazing, just, experiences. Right? Some of you have great campuses. Just get out. A story walk. Right? Just walk through your facility. I wonder what that piece of equipment is used for. I should ask someone. Oh, that thing, that room, what are we doing there? I've never talked about that in the field. So just get that inspiration. Right? Get out of your desk. If you're fully remote, get to the facility. Get to the program. Witness something. That's where stories come from. You gotta find a way to connect with the program. Connect with that program. As I already said, if you had a great one a couple years ago, use it again with that quick update. Right? Or not. Like, your donors are not gonna remember that you already shared the story. Even if they do, they're gonna say, oh, it sounds familiar. I'm glad we're still doing that. We put too much pressure on ourselves to always come up with amazing, fresh, new content. You know, we get tired of our content, but our donors do not. Right? They are not our number one priority.

Alright. That was number one. We're going through five. We'll get to the campaign.

Number two, assure that your call to action is clear and specific. I see so many appeals. Last end of calendar year, I think I reviewed forty three appeals for nonprofits. When they first came to me, like, a third of them didn't really have a call to action. They told a story. They talked about their organization, but they didn't tell them what to do. So that clear call to action that's very specific. We ask the reader to do one thing and one thing only, donate. Right. Donate. Don't talk about your event. Don't talk about volunteering. One thing. Donate. We ask for a specific amount for a specific purpose. Right? "Would you consider making a gift" is, like, the least strong. People ask me how do I do this. If you can take an export from your database, perhaps Bloomerang, and one of the fields there is last gift amount. Take that, go to Excel, calculate one and a half times that last amount, that's a great ask amount. Great ask amount. You can put in a custom ask string. You can ask for something very specific. But the more specific we are with that call to action, the better it is. And it should be used multiple times throughout the appeal. Multiple times.

Number three. It's not just a call to action. It's an urgent call to action. Urgent call to action. Right? Why should I give now rather than waiting three months? Why now? What's that look like? So here are the ways to show urgency. I already mentioned the animals. You know, if somebody, people, animals, something won't survive, you know, we've all seen the commercials. Right? It's just super urgency. Right? We have the three C's of urgency. Cancer, children, cute animals. That's what tends to get all the attention, you know, every single giving day, community giving day. That's what wins the prize pots. Right? So if you can play that card, go for it. Do not try to play that card if you are not in that realm. Right? We're not pulling the wool over anybody's eyes here. Right? So most of us are gonna do the second two. A window of opportunity is closing. Right? So any donations received by December fifteenth will be matched dollar for dollar, will be matched twenty percent. Any new or increased donations will be matched by a generous supporter, will be matched by our board. Right? Matching funds work really well to create urgency. Gives that deadline. We want that extra leverage from our gift. Number two and number three here, conditions are going to change or get worse. Right? So if we don't reach our goal, if we don't do this, then it's gonna be more expensive. You know, we have an exclusive opportunity. You know, costs are going to increase. The waiting list is going to grow, but something to create this urgency. Why do I need to give now is a key part of any appeal.

Another key part, the P.S., especially with our mailed appeals. Right? Especially with the mailed appeals. P.S. statement. We're gonna go to a little, fundraising research in psychology here. So this is the great professor Siegfried Vogel, out of print book. It would be on my book stack if I could get a copy of it, but it's, like, a hundred and fifty dollars on eBay for this thing. It's super old, but great research, Handbook of Direct Mail, most exciting title ever. But what did they do? They looked at where your eyes go when you're reading mail. Right? And here's the infographic on the side. What do you do? You start with the logo at the top. Right? Who is this from? What is this? Then I go to the address block. You know, is this actually for me? Then the salutation, and I'll read that first sentence. See those three dots? They're reading the first sentence. That's why that first sentence is so key, and that's why we go right into the story. Then they're skipping. Right? They start skimming. Very few people read our full appeal letter word for word. They start skimming. What are they stopping on? Anything that we have bolded or underlined. Right? So those bold and underlines kinda need to tell the full story, and especially that call to action needs to be bolded or underlined. We stop on who it's from. Do I know them? And then, look, the only other spot with three dots other than the first line is the P.S. It's the last thing on the page. People will read it. Right? Where's my statistic? Ninety percent of all readers will read a P.S. word for word. So what goes in there? The call to action gets repeated. I know you don't like it. I know it feels like, you know, elementary school pen pal writing or putting a P.S., but people read it. Let's use it. Remember, personal preference does not equal fundraising best practice. So what are you gonna do here? We're gonna repeat that call to action. Some great examples. "Won't you join me and help the kids today with a hundred dollar donation?" "Your vital donation of a thousand dollars will be put to work immediately and will have a huge impact on our local community." That's what goes in the P.S. So alright. Number four.

