Webinar

A case study in tripling fundraising results

Tammy Zonker, Chief Philanthropy Officer at The Children’s Center of Wayne County (Detroit), recently joined us for a webinar in which she guided us through a case study of a three-year philanthropy operations turnaround, which resulted in 300% growth in net contributions in just 36 months.

Learning objectives:

  • Assess a fundraising program's health before changing it, reviewing staff roles, donor perception, cost per dollar by channel, data quality and board participation.
  • Decide which fundraising events to keep or retire by comparing cost per dollar raised and the staff time each one takes.
  • Plan a multi-channel year-end campaign with segmented drops and suggested gift levels tied to each donor's last gift.
  • Write a stewardship report that pairs donor-level impact figures with a story, and frame a small-looking number so donors see its value.

Transcript:

Steven Shattuck: All right, Tammy. My watch just struck 1:00. Is it okay if I go ahead and kick us off officially?

Tammy Zonker: Let's do it.

Steven Shattuck: All right. Cool. Well, good afternoon, everyone, if you are on the East Coast and good morning if you're on the West Coast or somewhere in between. Thanks for joining us for today's Bloomerang webinar, "Operation Rubber Tree: A Case Study on Tripling Fundraising Results in Just 36 Months." My name is Steven Shattuck, and I'm the Chief Engagement Officer over here at Bloomerang, and I'll be moderating today's discussion, as always.

Just a couple of housekeeping items before we get started. I want to let you all know that we are recording this presentation. I'll be sending out that recording later today. If you have to leave early, or you want to watch the content later on, review it or share it with a friend, you will be able to do that. Have no fear.

Look for an email from me later this afternoon. If you don't get it for some reason, if it goes to spam, let me know. I'll send you the recording again, or you can look on our blog. We'll also post it on our blog in about a week. You'll also get the slides if you haven't already gotten them. We'll make sure you get all the goodies from today.

As you are listening today, please feel free to use the chat box right there on your webinar screen. Our guests and I will both see those for the next hour or so, and we're going to try to save some time for Q&A at the end. So do not be shy at all. We love to hear your questions and comments, and we'll try to answer just as many as we can before 2:00 Eastern. You can also follow along today on Twitter. You can use the hashtag #Bloomerang or our username @BloomerangTech.

If you have any trouble with the audio or the visuals here, these webinars are only as good as your own internet connection. One little trick we've found that works pretty well is to dial in by phone for audio. If you have any trouble with the computer audio, it's usually a little bit better by phone. So if you can do that and you don't mind, check out the ReadyTalk email that went out about an hour ago today. There's a phone number in it just for you.

If this is your first Bloomerang webinar, I want to say a special welcome to you. We do these webinars just about every Thursday. We have a great guest. Today is no different at all. But if you are not familiar with Bloomerang, our core business is donor management software. So if you are in the market for that, or if you just want to check us out and learn more, visit our website. You can even download a quick video demo and see the software in action.

But for now, I am really excited to introduce one of my favorite people. Tammy Zonker is joining us from beautiful Detroit. Hey, Tammy. How's it going?

Tammy Zonker: It's going great, Steven. Thanks for having me.

Steven Shattuck: Oh yeah. I would not miss this. I actually saw this presentation delivered live at a conference, and I told Tammy, "Tammy, you've got to come on Bloomerang and give this presentation, because it's so awesome."

If you guys don't know Tammy, you've got to know her. She is the President and Founder of Fundraising Transformed. She's a coach. She's a trainer. She has led many nonprofit teams to raising a ton of money. I think she's up to about $400 million raised through her work at nonprofits and her coaching business. In her practitioner role, she currently serves as the Chief Philanthropy Officer over at the Children's Center in Detroit, in addition to running her agency.

And if that wasn't enough to keep her busy, she also does webinars, speaks at tons of conferences and does private workshops. Tammy, I don't even know how you do all this and still get the crazy results you do through all your work. I'm glad you do. I'm going to pipe down, because you are obviously an expert and an awesome person, so I'm really excited for you to share this case study with us. So take it away, my friend.

Tammy Zonker: Awesome. Thank you, Steven. All right. So we are going to talk about Operation Rubber Tree, which was a case study of tripling philanthropy fundraising results in about three years at the Children's Center in Detroit. The first question I always get when people come on to a webinar or hear me speak live is, "Okay, why Operation Rubber Tree? What does that mean?"

The rubber tree is a really phenomenal, unique plant. It's a tree that grows incredibly rapidly. It grows to over 100 feet tall, and it's known to grow about two feet or more in a single year. That was what we were aiming to do at the Children's Center. We wanted to very rapidly grow our fundraising results.

Some of you may know the song "High Hopes." I won't sing it for you here, because Steven would cut me off and put me on mute. But the tune goes something like, "What makes that little old ant think he can move a rubber tree plant? Anyone knows an ant can't." And it goes on in the chorus, "But he has high hopes."

That was my very small but tiny team of development professionals at the Children's Center. That was our theme song. Who would believe that this small group could actually triple philanthropy in three years? But it was high hopes and a metrics-driven plan. So I'm going to walk you through how we pulled together the team, the tools we used and the strategies to accomplish just that.

But first I want to give you a little context about the Children's Center. The Children's Center is an amazing organization in the heart of Detroit, where we serve about 7,500 children and families each year. These are children who have experienced unimaginable abuse and neglect, or some of them come from perfectly loving homes but have a mental health or behavioral health issue, and it's only compounded by the fact that they live in extreme poverty.

So transformational work, amazing work, is happening there. We have over 300 employees and operate on about a $27 million budget. When I first came into the Children's Center as Chief Philanthropy Officer in June of 2012, they were raising just about $1 million, and it was almost all event-based. You all know what that means. That's the most labor-intensive way to raise money. So they were ripe for transformation.

Here's how the net numbers shook out. You can see that on the first little mound there, the little sapling. That's what I inherited. They were raising $1,017,000 net. When I say net, it means direct cost minus direct growth, minus direct cost, which does not include labor. In that first year, we increased it to just over $1.4 million, then $2.1 million, and by that third year, $2.5 million. We actually did raise over $3 million, but the way it landed at the very end of the year, it got pulled over into the next fiscal year. I guess you just have to take my word for that or pull the 990s.

Why was it so important? Why were we so aggressively pursuing fundraising growth? It was because we were on a burning platform, in a very vulnerable place. Between 2008 and 2011, the state of Michigan had cut more than $40 million from the mental health budget. The vast majority of that was in children's programs. Even though we were raising $1 million out of a $27 million budget, it was continuing to shrink, and there was such an enormous gap between what we were able to deliver in services to vulnerable children and what really needed to be delivered. The philanthropy absolutely had to fill the gap.

So, coming into the organization, I had done some training and consulting with the Children's Center previously. I absolutely knew the operations of the philanthropy department and knew what I was getting into. The first thing we did was what any of you who are gardeners would do when you come into a new garden plot. You assess the richness of the soil. What's the moisture? What's the drainage? How much sun does it get?

In the philanthropy area, you take a look at the equivalent. How are the staff? What's their reporting structure? What do our donors think of us? What's our cost per dollar rate for each of the fundraising channels we use? Our practices and our policies?

Of course, what's the quality of our data? Has it been entered consistently? Can we get good data out? This is one of the reasons I love Bloomerang so much. It sets you up for success in getting good data. Great system. What are your brand strengths? That's incredibly important to your fundraising results. And then how does the board, or how do committees, participate in philanthropy?

We really took a deep-dive assessment of all those areas. The areas I'm going to talk about today are the three bullets that are bold, the first three bullets. So that was the garden plot. Now you have to look at what tools you have to grow this garden. Of course, I'm a big believer in the Association of Fundraising Professionals. The first thing we did was get organizational membership so everyone on my team could participate in those monthly education sessions.

We had the software in place. We looked at the meeting cadence and the communication structure, and really asked how we could grow philanthropy strategically and thoughtfully. We put together a three-year budget and looked at root cause, or what we call smart numbers: activities we could do on a daily basis that we knew would drive results.

Then, of course, how are we going to report growth and net fundraising numbers, and what we call Beyond Cash. This was a really beautiful dashboard that looked at the internal health of your philanthropy area. It was created by the brilliant Peter Drury out in Seattle. He's given me permission to give you a little glimpse of it today as well.

When I first came in, I sat down with my team and asked: What are your proudest accomplishments with the organization? What are the things that are life-giving to you and part of your core accountabilities? What are the things that hold you back? What keeps you from performing at your absolute peak? We looked at the job descriptions and asked whether each one had clear, measurable expectations and key performance indicators. What metrics were we looking at, both at the team level and the individual level? What was our culture of accountability?

After talking with this amazing group of people, what I saw is that they were really passionate about helping children heal. They loved our donors. They were incredibly busy, but they weren't always effective. One of the key things I saw is that activity does not equal effectiveness. Everyone was trying to help each other out first and foremost, instead of focusing on their core accountabilities and the top three to five things they needed to accomplish each week.

So we redefined what accountability meant to our team, and we wrote a new description of it. For us, being accountable and in integrity meant doing what you said you were going to do, by when you said you were going to do it, or getting into communication the very moment you saw that you couldn't keep your word. So that may mean going back to me and saying, "Tammy, I promised you this information by Tuesday. I didn't anticipate these things happening. Would Wednesday at noon work for you?" And then getting agreement: "Yes, Wednesday is great. Thank you for getting in communication."