This might be a second number four, but we'll see. We'll get through it. Implement a QR code. This is a new one for me. I've been doing this the last, no, three years now, where we're trying to get people from our printed and mailed appeal to our website. Right? And if we just put in a QR code and say scan here to donate now, like, you'll get a couple, but that doesn't really work. So, QR codes work now. We have our friends in the restaurant industry to thank during COVID and the pandemic. What did they do? Well, we didn't really know, you know, what people touching things, all of that, so they did the QR code menus. Right? So they taught everybody how to use QR codes. They work now. So let's use them. Places. Here you see on the right, we have a donation reply envelope. There's a QR code. Scan here to make a donation now. So that should be standard practice. But I wanna take this up another step here. Right? I wanna put a QR code right in my letter like this. Just wrap the text around it. So I'm gonna add one element that is not in this letter. They needed to caption that QR code to tell people what happens when you scan it. Alright? And they're telling the story of Janiyah here. Right? So that caption should say, scan here to watch a special message from Janiyah. What happens when I scan it? I scan it. I go to an unlisted page on their website. Just we buried it somewhere. It's not linked, but we're on it. All of a sudden, we're on your website. There is an embedded YouTube video. Right? None of this is complicated. If this sounds complicated to you, your office admin, your website person, this is super easy, they can do it in three minutes. Right? Embedded YouTube video. They watch the video. There's Janiyah saying, thank you so much for everything you've done for me and my family. Because of your generous support, we're able to. It's like thirty seconds. What is immediately below Janiyah's message, our giving form is right there. So this is a custom page. We're not just scanning, scan here to donate now. No. Scan here and you're gonna get this special message from Janiyah and hear how your dollars will be used. It's not super complicated. I've been testing this. I'm seeing anywhere between an eight and twenty seven percent increase in giving just by doing this, just by having someone scan that link and have that message. And right there is the immediate call to action. So it's not hard. And all of a sudden, they're on our website.

So alright. Final tip before we get to this simplified campaign that uses all of these tools, the package. So we're talking about the mailed piece. Yes. You have to mail something. This is not just an email campaign. So we have to mail something, but I need them to open the thing. Right? And I need it to work. We've talked mostly about the letter and what goes in it. Right? So what goes in it? Right? Well, you need a reply card. You need something that they see. So, after I read your letter, the next thing behind it should be a reply card. It seems antiquated. Right? Especially if there's already an envelope. Right? But the reply card just tells me it's another call to action. Right? And what do a lot of people do? They take your reply card, they tuck it in your envelope, and where does that go? That goes in my bill pile. So all of a sudden, that's my reminder. It's my call to action. So a reply card is a fabulous tool, but not a complicated reply card like this. Like, this has way too many things on here. We're trying to raise money for our operating fund and our capital campaign at the same time, and no. No. Super simple. This is a favorite template of mine that I've used with clients. Super simple. Just fill in a couple things, front and back. Yes. We still put payment information on there because I don't know why, but there are still donors that think it's more secure to write your credit card number on a piece of paper than it is to enter it on a website, but people will do it. Make sure you have policies and procedures in place there, to make sure if somebody does this, that it immediately gets entered and shredded, destroyed, blacked out, whatever it is, but it still happens. I still see it everywhere. So you need a reply card. Yes. You would need a return envelope. It can be very, very simple. Here's the super simple one. Right? No. You don't need a stamp on it. Just something to make it easier for them. Something again, it serves as a reminder to do it. They're gonna save that somewhere. The max I ever saw was somebody saved an appeal envelope from seven years prior, like it was sitting in the desk drawer, and then sent it in. But I've heard of people getting, like, donation cards from, like, twenty plus years ago. It had a former address for the organization and somehow magically got forwarded at that time. And so people hold on to this stuff. So give them these tools. Yeah. Tina says you see them many months later. Many years is not uncommon as well. But we can optimize it a little bit here.