It also meant doing the work the way it was meant to be done, or better. No shortcuts that cost the organization, our team or the donor. And then really using checklists and things like that to keep us all on track and in integrity.

We also created a culture where it was okay to make mistakes. In fact, we encouraged it. We'd say, "I made the biggest mistake today. Come here, everybody. I want to tell you about it, and let's learn from it." We wanted to create a culture where it was okay to make mistakes, but it was important that we made new mistakes and used our old mistakes as a place to stand. There's a saying I've seen on social media a lot lately: "I don't win or lose. I either win or learn something." Something to that effect. That was what we wanted to create within our team.

Then we borrowed a meeting rhythm born out of the Rockefeller Habits, which is a book. Someone asked, "Hey, Mr. Rockefeller, richest man in the history of the United States, how did you do it? How are you so effective?" He had someone follow him around and identify what he did on a daily, weekly, quarterly and yearly basis that made him so effective.

That's been turned into a system. Here's the snapshot of that system. I'm going to start with the column on the far right. Once a year, I bring together my full development team, which we call the philanthropy team, for an annual all-day meeting. It starts with a good news check-in, which is really just a way to build trust. You share a piece of personal good news and a piece of professional good news, and we do that at every meeting.

We talk about our top three to five priorities for the week, but then we delve into what we want to accomplish this year. What are our one-year goals that roll up to our three-year goals, and what do we need to focus on each quarter to accomplish those things? Then once a quarter, we revisit those and set quarterly goals. We report on how we did in the past quarter. Again, that's the full team.

On a monthly basis, I get together with just my directors, and we focus on the operations, the fundraising and all the key elements of our development team. Then on a weekly basis, we have a full team meeting, with everyone on the team. Again, you can see the agenda.

Everyone on the team has an opportunity to submit agenda items. It keeps us in communication. It keeps us operating as a unit. It also helps us understand what's going on in our colleagues' world: What are their top three to five priorities that week? That helps me understand not only how I can support them, but also how to be sensitive to what's going on in their world as I make requests of them. This was a great tool for us. I hope you'll find some value in it too.

Out of all of that, here's what we found. There are seven truths out of Operation Rubber Tree. The first one is that Operation Rubber Tree was not for everyone. We originally had a team of five. We added two new positions, so it grew to a team of seven in that first year, but we had three resignations and two terminations.

Those terminations weren't necessarily legacy people. It was not "out with the old, in with the new." One of them was a bad hire. One was a hire who came in and then said, "Oh, this isn't for me after all. Everyone says their biggest challenge is volume management of work, but you guys are crazy." So every staff change, whether voluntary or involuntary, made us stronger.

Here's how the org chart looked when I first walked in. The Chief Development Officer role was the one I was stepping into, and they had one direct report: the Director of Development, who managed the events manager, the volunteer manager and administration, which included, of course, database management.

Within a year, I moved the Director of Development to Director of Individual Philanthropy, hired a Director of Corporate Philanthropy, and then created a new position called Director of Philanthropy Operations. This person could focus on making sure our events stayed on time and in budget, that gift recognition and acknowledgment letters went out within 72 hours, that those letters were changed with each campaign or at least every six months, and on things I find not that exciting, like coding the payables, getting them to finance and signing off on expense reports.

This person loves that stuff. She loves being the glue and the ringmaster of this three-ring circus. It's very life-giving to her. That freed me up to focus on major gifts and fundraising strategy. So it was really about looking at each individual's gifts and talents and how we could match them to roles that would empower them personally and the entire team. Now she manages all of the events, volunteerism and administration.

Then the next year, we as an organization decided to pursue a five-year contract to open a Head Start Academy. The person who became Head of School had been Director of Program Enrichment. She was running over 120 events a year focused on the children and families we serve: Homework Mondays and Wednesdays, monthly birthday parties, monthly game nights, summer day camp, foster parent appreciation dinners.

When she became Head of School, all of those accountabilities rolled up to philanthropy, with the thought that volunteers could help run them. So you can see how the org chart changed. The positions in deep burgundy are fundraising accountabilities. The positions in green are focused on volunteerism and enrichment programming. On the far right, the events manager and the administrative person split their time between those accountabilities. Our team grew rapidly, but so did our non-fundraising accountabilities.

As part of all of this, we did a deep dive into job descriptions, identifying core accountabilities and specific, measurable performance expectations. Here's a snapshot of the job description for the Director of Individual Philanthropy. They were going to focus on donors giving $1,000 a year up to $5,000 a year. We had goals around growing the giving society we call the Village of Giving by at least 10% annually. We had goals around retention.

It was very specific and very metrics-driven. At any point in time, this individual knows: Am I winning? Am I on track, or am I behind? If we were behind, we could strategize how to get ahead. If we were on track, we'd make sure to finish strong. If we were ahead, we celebrated and looked at which activities were driving that excellent performance, so we could replicate them on other levels of our team.

We did the same thing for the Director of Corporate Philanthropy. We charged both of those roles, corporate and individual philanthropy, with spending 70% of their time in the community, in front of donors, not in the office. Although we have staff donors, the majority of our donors are not in the office. Let's get out. Let's meet with them. Let's love them up and let them know how their gifts are making a difference.

Regina asked a question: "How do you specifically fundraise knowing that the monies are needed to build out the team?"

I was very fortunate that even in the interview and the preliminary conversations before taking on this role, I talked with the CEO, and we agreed that if we were going to aggressively grow fundraising results, it would require an investment. It would require an investment of staff and tools, and we would need some time to ramp up. So you've got to spend some money to make some money. Fortunately, I had a CEO who was bought into that, and a very supportive executive committee of the board as well.

Then, for that new position we created, the Director of Philanthropy Operations, you can see very specific expectations. We want those acknowledgment letters going out the door accurately within 72 hours. I'm expecting monthly reconciliations with the finance department. I'm expecting that we manage our spend to how we budgeted our expenses. All of that good stewardship, all of that running a tight ship, would inspire donor confidence and gratitude and affinity, and we would have an 85% greater pledge fulfillment rate.

Then here's my role. I held myself to the same level of accountability. I needed to spend a specific amount of time out in the community. For me, that's 20% of my time with the major gift portfolio I manage. I needed to have 10 or 12 face-to-face visits a month with donors. Very specific accountabilities. I think that was key. Everyone knew the unique value they bring to the team, and they were empowered to focus on that accountability and play in their wheelhouse.

Then we took a look at effectiveness. We're raising about $1 million a year in events. We're raising some amount in non-event-based fundraising. How effective and efficient are we in that realm? So we did a deep dive into all of that.

The first thing we did was look at every event. I think it was a seven- or eight-year history, and we calculated the cost per dollar raised for each event. We also looked at the indirect time staff put into those events, which didn't get calculated into the cost per dollar, so we could see which events were super labor-intensive and which ones were manageable.

Then we asked ourselves some questions. Does this particular event bring guests closer to our mission, or is it just a fun party? Is there a post-event call to action? Are we staying at that $0.50 cost per dollar raised, or in that range? Is there any way to increase revenue without fatiguing the donor? Is there any way to reduce our cost without reducing the guest experience? Could we expand the audience? Could we add a raffle? Should we take away valet? Those kinds of questions.

Here is that eight-year analysis of our three signature events. The top event is the gala, which is associated with the Detroit International Auto Show. It's a big night in Detroit, where thousands and thousands of people come to a car show at our convention center, where all the big manufacturers debut new models and concept cars. So we have a gala that starts before that event, shuttles people to the car show, and brings them back for a big party, with dancing and dinner.

We calculated how many guests attended year over year, what the total sponsorship was year over year, ticket sales, gross revenue, expenses, net revenue and cost per dollar raised. We even did a deeper dive on expenses. Of the $250,000 we spent to raise $508,000, how much was venue? How much was décor? How much was food and beverage? That gives us some muscle around what works, what didn't, and how we can work smart and plan this event well.

One of the events that really caught my eye was the year we kept our cost per dollar raised under 40 cents for this big gala with an open bar. The theme that year was Under the Big Top. That was probably the only time you can charge $300 per person to come to a gala where you serve hot dogs and cotton candy with a circus theme. So we began to distinguish which types of themes cost us more money and which were most cost-effective. Our Power of Possibilities Breakfast is phenomenal. We typically spend less than 10 cents to raise $1.00.

Detroit Uncorked is an event where we had an aha moment. It cost us about 48 cents to raise $1.00, but we never could really scale it. In its very best year, we netted just under $80,000. More likely we raised $40,000 or $50,000 most years. Then we split that with the Detroit Wine Organization, which helped us put on the event. The only difference was they had one staff member, and I was putting multiple staff members on it.

So it really was costly once you factored in the more significant indirect costs we put into it. We made the decision collectively to retire that event. The Detroit Wine Organization now does an event with Gleaners Food Bank, and it really works for them. Food and beverage go much better than beverage and children anyway.

Okay. I see a few more questions coming in. We're going to do more Q&A at the end, so hold some of those questions. But the point is, you really have to dissect your events and look at what is truly working and where you can make changes. Or truth number two: do I need to retire this event? That's what we learned.