I love this one. So this is a buck tail, hang tail, whatever envelope. So we're printing on the extended flap. So we're kinda combining our reply card and our reply envelope in one. I love this one because of these little notes with arrows. Right? Many supporters give at this level. So tell them what you want them to do. And monthly gift option. Right? Please consider more than you would normally be by spreading your gift over twelve months. Alright? There we go. And none of that matters because that's all on the inside. I need them to actually open it. Right. I need them to open it. So the outer envelope. What are we gonna do there? Most effective outer envelope ever. What's it look like? Right? It looks like a letter from Aunt Edna. Right? It's personal correspondence. So can we do this for our two thousand piece appeal? No. Can you pull out the top one hundred, two hundred, most loyal, highest donors and do this, or have a volunteer do this? I had groups even during COVID that were doing this. They were dropping off envelopes and supplies at someone's house on their front porch. They'd address them and they'd pick them up, like, a week later. Like, this is great for that volunteer that wants to do administrative work that you don't trust touching your database. I don't hand address envelopes perfectly. This gets opened. Right? What else gets opened? Well, that plain white stamped handwritten, that gets opened. Also, we just need to stand out in the inbox. So brightly colored, you know, hot pink, green, something a little different that's gonna stand out. Oversized. So instead of the standard number ten envelope, can you go to a booklet envelope? Right? So more like this size. So it's a half fold. Basically the same size as a greeting card. That's gonna stand out in the mail stack and get opened. And then don't get super fancy. Just your standard number ten organization envelope with your logo that your billing department uses, and you have tons of, that's fine. People get fancy. They start printing, like, images on it and teasers. Worst teaser I ever saw. "Your twenty nineteen annual appeal is enclosed" printed across the bottom. Is that gonna get it opened? No. You're right. That's just an instant chance to throw it in the trash, other than, like, the twenty people that are truly waiting for that to come. Right? The other thing, window envelopes. No window envelopes. What comes in a window envelope? Throw it in the chat. I haven't had you comment in the chat a little bit. What shows up in your mailbox in a window envelope? You know, when the crinkly little clear thing, your address is showing through there. Right? Bills. Bills. Bad news. Bills. Yeah. Yeah. Right. So do we want our appeal to show up in a window envelope and look like a bill? No. Not what we want. Oh, jury summons. Even better. Right? Yeah. Not what we're looking for. So don't listen to your printer. Don't listen to your finance person that says, oh, here's window envelopes. It'll save money. It saves a tiny bit of money, but it's just not worth the decreased open rate. Because we can have the most amazing letter ever. And if they don't open it, nothing is gonna happen. Alright, folks. I've held you off long enough. Let's do our simplified campaign now that you have some best practices in mind.

Here we go. First off, we found our story in September. Now we're coming into October, and I wanna do a priming email series. Priming email series. So I'm gonna take that story, and I wanna break it into three or four parts, like three or four paragraphs. And over a series of maybe a week, maybe two weeks, I wanna just gradually leak, or the industry term is drip. Drip that out. Just a little bit at a time. Alright? Little bit at a time. Here we go. So I give you the first paragraph. Stay tuned. Next week, we'll tell you what happens next in our story. So we're just building some interest. There is no ask with this series. No ask. But over a series of a couple emails, I don't love four days in a row just because I think it's too much for most organizations. But every other day, you know, maybe over two weeks, like, Tuesday, Thursday, Tuesday, Thursday, we tell our donors a story. We tell them our best story of what has happened over the last year. Just make them feel really good. What is this doing? The term there is priming. So it's reminding them that we still exist. It's telling them that we're still doing good things. It's telling them what we did with their money. It's kinda warming them up. Right? It's reminding them. So they're feeling good about our organization coming into this end of calendar year appeal time, especially if we solicited them a couple weeks prior or there was a big event. Like, take them back to the mission. Remind them of why we do this important work. So that's step number one, priming email series. A series of emails. And you could just send one email. Like, if that's what you can do, that's great. But the more touches we have, like, we're spreading this out. We're building some anticipation. We're getting, like, kinda, oh, what's next? I can't wait to see the next one. That's that feeling I wanna create in them.