Sometimes you need to prune fundraising events that have a low return on investment. That sounds so easy to do, but as you retire an event, you have to reach out to board members or donors who especially love those events and walk them through why you had to retire it. If you're going to rapidly raise money and double or triple the amount of funds you're raising, you have to focus on the things that give you the best return on investment.

Okay. Now we're going to talk about the year-end campaign. In 2010, the Children's Center netted 97 cents from its campaign. We teased, "That was not a fundraiser." In 2011, they actually lost $2,000. It cost more to produce, to get postage on it and to deliver it than it raised.

The very first campaign we did in 2012 netted over $72,000. The next year, we increased it to $90,000. That campaign in 2013 won the 2014 Fundraising Success Magazine Campaign of the Year for a large organization and multi-channel campaign. I'm going to share a little about that and give you some ideas of why it was so innovative, and hopefully ideas you can take and apply to your own campaign as we move into year end. I know you're still thinking, "Please, spring, be here," but we start planning the fall campaign in summer, so it's not that far away.

In 2014, we increased that year-end campaign to $235,000. The big leverage point was an $85,000 match gift in honor of the Children's Center's 85th anniversary. Then in 2015, we netted just over $140,000. So again, you can see we're taking each fundraising channel and doing a deep dive, dissecting what works, what doesn't and how we can squeeze and maximize for optimal results. Why did that campaign win Fundraising Success Magazine Campaign of the Year?

Well, in the prior years, we dissected why they didn't work. First, it was direct mail only. There was no online element and no social media element, and there were lots of mixed messages. We threw in descriptions and teasers about over 30 different programs. We didn't have impact statements or suggested giving levels on the solicitation based on the donor's last gift. There was no segmentation or personalization. It was the proverbial "Dear Friend" appeal.

It went in a plain white envelope. We all know from Tom Ahern and Jeff Brooks and all the great direct mail gurus that getting the envelope opened is the first main hurdle. It was a single drop, meaning one mailing, with no follow-up mailings and no sequence of mailings in that solicitation cycle.

There was also no custom landing page. If it drove you back to our website to make an online gift, it took you to the homepage, which is like sending a child with attention deficit disorder into a toy store. So many things to look at, shiny object syndrome. So we're big believers in custom landing pages.

Here's the cover of Fundraising Success Magazine the year we won. You'll see that yellow circle, which was the anchor of that whole campaign. Here's some of the inside baseball. We had budgeted to raise $70,000. Our goal was to renew and upgrade current donors, and to renew recently lapsed donors, meaning those who hadn't given in the last two years. But we also noticed our donor base was aging. We had a much older donor base. We wanted to grow the next generation of philanthropists, so we had a specific strategy to engage younger people: millennials, Gen Xers and Gen Ys.

Here's the math, the analytics behind what we actually raised, who we mailed to and the average gift size. This campaign addressed all the issues from the previous campaign. It was truly multi-channel: direct mail, email and social media. We even did some live, in-person pop-up events and contests. I say "we" because I co-created this campaign with Trent Thompson, who is a contractor to the Children's Center. We collaborated, and he drove the strategy. It included some pretty innovative things.

There were three segments, so three solicitation drops, whether in the mail or online. If you didn't give to the first one in early November, you got the second one in late November or early December. If you didn't give to the second one, you got the third one, which landed right after Christmas but before New Year's.

We knew that consistency in messaging and campaign imagery increases donor confidence and trust, so we pulled the thread through the entire campaign. We had very specific variable print strategies. If you had been a donor who gave $200 last year, the solicitation you received came with your first name, and the three suggested giving levels started at $200, $275 and $325, to help you stretch from your prior year's gift.

Each of those levels had impact statements attached. "$200 will do this." The whole essence of this campaign, and really all of our work, is clear, simple, human messaging.

Then we took a look at grants. In 2011–2012, when grants reported to finance, they raised $27,000. The next year, $36,000. Then we rolled the grant management process up into the philanthropy area, and you can see we steadily increased the amount we raised through grants. I think that's largely because the grant writer felt part of a team with a culture of philanthropy. The way we engaged with one another, with accountability, keeping our word and the communication structure, fostered success.

We were also able to build and scale our major gifts program. You can see that one sorority gave us $80,000. The next year, we increased that to $100,000. That was one donor. Then in 2012 and beyond, we engaged multiple individuals in our major gift program. So how did that start? How did we ramp it up?

I'm going to pause for a second, because JC asked a question about the multi-channel campaign, and it was: "What type of contest?"

I mentioned that we did some in-person pop-up dinners and contests to engage millennials. The contest was what we called the Yellow Coaster Contest. We had yellow coasters produced with campaign messaging, like "Getting Detroit back on its feet starts with baby steps. Support the Children's Center." And "Want to see your investment grow? Invest in a child." Clever campaign messaging printed on disposable cardboard coasters, the kind you use four or five times and then discard.

We produced five or six of these. We went to area restaurants, pubs and coffee houses, the places where young people hang out, the really cool places, and asked if they would put these coasters out for the month of December.

We launched the campaign on social media and encouraged people to go to those restaurants. If they took a picture with their smartphone of the coaster, tagged the name of the campaign, which I think was the Heal Children, Heal Detroit campaign, and posted it on Facebook, Instagram or Twitter, they were entered into a contest to win a gift card from one of the restaurants. The restaurants also donated some $25 and $50 gift cards.

It was great fun, and it really got the Children's Center on the radar of a lot of these young people. They came in for tours. We had a text-to-give option. That wasn't hugely successful, but some of them did text to give. But they came to learn more, started volunteering, and did drives for us, whether school supply drives, gently used clothing drives or hygiene product drives. It was a way to engage them.

Now, back to major gifts. How did we grow them? We sat down and met with our major donors. In 2012, when I came in, a major donor was anyone giving $1,000 or more. We sat down with them and asked questions like: What do you want to accomplish with your philanthropy? What are some of your proudest moments with the Children's Center? What are some of your biggest regrets or disappointments? What are some of your fondest dreams? When it comes to nonprofits, who does it best, and why? What's the most meaningful gift you've ever made, and why was that?

We really began to build the relationship. We found that yes, they were giving $1,000 and $5,000 gifts, but so many of them had great capacity to give even more, and they did, through cultivation, good old-fashioned major gift engagement, solicitation, recognition, stewardship and getting to know them better and better over time. They understood how their gifts were making a difference, and we asked what the next big needs were.

What more do our children and families need to heal, to grow and to become the great people they were born to be? That's what our donors wanted to do. They wanted to help the kids.

Then we began building the infrastructure to support major gifts. We developed a strategy, looking at donor personas and mapping them to who was really giving to us. We developed a major gift investment menu, so when someone asks, "What do you need?" we have options documented with prices and impact statements. We started proactively doing stewardship reports for everyone giving at those higher levels, whether they requested them or not.

Making time to meet with donors was key. I took a page from the brilliant Amy Eisenstein. If you know Amy, she does amazing work helping smaller nonprofits get into major gifts. One of her books, "50 Asks in 50 Weeks," talks about having the discipline to block out a day a week to work on major gifts.

So that's what I did. I called it Major Gift Wednesday. Sometimes it got compromised, but most of the time I tried, tried, tried to focus on major gifts on Wednesdays. The thing with being so event-driven is that events are urgent. There's always something that has to be done because you have an event date. Major gifts are important, but not necessarily urgent, so they always get pushed to the back seat. Having the discipline to commit a specific amount of time, whether that's two half-days a week or a full day a week, will be incredible for your organization. It was one of the things that helped us scale our major gifts program rapidly.

Then creating donor experiences. Gone are the days when donors want the red carpet and white glove treatment. They want to feel something real. Whether that's bringing them into program delivery, we're mental health. We're governed by HIPAA and all kinds of confidentiality issues. Some of you are as well.

For us, it was finding the areas where HIPAA was not a concern. That included the monthly birthday party for every child who received services and had a birthday that month, Art Enrichment Night, or our foster care graduation for the foster kids graduating from high school that year. Something where they could meet the families, feel the mission and feel related to the work being done.

We had a long list of donor experiences, from summer day camp to reading to kids to participating in a life-skills class. But one of the key ways people feel our work is by coming through a tour. If you're interested in the Children's Center tour, you can Google the Children's Center of Wayne County or the Children's Center in Detroit and the phrase "take the tour." It will take you to a four-minute trailer that shows a peek at our full one-hour tour. That leads us to truth number three, which is that all good things begin with mission and stories, real live experiences.

Then, measuring what matters: smart numbers, reporting both gross and net contributions, and what Peter Drury calls Beyond Cash metrics. I'm going to walk you through those. For my externally facing people on my team, including myself, we measure face-to-face visits, handwritten notes, outreach calls and mission tours. Each of us has monthly goals for face-to-face engagement or quality contacts that include one of these four things.

For it to qualify as a quality contact, it has to meet one or more of these criteria. It has to leave the donor feeling appreciated and more connected to our work, increase their knowledge of our work or the need, or report the impact or outcome of their contribution. And if it's not in the database, it doesn't count.

So running into a donor at the grocery store and having a nice little chat doesn't count, unless it accomplishes one or more of those three criteria. And it has to be in the database, including for me.