So, timing. That's gonna come up. Yeah. I already see it in here. When is this step? Timing. So, normally, I would say the priming email series would be late October, early November. You're gonna find that story in September. That's where we want it to go. For, I think most organizations here are US based, we have a little conundrum this year. We have an election. We have what will probably be a big money, contentious, nasty election. So anything we send is just gonna get buried and people are gonna be ignoring the media. So I'm really thinking this year, I would send this priming email series out the week after the election. So kind of that, you know, second, third week there in November is when we're targeting this. It's later than I normally do, but don't try to compete. Alright? You're just not gonna see it. So feel good news the week after the election, I think, will resonate really well. So next up is that mailed appeal letter. I gave you the best practices before. Right? We know what we're gonna send. When do you send it? I tend to always like to send appeal letters kind of the week after US Thanksgiving. Right? Week after US Thanksgiving. Cyber Monday, great time to drop that off. Call ahead, talk to your mail house, make sure they know your timing, all of that. Ideally, the top ten percent is hand addressed, has a first class stamp on it, and the rest is going that nonprofit standard bulk mail. So that gets our mail appeal out. So that's within our last six weeks of the year when thirty percent of all giving happens. So that's our goal there. Let's look at a fun example. This is the Edmond History Museum in Edmond, Oklahoma. Here's a nice hand addressed envelope. Got a horse on the front. That's interesting. I'm curious now. This letter is from the horse. The horse's name is Applesauce. Right? I bet you've never, like, gotten a letter from a horse before, so the horse is in there. They changed the hats on the horse for the season. So Applesauce tells us this great little story about the museum. Uh-huh. Fabulous. There we go. Applesauce signs it with her horseshoes, and she has a nice P.S. for the call to action. Alright. What else is in here? Here's our reply card with a QR code and a simple little reply envelope. That's what we're looking for. All the best practices we just talked about right there. I threw this in here. I wanted you to have one more example. I wanted you to have an example of a full package. That's what that looks like. Next up, email appeal.

So a follow-up. I like to send this ten days after the mail letter drops is received. Right? How do you know when it's received? You include yourself on the mailing list. So you know when your donors are getting it. Ten days later, the email appeal. What's the email appeal look like? It's almost the same as the mailed appeal. We repeat that story. It's probably not as long. We'll shorten it up, make it tighter, but it retells that story and has that donate button, that call to action right there. Here's a nice, simple, little email appeal example. If I can get to my scroll on the other computer. Right. So tells a little story. There we go. It's fighting me a little bit. So quick little story. So it's not as long as the appeal, kinda repeats some of the same information, has that donate now button, and a nice photo to go with it. Super simple, super short. So that's right there. That is our appeal follow-up. K. Get out of here. Here we go. Alright. Email appeal. Next up, LYBUNT calls.

So as the term in the industry, people yell about using the terms, but what does LYBUNT stand for? LYBUNT stands for "last year, but, unfortunately, not this." Right? So these are our kinda recently lapsed donors. So they give to us every year, but they're not in yet this year. So around, like, December fifteenth, twentieth, somewhere in there, that's when we make some live calls. Who typically gives to us every year but has not given yet? You're not gonna call the people that give on December thirty first every year. That'll hopefully just happen. But there's probably twenty, thirty, fifty, a hundred, whatever it is, people that, you know, they're just not in yet this year. So a simple little call. Hey. Thanks so much for your past support. We're just reaching out. We're trying to close out this year strong to help, whoever we help. We wanted to see if you'd be able to come on board and help us out again this year. Simple little live calls.

Number five. End of your emails. So I said thirty percent of all giving happens in the last six weeks of the year, twelve percent happens in the last three days of the year. So you need emails out there on the last three days of the year. Right? I tend to send on the twenty ninth and the thirty first. And what is it? It's really the same email I sent earlier in the month. Change the wording a little bit. Add in some urgency. Would love to hear from you before the end of the year. All of that. That's it. It's simple. It can be set up. It can be scheduled using a great tool like Bloomerang email, which we just announced. Like, great upgrade to Bloomerang email today. So check that out. Some fabulous new templates for those of you to use. That's what we do. So let's prime them. Let's get them interested. Let's send that mail appeal, the email follow-up, some call follow-up, and then those two, at least two emails in the last three days of the year. That is our formula. Here's one example of one of those end of calendar year emails. You know, this is great. They're showcasing their staff, remembering us in their year end giving. There's some bullets on what they've done. They're here. They're testing a split ask. So always testing something interesting is a great way to do it. I see a ton of questions, so I'm gonna just roll through the back here and get to those.