Here's how we reported revenue. We did a year-over-year comparison. Across the top, you can see all of our events, and all of our non-event-based fundraising initiatives, so we could break down where our growth was. Over those three years, we went from about $910,000 to $1.2 million in events. That was modest growth. The real growth came in non-event-based fundraising.

Then we looked at Peter Drury's tool, the Beyond Cash dashboard, which measures donor retention, what he calls the engagement index, median gift value, the non-ask ratio, new donor counts, brand strength and how many people are in a future pledge. I liken it to going to the doctor. You can walk in looking perfectly fit and healthy, with rosy cheeks and a trim waistline. To me, that's your revenue dashboard. You look healthy. You're doing great.

But then the doctor checks your pulse and does a blood test, and you have high blood pressure and anxiety. That's your dashboard's internal health. You could be raising lots of money by acquiring new donors, and still have a hole in your bucket. Your donor retention rate is through the floor. That's not very healthy. This is a nice way to look at the outside of your fundraising and the inside of your fundraising operations, to make sure you're doing a good job.

If you're interested in the Rockefeller Habits dashboard, the job descriptions or Peter's materials, I can send you a link to a Dropbox. Just email me or let me know, and I'd be happy to share any of those tools. The metrics shine a bright light on all of it. That was truth number four.

Truth number five: there will be prickly issues. Board confidence, staff resilience, the culture of scarcity. When I sat down with our program staff at the beginning and said, "We're going to start a major gifts program. What do you need?" the answer was, "We need granola bars and bus tickets." They were serious. Families show up hungry for their appointments, and transportation is a big problem. We need bus tickets to get our children and families even into services. Okay, that's a place to start. So expect scarcity and lots of prickly issues along the way, and be prepared to address them.

Truth number six: you're going to get dirty. This was a big, hairy, audacious goal to triple philanthropy in three years. It was a lot of hard work. It was exciting, but it was dirty work, and a lot of it. An old friend of mine used to say it's like picking up a rock. You're moving rocks. But what lives under a rock? There's some pretty icky stuff under there. You're going to have to deal with some icky stuff and get a little dirty.

Truth number seven: it will all be worth it. The secret to success was having high hopes, ambition and a belief that it could be done. Then a metrics-driven plan. Without a plan, it just will not happen.

Here's the summary of our seven truths from Operation Rubber Tree, tripling fundraising results in three years. It was pretty awesome. We learned a lot. Now it's, what have you done for me lately? What's the next big thing? Stay tuned for that. We're definitely working on the next big thing at the Children's Center.

But I'd love to take some questions. We have about ten minutes. Steven, I'm going to toss it back to you for Q&A.

Steven Shattuck: All right. Man, that was awesome. I told you all it was going to be a good one, and Tammy delivered, no doubt about it. Tammy, you touched on so many different things, and I want to talk to you for 12 hours about all of them, but we only have ten minutes. We're going to get everyone the slides and the recording, so check your email later today. If we don't get to your question, Tammy, is it okay if people reach out to you, tweet you, all that good stuff?

Tammy Zonker: Of course. I'd love it.

Steven Shattuck: Yes, please do that. I know you answered a few questions as you went along, but we've got a lot here. I'll roll through them. A lot of people, Tammy, asked about being a small, one-person shop. How can they replicate some of this success? Obviously, you had a big team and a big budget, but any advice for those one-, two-, or three-person shops?

Tammy Zonker: For sure. The first thing is to start with what you have. Before you start a new initiative, look at how you can maximize what you're already doing, either to raise more money or to do it more efficiently, to free up time and resources for the next big initiative. Then identify that you don't have to do this all at once. You can eat that elephant one bite at a time. Say, "I'm going to take on major gifts next," or, "I'm going to transform my year-end campaign next." Do it at a pace that works for the resources you have.

Steven Shattuck: Makes sense. Tammy, I know you touched on this a little, but a few people asked about buy-in. You made new hires, you created new positions, and you cut events, which is something people had relied on. How did you get buy-in from the board and from people higher up in the organization? What was your strategy?

Tammy Zonker: I was very fortunate, because I had part of this conversation before I agreed to take the position. If you're serious about this, you're going to need to spend some money. But not everyone has that luxury. You're thinking, "Hey, I already have this job." The first thing is that every move we made, I talked about the return on investment. If we retired Detroit Uncorked, where would we redirect those resources, and how much more would we raise?

If we added the Director of Philanthropy Operations, that would take things off my plate as Chief Philanthropy Officer and free me up to do major gifts. In that role, I'd commit to raising a certain amount of dollars. So every expense had a return on investment, even if it wasn't a direct fundraising position. The Director of Philanthropy Operations doesn't raise money, but the work she does frees me or someone else up to raise more money. So it was always a return-on-investment conversation.