Key to success on all of this. Start now. Why am I doing a year end webinar in July? Because it's not too early. It's time to start. It's time to start thinking about this. Put this stuff in place. In September, you already have to be working on that story. So August is probably the time to plan this all out. Figure out who's gonna do what. What collateral do we need? What help do I need? Right? Start now. Just schedule it an hour a week between now and the middle of November. That's all you need to make this a reality, but you gotta start planning ahead now. As I mentioned, I always have additional fundraising resources for you. I mentioned books. This is my favorite fundraising writing book. This is The Fundraiser's Guide to Irresistible Communications by Jeff Brooks. Super short, super thin book. Right here. Right? See it? It's super tiny. Right? You can read it in an afternoon for sure. This will teach you what you need to know about fundraising writing. So that's my one zero one book. What's my two zero one book? That's the one I mentioned earlier. That is Creative Deviations by John Lepp. Fabulous book. Fabulous examples. It is right there. I actually got it out without knocking off the book stack. So much much thicker, much bigger. You can see tons of examples of what things actually look like. So another great book. Both fabulous gentlemen that contribute a lot to the sector. So if you wanna go a little deeper than what we did today, that's my recommendation. I go by fundraiser, Chad, on social media. Most active on Facebook and LinkedIn. Would love to connect. If you have follow-up questions that we don't have a chance to get to today, feel free to reach out over there. I also do a free monthly webinar. This month, I am doing sponsors.

In a minute or two here, Kate is gonna pop up a poll, which will let you request more information from me, add on to my email list, which gets you information on the webinars, other free tips. Also, it allows you to sign up for, request information from Bloomerang on their fabulous product and how it can help you implement a lot of what we talked about today. And with that, I think we are ready to go over and hit the Q and A and then go from there. So if you threw your question in the chat, if you don't mind copying that over into the Q and A, that'll make sure we have time to get there. But I see there's thirty one questions. So I don't know.

Kate Kramer: Yes. Okay. So first, let me throw up this poll. We are not gonna be able to get through all of the questions, so let Chad know if you wanna connect with him. If you wanna see how email works in Bloomerang, or if you're already a Bloomerang customer and just wanna connect on some additional services, let us know that as well. So, Chad, several of these I'm gonna combine. There's a lot of questions about how you can tell a story if your clients are a vulnerable population or you can't use their names or their pictures. Is it okay to change their names?

Chad Barger: Yeah. So it's very difficult. I see that. I get this question a lot. So, yes, you can change their names. You know, take a story. You can also create a fictional story as long as it is something that you've seen happen and is routine. What do you do? You put an asterisk on it and say, name changed to protect donor or beneficiary anonymity. You know, this is a hypothetical situation because, unfortunately, we can't share real world examples for you, but this is what we see and face every single day. So you can do it that way. And also I don't have the exact link for you, but I'm gonna tell you what to search. Nonprofit Nation podcast, that is Julia Campbell's podcast. She had an excellent episode on telling difficult stories. So I am quite confident that if you just Google that, it'll pop right up. And if somebody wants to help me out and actually do that Google and throw it in the chat, that would be fabulous. But Julia Campbell, Nonprofit Nation podcast, telling difficult stories. Excellent half hour conversation on exactly this.

Kate Kramer: Several questions on Giving Tuesday. How do you work that into the plan?

Chad Barger: So Giving Tuesday, I will say that I don't, but I understand that some organizations need to. So it's the same way with your giving day, if your giving day falls in there. You know, how has Giving Tuesday performed for your organization? If it works, great. I'm not gonna tell you not to do it. But if it's like you try every year and nothing really happens, then maybe Giving Tuesday becomes, like, thankful Tuesday. Like, we're just gonna reach out and say, we greatly appreciate you. You're amazing. We appreciate our donors. And there's still a donate link in the bottom, but it's not a call to action. There are people that will call me on this, and I'll get tons of hate mail. But I just don't love soliciting our donors the same day that everybody else solicits our donors. And, you know, I tend to get three hundred emails every Giving Tuesday, and I don't give a cent because I'm just overwhelmed. But some organizations really build themselves on it. So can you adapt this for Giving Tuesday? Yes. Could your priming emails lead into Giving Tuesday? And then could you start with the email first before the appeal? Yeah. You could do that. That could go on Giving Tuesday if that works for your organization. But I'm not gonna tell you to adapt this and make it go on Giving Tuesday. But clearly adaptable. The order can shift around, make it work for you.