Steven Shattuck: Board members love that ROI topic, don't they?

Tammy Zonker: They do. They light up.

Steven Shattuck: Tammy, you... go ahead.

Tammy Zonker: Well, when I put forth my very first budget, which showed a 30% increase in fundraising, my board chair at the time was an actuary. He said, "Tammy, that's highly improbable." Which, of course, he would. It is highly improbable. But we had a plan. It wasn't "space-based fundraising": put a number up there and pray. We had a plan. We knew which fundraising channel we were going to focus on and what the predictable ROI would be.

Steven Shattuck: I love it. Tammy, could you elaborate on the concept of a stewardship report? A lot of people asked what that is. I think it was a new concept to some of the listeners today.

Tammy Zonker: Yes. It's similar to what you provide a foundation after they've given you a grant. We adapted it and made it a little simpler for individual donors. For example, I had a donor giving $20,000 a year to our emergency crisis care center. I prepared a report that said, "Hey, last year we had 900 children come through the crisis care center. These are children who, after hours, over 70% of them are presenting with homicidal or suicidal ideations. They're threatening to harm themselves or others."

"If we don't have the service, they end up at the hospital emergency room, which is not equipped for psychiatric crisis. I want you to know that of those 900 kids, 76% were de-escalated. They were able to be calmed down, to address the issue, maybe address their medications, and get back home where they're safe and sound. Your gift helped 14 of those 900 children."

I remember one donor who was so intrigued by it, but when I said 14 of 900, her shoulders slumped. She was disappointed. It seemed like a small number for $20,000. I'm very good at reading people's body language. I said, "Listen, [donor name], 14 may sound like a small number, but you have to remember, this might have been the worst day of their life."

Steven Shattuck: Right.

Tammy Zonker: "You should be incredibly proud of 14." So that was essentially a stewardship report: "Here's what your gifts accomplished, and here's the big picture as well." It was in writing. It had stats and a story. The perfect scenario is when you can pair it with a tour. In the case of [donor name], we did a tour of the crisis care center.

Steven Shattuck: Love it.

Tammy Zonker: And of course, a great story of a child. Yeah.

Steven Shattuck: Well, Tammy, we're about out of time. I know we didn't get to nearly all of the questions. If we didn't answer yours, I'm sorry. We're about two minutes away, and I want to give Tammy the last word. Please email her. She's obviously a wealth of knowledge, and I'm sure she'd be glad to offer advice on your specific issues. Tammy, this was so awesome. I'm so glad we had you on. Thanks for spending an hour with us.

Tammy Zonker: My pleasure. I would love to answer any questions we didn't get to. Just send me an email, or if you're interested in additional resources, send me your address and I'll send you a link to a Dropbox.

Steven Shattuck: Very cool.

Tammy Zonker: Steven, thank you. This is such a great service you provide to all of us, and to all these great speakers with so much information. I listen and sign up for your webinars all the time. So thank you.

Steven Shattuck: Aw, thanks. I love doing it. It's an easy part of my job, but I love it. Speaking of the webinar series, we're taking next week off, but we're back two weeks from today. Vanessa Chase is going to join us to talk about fundraising copywriting. It's going to be a great one, Thursday, March 23rd. If you struggle with writing appeals or newsletters, don't miss it. Vanessa is super smart, and you'll enjoy it as much as you enjoyed Tammy. Thanks to all of you for taking an hour out of your day. I know it's a busy time of year. Maybe event season is heating up for you.

Look for an email from me with the slides and the recording. And do reach out to Tammy if you want any of those resources or job descriptions. I kind of want to see those job descriptions myself, so don't be shy about asking. Thanks. Have a great rest of your afternoon, and have a good weekend. Hopefully we'll see you in a couple of weeks for another webinar. We'll call it a day there. Take care.

‍

Key takeaways:

  • This nonprofit fundraising case study starts with an assessment, not a new campaign. Tammy reviewed staff, donor views, cost per dollar, data quality and board participation before changing anything.
  • Judge each event by its cost per dollar raised. Her team reviewed eight years of event data and retired Detroit Uncorked, which cost about 48 cents per dollar raised and could not be scaled.
  • Build the year-end campaign around segments and several channels. The campaign grew from netting $72,000 in its first year to $235,000 two years later, with mail, email and social media, three drops and gift amounts based on each donor's last gift.
  • Measure internal health alongside revenue. Tammy's Beyond Cash dashboard tracks donor retention, median gift value and future pledges, so a team can see problems that revenue totals hide.
Helping you help others

Every act of generosity starts here.

Empower your team to connect deeply and fundraise confidently.