Kate Kramer: Awesome. Do you think a brochure should be included with the direct mail letter?

Chad Barger: Yep. That's a best practice that we didn't get to today. No. No brochure. You don't wanna confuse them. Right? So you're ending with the call to action repeated in the P.S. Right. They know exactly what to do. They put your letter down. What are they holding? They're holding your reply card in their envelope. They're ready to give. If you give them something else to hold, you know, a brochure about your programs, a save the date card for your special event, now all of a sudden, they're thinking about your programs. They're going to their calendar to see if they're free. No. That has other times, other purposes. That can be an email, but no additional things. Extra stuff does not equal more money.

Kate Kramer: A couple of LYBUNT questions. What was the timing of those calls, and what is the percentage of renewal, and do you encourage folks to leave a message?

Chad Barger: Okay. So timing of that call, I wanna give them as much time as possible. So I tend to like to do it, like, the week before Christmas. So, like, the fifteenth to the twentieth, somewhere in there. Like, usually, when I was a frontline fundraiser, my last two or three days in the office, it was spent making live calls. Yes. And, yeah, it's reaching out to anybody that's normally in by that time, but is not in yet. Right? That's the key. What was the second part of that question, Kate?

Kate Kramer: Leaving messages.

Chad Barger: Leaving messages. Yes. Certainly. Yeah. Voice mail, go for it. Like, "Hi. This is Chad with ABC nonprofit. Thank you so much for your past support. We're trying to wrap up our year here strong so we can support individuals just like we have in the past. We haven't seen your gift in yet. If you're able to, we would love to see your support again this year. We just sent you a follow-up email. We'd really love to see that come through. Thank you so much." Yeah. Super simple.

Kate Kramer: We have several questions about reply cards, so I'm just gonna throw them out. What do you think about an eight and a half by eleven reply card? Do you think separate cards or tear-offs at the bottom are more effective? How important is including a place for the credit card number?

Chad Barger: Okay. Yeah. So we're gonna plug this again.

Kate Kramer: We're talking through—

Chad Barger: all of those. But reply card is essential. Do I care what it is? I really don't, because the vast majority of people aren't actually gonna send you that reply card. It's the reminder. Right? It shows that it's an ask. It's necessary, but you're gonna get back, like, ten percent of your gifts are gonna have the reply card. Even, like, a lot of people that send checks are not gonna send you the reply card. They're just gonna put the check in the reply envelope. So what's on it is not essential. I have seen full size ones. I have not seen data that shows that they are more effective. What is nice is that a full size one gives you room to do other things like include a quick survey or, sometimes, like, we'd love to know why you support our organization and give them, like, a free response section. Sometimes you'll get little gems that come back, and it's an opportunity for a deeper conversation. So no firm data, but I don't care what it is. Some kind of reply device.

Kate Kramer: Wonderful. I am so sorry for everyone whose questions we did not get to. Please reach out to Chad on LinkedIn or on Facebook. I'm certain that he will be happy to still chat with you about this. Chad, thank you so much. Obviously, it was a great topic. Tons of engagement. Thank you all for being such a great audience, and I hope to see everybody again soon.

Chad Barger: Thank you, everybody. Happy fundraising.

Key takeaways:

• Open appeal letters with a story about one person, not with the organization. Chad said donors respond to one person, such as a family that got a month of groceries, far more than to totals like the number of people served. Collect those stories in September so they are ready when the letter is written.

• Ask for one thing, specifically, and repeat it. Chad recommended one call to action, a specific amount for a specific purpose, repeated several times and always in the P.S., since readers skim to the P.S.

• Run the year-end campaign in sequence. The simple year-end campaign for small nonprofits Chad described runs a priming email series after the election, a mailed appeal the week after Thanksgiving, an email follow-up about ten days later, live calls to lapsed donors, and final emails on December 29 and 31.

• A QR code can lead to a short video and a donation form. Chad said his tests showed a range of about 8 to 27 percent more giving when the QR code opened a special message with the donate form directly below it.

Helping you help others

Every act of generosity starts here.

Empower your team to connect deeply and fundraise confidently.